Mother settles case over death of baby born at Portlaoise hospital

Baby Katelyn died 10 months after she was delivered at Midlands Regional Hospital

The baby was delivered at Midland Regional Hospital Portlaoise in November 2006.  Photograph: Matt Kavanagh

The baby was delivered at Midland Regional Hospital Portlaoise in November 2006. Photograph: Matt Kavanagh

 

A mother whose baby was delivered at the Midland Regional Hospital, Portlaoise but died 10 months later has settled a High Court action.

Baby Katelyn was known as Baby X in an RTÉ Prime Time documentary seven years ago about the deaths of a number of babies at the hospital.

In the High Court on Monday, Mr Justice Garrett Simons was told the settlement had been reached in the case brought by Katelyn’s mother, Sharon McCarthy. The terms of the settlement are confidential.

Counsel for Katelyn’s mother, Alistair Rutherdale BL instructed by Roger Murray solicitor, told the court that after the documentary was aired in 2014, two investigations were carried out, but Katelyn’s parents were not told about either.

Ms McCarthy of Tipperary town had sued the HSE over the death of Katelyn. The baby was delivered at Midland Regional Hospital Portlaoise in November 2006. Katelyn died in a Dublin hospital in September 2007. A claim was also made for nervous shock. Liability was denied by the HSE.

Sharon McCarthy, in an affidavit to the High Court, said she was admitted to hospital in November 2006. She said her daughter was born at 2.45am on November 2nd but “sadly suffered severe brain damage”.

It was claimed by her side, she said, that there was an alleged failure to recognise the increased risk of foetal hypoxia and there was an alleged delay in obtaining obstetric opinion. There was also an alleged failure to expedite delivery by emergency caesarean section, it was claimed.

Ms McCarthy said her side’s expert would contend that Katelyn ought to have been born by 2am and there was an alleged failure to ascertain foetal wellbeing by foetal blood sample.

In the affidavit, Ms McCarthy said that at the time of the birth she was told the outcome was unavoidable. She said a particular feature of this case is that two HSE investigations in relation to Katelyn’ death were carried out leading to reports: one in July 2009 and another in March 2012.

She said she was not involved in either investigation and was not told of the existence of the reports until 2014.

“I subsequently heard of media coverage of certain deaths in Portlaoise hospital and only learned at that time that Katelyn was one of these,” she said.

Approving the settlement and the division of the solatium, a statutory mental distress payment which in this case was just over €25,000, Mr Justice Garrett Simons said it referred to the tragic death of Katelyn.

The judge ruled the solatium should be divided between the parents Sharon and Thomas as he said they had suffered the most emotional distress.