• Search
  • Newsletters
  • Crossword
  • Notices
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
  • Sign In
The Irish Times
Sat, Apr 17, 2021

  • The Irish Times
  • News
  • Sport
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Life & Style
  • Culture
  • More
  • Video
  • Podcasts
  • Executive Jobs
  • Search
  • Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Sign In
  • Global Tax
A Special Report is content that is edited and produced by the Special Reports unit within The Irish Times Content Studio. It is supported by advertisers who may contribute to the report, but who do not have editorial control.

Ireland jumps on to the knowledge-box wagon early

Ireland gained first-mover advantage by introducing the knowledge development box in 2014

Fri, Mar 4, 2016, 06:00 Updated: Mon, Apr 4, 2016, 09:42
Fiona Reddan
In partnership with Irish Tax Institute
Photograph: Thinkstockk

Photograph: Thinkstockk

   
 
 

Patent boxes have been around for quite some time. Indeed, Ireland is frequently cited as first introducing the concept back in 2000, and was swiftly followed by other countries such as France, Luxembourg, Netherlands and the United Kingdom. The so-called box allows companies to pay a lower rate of tax on intellectual property (IP) assets such as patents.

However, as part of the OECD’s Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (Beps) project and the subsequent move to align where profits are taxed with where real business substance occurs, the approach has evolved significantly.

In November 2014 the UK and Germany agreed on the “modified nexus” approach, which set out a new departure for patent boxes around the world. This means tax relief will now be restricted to profits generated from IP initially developed within the home country.

“This is shaping our future IP regime,” notes Joan O’Connor, tax partner with Deloitte, adding that it means larger countries such as Germany and the UK will benefit more from the regime. Indeed, as she adds, the largest multinational operating in Ireland will not have more than 1,500 R&D employees on the ground here.

But once the larger countries set out the approach, “Ireland really had no choice but to follow,” says O’Connor.

“There really wasn’t anything the Government could have done,” she says, “I have to applaud the way they managed to steer a course through supporting Beps while ensuring as a small country with an open economy they did as much as they could.”

As a result it introduced its new patent box regime, the “knowledge development box” (KDB) in 2014, with further details emerging in last year’s budget.

Low tax rate The KDB came into effect on January 1st, 2016, and it provides for a special low tax rate of 6.25 per cent on IP assets that are the result of qualifying R&D activity in Ireland. It is the first and only country to meet the OECD’s modified nexus standard.

“There are no other countries that have a box regime that’s fully compliant [with the OECD],” says Kevin McLoughlin, head of tax at EY Ireland, adding that in this context competing regimes in other jurisdictions such as the UK, which may now look more attractive, will be phased out over next few years and probably replaced by a version that will be compliant.

“For other countries it’s only a matter of time before they follow suit,” he says.

However, while Ireland may have had first-mover advantage with its KDB, O’Connor bemoans the speed with which it came about.

“What the Government could have done is waited longer to produce it. If they waited a few years more the temperature could have dropped and there would have been less focus on international tax, and they may have been able to pick up ideas from other countries,” she says.

“It has certainly impacted on how effective the KDB will be for the future in terms of an incentivisation vehicle”.

For now, multinationals will have “little interest in it”, she says, adding that the percentage of income they could run through it at the 6.25 per cent rate is “tiny”.

Ahead of a forthcoming review of the new regime, McLoughlin says there will be a need for greater clarity about how the KDB operates, and what profits will be eligible for the reduced rate.

Companies will be entitled to relief based only on the proportion that the Irish company’s R&D bear to the total R&D costs incurred in developing the qualifying assets.

So if an Irish company performs 40 per cent of the R&D spend on developing the asset in Ireland then 40 per cent of the income associated with that asset will qualify for the lower tax rate. But, given multinationals do not currently have do vast amounts of R&D in Ireland, the opportunities for taking advantage of it are, at present, limited.

Evolving product This may change, however. “The knowledge development box could possibly serve to attract new R&D investment into Ireland,” is how Washington based Nick Giordano, tax policy leader for EY in the US, sees it.

McLoughlin agrees. “Ireland has been very good at attracting R&D into the country,” he says, citing use of the R&D tax credit, which allows for a 25 per cent tax credit against corporation tax.

This is backed up by recent economic growth figures, which show Irish-based companies have been engaged in significant acquisitions of IP.

“Over the next few years companies will take longer- term decisions on where best to locate,” says McLoughlin.

“The box regime gives them a lot of food for thought”.

