Big tobacco upset at menthol ban as FDA moves on flavoured cigarettes

Imperial, BAT and Altria say ban on menthols not backed by science and evidence

The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has announced sweeping new restrictions on flavoured tobacco products, including electronic cigarettes popular among teenagers in an effort to prevent a new generation of nicotine addicts.

The much-anticipated announcement will mean that only tobacco, mint and menthol e-cigarette flavors can be sold at most traditional retail outlets such as convenience stores. Other fruity- or sweet-flavoured varieties can now only be sold at age-restricted stores or through online merchants that use age-verification checks.

The FDA also plans to seek a ban on menthol cigarettes, a longtime goal of public health advocates, as well as flavoured cigars.

The agency cited survey data showing that mint and menthol flavors were more popular with adult e-cigarette users than teenagers.


Anti-tobacco and public health groups commended the FDA on its proposed ban on menthol cigarettes, which data show are far more popular among young smokers and particularly young African-Americans.

Any move to ban menthol faces fierce resistance from the tobacco industry.

Menthol cigarettes represent more than 30 per cent of US cigarette volumes and approximately 55 per cent of British American Tobacco’s (BAT) US volumes, through its Newport brand.

Imperial, BAT and Altria said the ban on menthols or flavoured cigars was not supported by science and evidence.

FDA commissioner Scott Gottlieb said the moves on flavoured products are meant to prevent young people from continuing to use e-cigarettes, potentially leading to traditional cigarette smoking.

“I will not allow a generation of children to become addicted to nicotine through e-cigarettes,” Mr Gottlieb said.

The agency has faced mounting pressure to act on e-cigarettes amid their surging popularity among US teenagers in recent years. One of the most popular devices, made by San Francisco-based Juul, has become a phenomenon at US high schools, where "Juuling" has become synonymous with vaping.

E-cigarettes vaporise a liquid containing nicotine, the addictive stimulant that gives smokers a rush. They are widely believe to be less harmful than combustible cigarettes, but the long-term health consequences of using the devices are unknown.

Data released on Thursday by the FDA and the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention showed a 78 per cent increase in high school students who reported using e-cigarettes in the last 30 days, compared with the prior year.

More than 3 million high school students, or more than 20 per cent of all US high school students, used the products, along with 570,000 middle school students, according to the survey.


Juul and tobacco giant Altria Group had announced measures to pull flavored e-cigarette products from retail outlets, after the FDA threatened in September to ban Juul and other leading e-cigarette products unless their makers took steps to prevent use by minors.

Juul, Logic, a unit of Japan Tobacco, Altria, which makes e-cigarettes under the MarkTen brand, BAT and Imperial Brands , the maker of blu e-cigarettes, all said they supported efforts to reduce youth access.

E-cigarettes have been a divisive topic in the public health community. Some focus on the potential benefit of shifting lifelong smokers to less harmful nicotine products, while others fear it will create a new generation addicted to nicotine.

Last year the FDA under Mr Gottlieb extended until 2022 a deadline for many e-cigarette products to comply with new federal rules on marketing and public health. The new restrictions on flavours are interim measures that companies must follow before submitting detailed plans before the deadline.

The new rules on e-cigarette flavours mean that many of the sweet and fruity varieties believed to be most popular among minors will only be available in stores such as vape shops or tobacco shops that do not allow under-age people inside.

Stores could also have a separate, age-restricted section that allows sale of other flavours, the FDA said.

- New York Times