Rush to vilify GSOC over bugging fears augurs badly

Opinion: The Taoiseach has appeared to have no understanding that the commision does not answer to the Government

Sat, Feb 15, 2014, 00:01

The most disturbing aspect of what happened after the Sunday Times claimed that the offices of the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission (GSOC) had been bugged, was the alacrity with which senior Government figures sought to consign the story to the rubbish bin.

Within hours, a well-sourced report in a respected newspaper was being turned on its head by the Taoiseach and Minister for Justice.

The Taoiseach’s reaction was particularly disquieting and surely indicative. One might have expected an expression of concern at an allegation that at least potentially strikes at the heart of the State’s regulatory institutions.

Instead we had a castigation of GSOC for not reporting to the Minister for Justice, as, he claimed (erroneously) they had a duty to do under section 80 of the Garda Síochána Act.

It is almost irrelevant at this time that the Taoiseach misunderstood or misquoted the law in relation to the Garda supervisory body. It was the proprietorial, almost dictatorial tone in which he delivered himself that told much.

GSOC had to “level with the Minister” and to account for its shortcomings. It had failed in its legal duty. The Taoiseach seemed to have no understanding that GSOC is not answerable to Government (in the same way as the Garda Commissioner) but to the Houses of the Oireachtas.

Chairman of GSOC, former London Metropolitan Police officer Simon O’Brien, did little to reinforce the independence of his organisation by expressing “regret” to the Minister (where he had no need to do so) and emphasising the “kindness” of the Garda commissioner in having a pot of coffee with him later in the week.

Let us put aside for a moment the arcane arguments about “anomalies”, “potential threats” and “vulnerabilities”. GSOC commissioner Kieran FitzGerald spoke with clarity and shining honesty when he told the Oireachtas committee that the likelihood of a benign interpretation of the sweep by UK consultants Verrimus was “close to zero.”

There can be little doubt that somebody bugged, or tried to bug, key offices of GSOC. And they knew their stuff. They went for the fourth floor, where commissioners and senior staff meet for discussion and planning. Rank-and- file GSOC staff have no access to that fourth floor.

So who are the suspects?

Ordinary criminals? Subversives? Media? Foreign intelligence services – MI6 or CIA? A rogue element within GSOC itself? Gardaí who themselves (or their colleagues) may be under investigation by GSOC?

It is unlikely that ordinary criminals or subversives would have either the interest of the capacity to bug GSOC. From its establishment, GSOC has had in place relatively sophisticated counter-surveillance measures (on the advice of consultants that included former senior gardaí).

Thus, members of An Garda Síochána must, at the very least, be potential suspects in any investigation that begins on the premise that an attempt has been made to penetrate GSOC security.

Commissioner Martin Callinan has stated that no Garda surveillance, authorised or otherwise, was in place. With the greatest respect, it is doubtful if the commissioner knows everything that goes on in his force of more than 13,000 officers, as not a few of his predecessors in office found out to their cost over the years.

We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Standards. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or by filling out this form. New comments are only accepted for 3 days from the date of publication.