Jervis shopping centre takes major tenants to court over rent disputes

Fields, Schuh, New Look and Topman among retailers being sued by Paddy McKillen entity

Jervis Shopping Centre in Dublin has turned up the heat on several of its high-profile tenants in pandemic-related rental disputes by issuing legal writs, as retail industry lobbyists accused some shopping centres of ignoring the plight of retailers hit by the effects of virus restrictions.

JSC Properties, the offshore entity that owns the shopping centre, has issued proceedings in recent days for alleged non-payment of debt against four retailers. Court filings show they include the jewellers Fields, footwear retailer Schuh, Arcadia's Topman fashion outlet, and one of the Jervis Street scheme's main tenants, fashion retailer New Look.

JSC has hired Dublin solicitor Ivor Fitzpatrick to represent it against the tenants, who have not yet filed defences. JSC has sought summary judgment orders, which are considered an aggressive legal tactic where the plaintiff seeks a debt order from a judge without a trial. The retailers may yet dispute the claims.

JSC is jointly owned by developer Paddy McKillen and fellow Tyrone businessman Padraig Drayne, who built Jervis together 25 years ago. They shifted control of it to the Isle of Man in 2013 in a deal designed by tax advisers.


Mr McKillen, a JSC director, referred requests for comment back to Jervis Street, where Mr Drayne is more closely involved in the management of the centre. Lorraine Fitzgerald, a Jervis manager who was been involved in recent rent discussions with tenants, confirmed it was dealing with its tenants "one by one".

Rent relief

Many retailers stopped paying rent when they were forcibly closed during lockdown, between March and the beginning of June. It is understood that many retailers at Jervis have sought relief on their second-quarter rents, while third-quarter rents are also overdue for many. Many retailers have also struggled to pay their service charges while their shops were shuttered.

"Jervis Shopping Centre Management Ltd and our landlords remain sympathetic to the issues facing occupiers during these unprecedented times," Ms Fitzgerald said last night.

“We are presently in contact with all of our tenants on a one-to-one basis, with the intention of finding mutually agreeable solutions where possible.”

She declined to comment further on the legal disputes with individual tenants.

Jervis was one of several shopping centres that received letters last month from industry lobby group Retail Excellence seeking rent talks on behalf of its members.

It is understood that Jervis rebuffed the attempted intervention. Other shopping centres to receive the letters include Dundrum Town Centre in Dublin, Mahon Point shopping centre in Cork, Blanchardstown Centre in Dublin, and Crescent shopping centre in Limerick.

“We need to open up the dialogue between landlords and retailers to form a meaningful resolution. Otherwise thousands of stores will pull the shutters down permanently as they can’t afford to absorb three months’ full rent without any income,” said Keelan Bourke, head of commercial at Retail Excellence.

“The burden must be shared, and many shopping centre owners need to come to the table and engage with their tenants. Many are still not responding to our members, which is causing great uncertainty to the future viability of many businesses.”

Mark Paul

Mark Paul

Mark Paul is Business Affairs Correspondent of The Irish Times. He also writes the Caveat column