Alphabet shares fell hard on Wednesday after Apple’s Eddy Cue told a US courtroom that Google searches on Apple’s Safari browser declined in April – the first such drop – as users increasingly turn to AI tools like ChatGPT and Perplexity.
The stock recovered some ground after Google said search volumes are still growing, and multiple analysts claimed the sell-off looked overdone.
They suggest Apple may have reason to downplay Google’s dominance, given the Department of Justice is scrutinising their search partnership, which reportedly saw Google pay Apple $20 billion in 2022.
Besides, Google still owns YouTube, Android, Google Cloud and Waymo – it’s not a one-trick search pony.
‘No long-term commitments to anything’ – the silent slowdown of Ireland’s economy
UCC professor launches support service for doctors suffering from exhaustion and burnout
Counting the cost of Donald Trump’s attack on American science
CIÉ staff end 17-year wait for pension rise and Irish consumers’ love affair with US fast food
Still, there are obvious reasons to be cautious. High-profile technology analyst Gene Munster called it the “beginning of the decline”, saying that search “is in the very early stages of a seismic change that investors haven’t fully factored into current valuation”.
If users bypass search in favour of AI assistants, monetisation becomes trickier – conversational answers don’t serve ads like ranked links do.
The structural threat is real. Alphabet’s valuation has already come down. Its price-earnings ratio is now 18, well below the 10-year average of 28.
Investors are pricing in AI-related disruption, though not a full-blown collapse of the search business. For bulls, it’s a bargain. For bears, it’s just the beginning of a long re-rating.
