State’s most bizarre body to advise on abortion Bill
Meetings of the council take place behind closed doors and no detailed record kept
President Cearbhall Ó Dálaigh (right) was to resign after Paddy Donegan called him a “thundering disgrace”. Photograph: Pat Langan.
President Michael D Higgins’s decision to summon the Council of State on Monday to discuss the constitutionality of the Protection of Life During Pregnancy Bill has put the focus on what is probably the State’s most bizarre institution.
Its job is to advise the President on the rare occasions when he or she wishes to exercise one of the reserve powers detailed in the Constitution. The President is not obliged to accept the advice, however, no matter how overwhelming.
The council meets on only a handful of occasions during a normal seven-year presidential term. Advising the incumbent on whether or not to refer a Bill to the Supreme Court is the most common reason for a meeting.
The current council is the biggest, with 24 members, as a result of the number of former taoisigh and chief justices still living. It comprises senior serving and retired politicians and judges, as well as seven members appointed by the President when he took office.
Meetings of the council take place behind closed doors and, as with Cabinet discussions, no detailed record is kept about what is said by individuals. Nor is there a record of those for or against the referral of any particular Bill to the Supreme Court .
A rare insight into what happened at one of the most controversial meetings of the council was given to me some years ago by the late Jim Dooge, cathaoirleach of the Seanad from 1973 to 1977. As cathaoirleach he attended the crucial meeting of the council in September 1976 that discussed the Emergency Powers Bill passed by the government in response to the murder of British ambassador Christopher Ewart-Biggs in Sandyford, Co Dublin, by the Provisional IRA.
Cearbhall Ó Dálaigh
The then president, Cearbhall Ó Dálaigh, who was already on poor terms with the Fine Gael-Labour coalition led by Liam Cosgrave, and had threatened to resign on a number of occasions, summoned a meeting of the council.
As Dooge recalled, the president was more intent on proving he was entitled to refer the Bill to the Supreme Court than on expressing much concern with the contents of the legislation.
“Tom O’Higgins was there as chief justice and said that since the matter might come to the Supreme Court he wouldn’t give any advice to the president. But Tom Finlay was there as president of the High Court and he gave devastating advice that there was no point referring it to the Supreme Court. The legislation was so clearly constitutional that it was a waste of time,” said Dooge.
“Cearbhall kept trying to say there was a suggestion that he could not refer emergency legislation but Finlay was quite clear that as it was emergency legislation there was no doubt about its constitutionality. After that meeting I was of the opinion that Cearbhall was being quite irresponsible.”
Ó Dálaigh proceeded to refer the Bill to the Supreme Court, despite the contrary advice and to Cosgrave’s deep annoyance. Minister for defence Paddy Donegal subsequently described the president as “a thundering disgrace”. Ó Dálaigh resigned and the government suffered a strong public backlash that counted heavily against it in the general election the following June