Man jailed for 24 years over manslaughter of Irish woman in New York Irish pub

Marcin Pieciak sent to prison over the killing of Longford woman Sarah McNally in an attack at bar in Queens in March 2024

Longford woman Sarah McNally was killed in an attack by her boyfriend Marcin Pieciak at the New York Irish pub where she worked in March 2024. Photograph: rip.ie
Longford woman Sarah McNally was killed in an attack by her boyfriend Marcin Pieciak at the New York Irish pub where she worked in March 2024. Photograph: rip.ie

A US court has handed a 24-year prison sentence to a man for the manslaughter last year of Longford woman Sarah McNally in an Irish pub in New York city.

Marcin Pieciak, a 38-year-old man from Glendale, Queens, had initially been charged with murder, but a subsequent plea deal between legal teams on opposing sides resulted in a manslaughter verdict.

Sarah McNally, a 41-year-old woman originally from Co Longford, had been living in New York for about 10 years at the time of her death.

She had been working a bartending shift at The Ceili House, a since-closed Irish bar in the Queens neighbourhood, Maspeth, on March 30th, 2024, when Pieciak arrived armed with two knives and attacked her.

She was subsequently stabbed 19 times, suffering extensive injuries, including a severed spinal cord and damage to her carotid artery. She died shortly after being admitted to nearby Elmhurst Hospital.

Pieciak, after the attack, proceeded to injure himself with a knife after being tackled by a patron at the bar, who prevented his escape. He later disarmed and arrested by police officers at the scene.

Appearing before Justice Ushir Pandit-Durant in New York on Friday morning, Pieciak reaffirmed his guilt and accepted his sentence, claiming to the court that he had no explanation for the crime he had committed.

In remarks directed at Ms McNally’s extended family in Ireland, he said: “Unfortunately, I don’t have any answers. I’ve been thinking about her every day and night, about Sarah. I have no answers.

“I know it’s too early now, but I hope one day you will forgive me,” he added.

Marcin Pieciak (centre) who was sentenced to 24 years in prison for the manslaughter of Longford woman Sarah McNally in The Céilí House Irish pub in Queens, New York in 2024. Standing next to Pieciak's left is his attorney Garnett Sullivan.
Marcin Pieciak (centre) who was sentenced to 24 years in prison for the manslaughter of Longford woman Sarah McNally in The Céilí House Irish pub in Queens, New York in 2024. Standing next to Pieciak's left is his attorney Garnett Sullivan.

Assistant District Attorney Gabriel Reale, acting on behalf of the McNally family, read out a victim impact statement, detailing Sarah’s particularly close relationship with her mother Dorrie and her love of animals and music.

He also spoke about how her parents Dorrie and Des had lost their only child, and relatives their eldest cousin and niece.

“Losing Sarah in the circumstances we did, has been the most painful, gut-wrenching thing we have ever experienced, and not something we will ever get over,” the family said in the statement.

  • Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date

  • Sign up for push alerts to get the best breaking news, analysis and comment delivered directly to your phone

  • Listen to In The News podcast daily for a deep dive on the stories that matter