The client rosters of Swiss banks are among the world's most closely guarded secrets, protecting the identities of some of the planet's richest people and clues into how they accumulated their fortunes. Now, an extraordinary leak of data from Credit Suisse is exposing how the bank held hundreds of millions of dollars for heads of state, intelligence officials, sanctioned businessmen and human rights abusers, among many others.
A self-described whistleblower leaked data on more than 18,000 bank accounts, collectively holding more than $100 billion (€88bn), to the German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung. The newspaper shared the data with a nonprofit journalism group, the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project, and 46 other news organisations around the world.
The data covers accounts that were open from the 1940s until well into the 2010s, but not the bank's current operations. Among the people listed as holding amounts worth millions of dollars in Credit Suisse accounts were King Abdullah II of Jordan and the two sons of former Egyptian strongman Hosni Mubarak. Other account holders included sons of a Pakistani intelligence chief who helped funnel billions of dollars from the United States and other countries to the mujahedeen in Afghanistan in the 1980s and Venezuelan officials ensnared in a long-running corruption scandal.
The leak shows that Credit Suisse opened accounts for and continued to serve not only the ultra-wealthy but also people whose problematic backgrounds would have been obvious to anyone who ran their names through a search engine. Swiss banks have long faced legal prohibitions on taking money linked to criminal activity, said Daniel Thelesklaf, the former head of Switzerland's anti-money laundering agency. But, he said, the law generally hasn't been enforced.
Candice Sun, a spokeswoman for the bank, said in a statement that "Credit Suisse strongly rejects the allegations and inferences about the bank's purported business practices". She said many of the accounts in the leak date back decades to "a time where laws, practices and expectations of financial institutions were very different from where they are now".
Ms Sun said that while Credit Suisse can’t comment on specific clients, many of the accounts identified in the leaked database have already been closed. “Of the remaining active accounts, we are comfortable that appropriate due diligence, reviews and other control-related steps were taken, including pending account closures,” she said.
Ms Sun added that the leak appears to be part of “a concerted effort to discredit the bank and the Swiss financial marketplace, which has undergone significant changes over the last several years”.
The leak follows the so-called Panama Papers in 2016, the Paradise Papers in 2017 and the Pandora Papers last year. They all shed light on the secretive workings of banks, law firms and offshore financial-services providers that allow wealthy people and institutions – including those accused of crimes – to move huge sums of money, largely outside the purview of tax collectors or law enforcement.
The new disclosures are likely to intensify legal and political scrutiny of the Swiss banking industry and, in particular, Credit Suisse. The bank is already reeling from the abrupt ousting of its two top executives. With its ironclad bank-secrecy laws, Switzerland has long been a haven for people who are looking to hide money. In the past decade, that has made the country's largest banks – especially its two giants, Credit Suisse and UBS – a target for authorities in the US and elsewhere who are trying to crack down on tax evasion, money laundering and other crimes.
In 2014, Credit Suisse pleaded guilty to conspiring to help Americans file false tax returns and agreed to pay fines, penalties and restitution totaling $2.6 billion. Three years later, the bank paid the US Justice Department $5.3 billion to settle allegations about its marketing of mortgage-backed securities. Last autumn, it agreed to pay $475 million to US and British authorities to resolve an investigation into a kickback and bribery scheme in Mozambique. And this month, a trial got underway in Switzerland in which Credit Suisse is accused of allowing drug traffickers to launder millions of euros through the bank.
The US Justice Department and the Senate finance committee are also looking into whether US citizens continue to hold undeclared accounts at the bank. Several former Credit Suisse employees told federal prosecutors late last year that the bank continued to hide hundreds of millions of dollars for clients long after its 2014 guilty plea, according to a whistleblower lawsuit filed last year by a former bank official and a lawyer for other former employees.
The suit was dismissed after the Justice Department said it “threatens to interfere with ongoing discussions with Credit Suisse” about dealing with Swiss bank accounts held by US citizens.
The media consortium has nicknamed the latest leak “Suisse Secrets”. Of the more than 18,000 bank accounts involved, roughly 100 US citizens held accounts, but none are public figures.
