USC cuts would favour higher earners, says Social Justice Ireland

Budget cuts to USC would be ‘profoundly unfair’ on lower-income workers, says study

Minister for Finance Michael Noonan: “We want the gains to be proportionate.” Photograph: Eric Luke

Minister for Finance Michael Noonan: “We want the gains to be proportionate.” Photograph: Eric Luke

 

Proposed changes to the universal social charge (USC) would disproportionately favour higher earners and could be “profoundly unfair” on lower-income workers, a new study said on Monday.

According to Social Justice Ireland (SJI), changing the income taxation system through the elimination of the first three rates of the USC “is an expensive and unfair policy path”.

“Some tax proposals currently being considered by Government should be rejected because they would give far greater benefit to people earning higher incomes than to lower-income employees” said SJI director Seán Healy, who argued that the impact of some of the proposals could be “profoundly unfair” on lower income workers..

Impact

The study considers the impact of the following changes to the USC:

The elimination of the current 1 per cent USC rate – that applies to income below €12,012 (full-year cost: €247 million);

The elimination of the current 3 per cent USC rate – that applies to income between €12,012 and €18,668 (full-year cost: €471 million);

The elimination of the current 5.5 per cent USC rate – that applies to income between €18,668 and €70,044 (full-year cost: €2,024 million)

According to SJI, the total cost of these changes would be €2,742 million in a full tax year – or almost 14 per cent of the expected income taxation yield in 2016. But the gains, it says, are “ heavily skewed” towards those on the highest incomes.

For example, a single worker earning above €70,044 would gain €3,145 a year, more than 4.5 times the gains for a worker on €25,000. Similarly, couples with two incomes totalling €125,000 would gain more than €4,000 a year, almost three times the amount that goes to a similar middle-income couple on €50,000.

Proportionate

However, while cuts to USC have been signalled, Minister for Finance Michael Noonan previously said: “We want everyone on an income to gain from this. But we want the gains to be proportionate.”

The elimination of the PAYE credit – worth €1,650 a year – for those on higher incomes is seen as one of the key ways to take back some of the gains from the better off.