Read More

  • ‘Playtime is over’: changing tax rules in an era of globalisation
  • A big year for the global tax system
  • US is moving slowly, if at all, on its tax agenda
  • European Commission to tackle aggressive tax planning
  • World tax triumvirate at tax forum

More in Sponsored

Nicola and Dvir with children Adele and Oran, at home in Tramore, Co Waterford. Photographs: Conor Mulhern Sustainability is the goal for this family from the sunny south east
Last year Ibec trained 5,000 managers in critical skills and knowledge, while more than 300 graduates gained diplomas and certificates with its strategic partner Technological University Dublin. The imperative for lifelong learning
L-R: Maeve Monaghan, Chief Executive, NOW Group; Minister of State for Disabilities, Anne Rabbitte TD; Robert Ryan, Chief Operations Officer, Lidl Ireland; and Ciarán Delaney, NOW Group Ambassador ‘Just a Minute’ is all some customers might need
Ulster University researchers have helped develop new patented technologies and achieve significant cost and performance improvements in manufacturing. Ulster University leading the way working with composite materials

Also in Global Tax

Organised by the Irish Tax Institute, the conference will discuss how new tax rules will affect companies and countries across the world ‘Playtime is over’: changing tax rules in an era of globalisation
Irish Tax Institute president Mary Honohan A big year for the global tax system
Mainstream Republicans realise that the situation is a mess. “There is a 35 per cent federal corporation tax rate with at least another 5 per cent on top of that at state level. The lowest effective rate is 40 per cent for most companies. Why would American multinationals want to locate their profits there?” US is moving slowly, if at all, on its tax agenda
Pascal Saint-Amans: director of the OECD World tax triumvirate at tax forum
Europan Commission European Commission to tackle aggressive tax planning
Photograph: Thinkstock Multinationals in new era of transparency
New transfer-pricing rules could make things difficult for large companies
Photograph: Fotolia Ireland faces thinking outside the knowledge box
Photograph: Thinkstockk Ireland jumps on to the knowledge-box wagon early

recruit ireland

Subscribe
About Us
Policy & Terms
Cookie Settings
Subscribe
  • Why Subscribe?
  • Subscription Bundles
  • Digital Subscriptions FAQs
  • Gift Subscriptions
  • Home Delivery
Irish Times Products & Services
  • ePaper
  • Crosswords
  • Newspaper Archive
  • Article Archive
  • eBooks
  • Newsletters
  • Recruit Ireland
  • Page Sales
  • Photo Sales
  • Discount Codes
About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • The Irish Times Trust CLG
  • Careers
Download on the App Store Download on Google Play
  • Our Partners
  • Rewarding Times
  • MyHome.ie
  • Top 1000
  • The Gloss
  • Irish Times Training
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Information
  • Cookie Settings
  • Community Standards
  • Copyright
  • FAQs
© 2018 THE IRISH TIMES

Sign In

Forgot Password?
Don't have an account?
Subscribe

  • Digital Subscriptions FAQs
  • Subscriber Only Articles
  • The ePaper
  • Subscriber Rewards
  • Subscriber Tour
  • Breaking news app
  • My Account
  • eBooks
  • Email Newsletters
  • Crossword Club
  • Newspaper Archive
  • Sign Out
SUBSCRIBE

Sat 17/4/2021
  • News
    • Coronavirus
    • Ireland
    • World
    • Politics
    • Crime & Law
    • Health
    • Education
    • Subscriber Only
    • ePaper
    • Brexit
  • Sport
    • Gaelic Games
    • Soccer
    • Rugby
    • Golf
    • Racing
    • Other Sports
    • Women in Sport
    • Comment
  • Business
    • The Economy
    • Your Money
    • Companies
    • Technology
    • Work
    • Commercial Property
    • Comment
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Columnists
    • An Irishman's Diary
    • Opinion & Analysis
    • Martyn Turner
  • Life & Style
    • Food & Drink
    • Homes & Property
    • Health & Family
    • People
    • Travel
    • Motors
    • Fashion
    • Abroad
  • Culture
    • Books
    • Film
    • Music
    • Stage
    • Art & Design
    • TV, Radio, Web
    • Tuarascáil
    • Heritage
  • More
    • You are what you read
    • eBooks
    • Offers
    • Jobs
    • Family Notices
    • Competitions
  • Video
  • Podcasts
    • Confronting Coronavirus
    • Inside Politics
    • The Women's Podcast
    • Inside Business
    • Added Time
    • World View
    • Back to Yours
    • The Irish Times Book Club
  • Executive Jobs
  • Crosswords
  • Newsletters
  • Notices
Forgot Password?

Invalid email or password.

Not an Irish Times subscriber? Subscribe
  • Digital Subscriptions FAQs Frequently asked questions about your digital subscription
  • Subscriber Only Articles Specially selected and available only to our subscribers
  • Subscriber Rewards Exclusive offers, discounts and invitations
  • Subscriber Tour Explore the features of your subscription
  • Crossword Club Digital Simplex and Crosaire crosswords
  • Newspaper Archive 150 years of Irish Times journalism
  • My Account Manage your account
  • eBooks Carefully curated selections of Irish Times writing
  • Email Newsletters Sign up to get the stories you want delivered to your inbox
  • The ePaper An exact digital replica of the printed paper
  • Breaking news app Our Apple and Android apps to read on the go
  • Sign Out