Among the biggest revelations is that Credit Suisse continued to do business with customers even after bank officials flagged suspicious activity involving their finances. One account holder was Venezuela's former vice minister of energy, Nervis Villalobos. Employees in Credit Suisse's compliance department had reason to be wary of doing business with him. The bank had a 2008 report by an outside due-diligence firm detailing corruption allegations involving Mr Villalobos and Venezuela's state-owned oil company, Petroleos de Venezuela, according to a Spanish police report obtained by the media consortium.
Credit Suisse nonetheless opened an account for him in 2011, the leaked bank data shows. The account, which was closed in 2013, held as much as $10 million. Lawyers for Mr Villalobos, who was criminally charged in the US in 2017, didn’t respond to requests for comment.
All told, there were 25 Credit Suisse accounts, containing a total of about $270 million, that belonged to people accused of being involved in a wide-ranging conspiracy surrounding Venezuela’s oil company. The accounts remained open after the scandal started to become public, but were closed by the time criminal charges were filed.
The bank also kept accounts open for a Zimbabwean businessman who was sanctioned by US and European authorities for his ties to the government of the country's long-time president, Robert Mugabe. The accounts stayed open for several months after the sanctions were imposed.
Middle East officials
The leaked bank information included many accounts linked to government officials across the Middle East and beyond. The data raises questions about how public officials and their relatives accumulated vast fortunes in a region rife with corruption.
The sons of former president Hosni Mubarak of Egypt, Alaa and Gamal Mubarak, held a total of six accounts at various points, including one in 2003 that was worth $196 million. In a statement to The New York Times, the Mubaraks' lawyers declined to comment about specific accounts but said the suggestion that any of the Mubaraks' assets had been "tainted by any illegality or a result of any favouritism or use of influence" would be "both unfounded and defamatory".
Any assets they held, the statement said, were from their "successful professional business activities". King Abdullah II of Jordan, one of the few officials in the leaks who remains in power, had six accounts, including one whose balance exceeded $224 million. Jordan's Royal Hashemite Court said in a statement that there had been no "unlawful or improper conduct" in relation to the bank accounts. They held portions of the king's private wealth, which was used for personal expenses, royal projects to help Jordanians and the maintenance of Islamic holy sites in Jerusalem, of which he is the custodian.
Senior intelligence officials and their offspring from several countries that cooperated with the US in the war on terrorism also had money stashed at Credit Suisse. As the head of the Pakistani intelligence agency, General Akhtar Abdur Rahman Khan helped funnel billions of dollars in cash and other aid from the US and other countries to the mujahedeen in Afghanistan to support their fight against the Soviet Union.
In 1985, the same year US president Ronald Reagan called for more oversight of the aid going into Afghanistan, an account was opened in the name of three of Khan's sons. The general never faced charges of stealing aid money. Years later, the account would grow to hold $3.7 million, the leaked records show.
Two of the general's sons, Akbar and Haroon Khan, did not respond to requests for comment from the reporting project. In a text message, a third son, Ghazi Khan, called information about the accounts "not correct," adding that "the content is conjectural".
In 2003, the year the US invaded Iraq to topple Saddam Hussein, Saad Kheir, the head of Jordan's intelligence agency, opened an account that would eventually hold $21.6 million. The account was closed after Kheir's death in 2009. The family of Mubarak's long-serving and brutal spymaster, Omar Suleiman, had an account, too. Suleiman died in 2012. Efforts by the reporting project to reach his family were unsuccessful.
The leaked records were provided to Germany’s Süddeutsche Zeitung more than a year ago by an unidentified whistleblower. Of the dozens of news organisations collaborating on the project, none were based in Switzerland, where a 2015 law restricted journalists from writing articles based on internal bank data.
The whistleblower said in a statement to the media consortium that Swiss bank-secrecy laws were “immoral”. “The pretext of protecting financial privacy is merely a fig leaf covering the shameful role of Swiss banks as collaborators of tax evaders,” the whistleblower said. - New York Times