Colorado governor urges toned-down abortion debate after clinic rampage

Mike Huckabee draws direct parallel between attack on clinic and abortion

Mourners attend a candlelight vigil for Garrett Swasey, a  police officer killed in the Planned Parenthood shooting. Photograph: Nick Cote/The New York Times

Mourners attend a candlelight vigil for Garrett Swasey, a police officer killed in the Planned Parenthood shooting. Photograph: Nick Cote/The New York Times


The attack at a Colorado Planned Parenthood clinic that killed a police officer and two other people suggests that both sides of the abortion debate in the United States need to “tone down the rhetoric”, according to the state governor.

John Hickenlooper spoke the morning after unnamed law enforcement authorities told NBC News and other media that the suspected gunman had muttered “no more baby parts” when he was arrested after an hours-long standoff at the Colorado Springs clinic.

Planned Parenthood provides a range of health services for men and women, including abortion. The remark attributed to Robert Lewis Dear (57) appeared to be a reference to Planned Parenthood’s abortion activities and its role in delivering foetal tissue to researchers, a hot button issue in the 2016 race for the presidency.

Mr Hickenlooper, a Democrat, told CNN that the shooting and similar acts of mass violence might be a function of the “inflammatory rhetoric we see on all levels”, referring to the heated debate over abortion.

“I think we should have a discussion at least urging caution when we discuss some of these issues, so we don’t get people to a point of going out and committing violence,” he said, describing the rampage as “a form of terrorism”.

Friday’s shooting was believed to be the first deadly attack at an abortion provider in the United States in six years. The Colorado Springs centre has been repeatedly targeted for protests by anti-abortion activists.

While Dear’s reported remarks could hint at a possible motive, the sources told NBC that investigators were still not sure why the gunman launched the attack, in which nine people were also injured.

The reports could not be independently confirmed and authorities have steadfastly declined to discuss a possible motive for the attack, saying their investigation was still under way.

Dear, a South Carolina man who appeared to have moved to Colorado last year, has been jailed ahead of a court appearance scheduled for Monday.

Planned Parenthood, however, suggested that the reports were clear evidence of a motive. “We now know the man responsible for the tragic shooting at PP’s health centre in CO was motivated by opposition to safe and legal abortion,” the organisation said on Twitter.

While calling the shooting “an incredible tragedy”, Republican presidential candidate Mike Huckabee yesterday dismissed talk that harsh anti-abortion rhetoric may have contributed to the attack. However he also drew a direct parallel between the attack and abortion.

“There’s no excuse for killing other people, whether it’s inside . . . Planned Parenthood clinics, where many millions of babies die, or whether it’s people attacking Planned Parenthood,” the former Arkansas governor told CNN, saying the attack was an act of “domestic terrorism”.

Abortion opponents stepped up their criticism of Planned Parenthood this year after officials of the organisation were secretly recorded by an anti-abortion group discussing how to obtain human tissue from aborted foetuses. The non-profit organisation has strongly denied doing anything illegal or unethical.

Mr Hickenlooper also disclosed that the two civilian fatalities were a man and a woman, but he offered no further information and would not say whether they were patients or employees at the clinic. Planned Parenthood said all of its employees escaped unharmed.

Authorities have said they would say nothing about the pair until after their postmortem reports, likely on Monday.

Garrett Swasey (44), the police officer killed in the attack, worked for the University of Colorado at Colorado Springs. He had joined city police in responding to reports of shots fired at the clinic. The father of two served as an elder at Hope Chapel, the church said on its website.

Except for his name and age, police have said only that Dear recently resided in rural Hartsel, Colorado, about 60 miles (96km) west of Colorado Springs. Official records show that he has a history of brushes with the law, mostly in South Carolina, but no criminal convictions.

At least eight workers at clinics providing abortions have been killed since 1977, according to the National Abortion Federation. he most recent was in 2009, when Dr George Tiller was shot dead at church in Wichita, Kansas. – (Reuters)