Coronavirus: Berlin ready to aid EU economy, says Merkel

Calls in Germany and Netherlands grow for pooling of European debt liability

The European Union is facing the biggest challenge since its foundation, chancellor Angela Merkel warned on Monday as she stressed Germany's readiness to help revive the continent's economy once the coronavirus pandemic subsides.

"Everyone has been hit equally by this and it must be in the interest of everyone and of Germany that Europe emerges stronger from this test," Dr Merkel said in a press briefing before crucial talks among finance ministers over the EU's crisis response on Tuesday.

Her comments come as economists and politicians in Germany question the previous consensus against pooling debt liability.

That mirrors a debate in the Netherlands, where prime minister Mark Rutte is coming under increasing pressure domestically – including from within his own coalition – to soften the Dutch position on the so-called corona bonds, with stinging accusations that he is failing to recognise the new pan-European reality of Covid-19.


Mr Rutte’s critics include the governor of the Dutch central bank, who has warned that, while a conservative fiscal policy is normally politically popular in the Netherlands, it may not be an appropriate response to a potentially lethal pandemic.

Convincing solidarity

"This is a test for the euro zone", said the governor, Klaas Knot. "When we see what's happening in countries such as Italy and Spain, I personally find the call for solidarity extraordinarily convincing."

Mr Knot said such solidarity could take one of two forms: either corona bonds or credit lines issued by the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), the euro zone's permanent bailout fund for struggling economies.

Both Mr Rutte and Dr Merkel have indicated that ESM credit lines could be an acceptable compromise if they come with strict conditions attached.

Within the coalition, the toughest criticism has come from centre-left D66, whose leader in parliament, Rob Jetten, tweeted: "The Netherlands became rich as a result of the EU. Now that jobs and incomes are at stake throughout Europe . . . we cannot let our friends suffocate. Only together can we survive."

‘We fall’

“The Netherlands, like other governments, sometimes enjoys being ‘a little bit stubborn’,” said D66 MEP Sophie in’t Veld. “But they’re playing with fire, because if Italy falls, then the euro zone and the EU fall, and we fall as well.”

Another of Mr Rutte's coalition partners, Gert-Jan Segers of Christian Union, called for "a new Marshall Plan" for southern Europe. "Italy is a tragedy. The country is in ruins. As far as I'm concerned, the first message should be: we're going to help you."

Meanwhile, figures from the European Central Bank show that it dived into the fight to save the economy from coronavirus last week with more than €30 billion of bond purchases up to close of business on Wednesday.

It has also skewed purchases toward Italy. A breakdown for the month of March showed it bought €11.9 billion of Italian sovereign bonds under the asset purchase programme, far more than normal for the euro zone’s third-largest economy. – Additional reporting, Bloomberg

Peter Cluskey

Peter Cluskey

Peter Cluskey is a journalist and broadcaster based in The Hague, where he covers Dutch news and politics plus the work of organisations such as the International Criminal Court