Opinion poll shows Irish favour a more liberal, less dogmatic, Catholic Church

Large majorities want end to rigid teaching on celibacy, women priests, contraception, same-sex marriage

Pilgrims attending the papal Mass at the Phoenix Park in Dublin talk about Pope Francis, child abuse, women priests, and why they made the journey.

 

Speaking to Pope Francis in a widely lauded address in Dublin Castle on Saturday, Taoiseach Leo Varadkar stressed that the Ireland of 2018 was a different place to the country visited by Francis’s predecessor John Paul II in 1979.

The same theme flowed through virtually all the reports and reflections on the pope’s visit. And the results of Tuesday’s opinion poll offer sharp details of just how much Irish people have changed in their attitude to some of the church’s teachings, in particular to its rules on high-profile social and sexual issues. John Paul, unyielding on such matters, would have been horrified.

Yesterday, the day after Pope Francis departed the country following his two-day visit, Ipsos MRBI contacted people around the country and asked a series of questions about their attitudes to the visit, to the pope himself, and about their views on aspects of Catholic teaching.

Snapshot

In contrast to regular Irish Times political polls, which employ a face-to-face methodology where respondents are questioned by interviewers on their doorsteps, this poll was conducted by telephone among a sample of 750 adults – large enough to produce a snapshot of national opinion with a margin of error of plus or minus 3.8 per cent.

The poll tends to show a desire for inclusivity and openness to diversity in the church extends across the population 

The results show that Irish people favour a more liberal, less dogmatic, church with huge majorities favouring an end to rigid Catholic teaching on celibacy, women priests, contraception and same-sex marriage.

Specific teachings

Asked about suggestions for changes in specific church teachings, significant majorities favour change in almost all cases.

Gallery

Pope Francis in Ireland: Wrapping up the papal visit VIEW NOW

Asked if priests should be allowed to marry, 90 per cent (of all respondents, not just Catholics) said they agreed.

Pope Francis in the popemobile moving through the crowds in the Phoenix Park. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw/The Irish Times
Pope Francis in the popemobile moving through the crowds in the Phoenix Park. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw/The Irish Times

Some 86 per cent said women should be allowed to become priests – something that successive popes have ruled out.

Fifty years after Pope Paul reasserted the church’s ban on contraception, 92 per cent of those who responded said contraception “should be allowed in all circumstances”. More than three-quarters (77 per cent) said the church should recognise gay and lesbian marriages.

Remarkably, the numbers are very similar for most questions among the population as a whole, and both practising and lapsed Catholics.

The numbers on abortion are noticeably tighter – just over half (53 per cent) say abortion should be permitted in a wide range of circumstances, with 41 per cent disagreeing, and 8 per cent expressing no opinion.

Diversity

The poll also tends to show that a desire for inclusivity and openness to diversity in the church extends across the population at large. Asked if the church should embrace those who do not agree with all church teachings “including those who voted in favour of abortion in the recent referendum”, the results show a large majority in favour of such openness.

More than three-quarters of people (77 per cent) say the church should be open to those who do not follow all its teachings.

The poll also shows the extent of the decline in religious practice among Catholics. Two-thirds (67 per cent) of adults say they “describe themselves as Catholics”, noticeably lower than the 2016 census which simply asked people’s religion, when 78 per cent of all people said they were Catholic.

Of those who identified as Catholics, 36 per cent said they attended Mass weekly or more often, with 29 per cent saying “less often” and 35 per cent saying they only attended for weddings and funerals.

Irish Catholics remain attached to their church – but on their own terms.