Poverty trap emphasises literacy gap among American children

A doctors’ group in the US is asking its members to hand books out to families in bid to narrow the literacy gap

Dr Leora Mogilner shows a book to nine-month old Kaylee Smith and her mother, Tameka Griffiths, at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York. Photograph: Ruth Fremson/The New York Times

Dr Leora Mogilner shows a book to nine-month old Kaylee Smith and her mother, Tameka Griffiths, at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York. Photograph: Ruth Fremson/The New York Times

Tue, Jul 8, 2014, 08:21

In between dispensing advice on breastfeeding and immunisations, doctors will tell parents to read aloud to their infants from birth, under a new policy that the American Academy of Pediatrics announced recently.

With the increased recognition that an important part of brain development occurs within the first three years of a child’s life, and that reading to children enhances vocabulary and other important communication skills, the group, which represents 62,000 pediatricians across the US, is asking its members to become powerful advocates for reading aloud, every time a baby visits the doctor.

“It should be there each time we touch bases with children,” says Dr Pamela High, who wrote the new policy. It recommends that doctors tell parents they should be “reading together as a daily fun family activity” from infancy.

This is the first time the academy, which has issued recommendations about how long mothers should nurse their babies and advises parents to keep children away from screens until they are at least two, has officially weighed in on early literacy education.

Not often enough

While highly educated, ambitious parents who are already reading poetry and playing Mozart to their children in utero may not need this advice, research shows that many parents do not read to their children as often as researchers and educators think is crucial to the development of pre-literacy skills that help children succeed once they get to school.

Reading, as well as talking and singing, is viewed as important in increasing the number of words that children hear in the earliest years of their lives. Nearly two decades ago, an oft-cited study found that by the age of three, the children of wealthier professionals have heard words millions more times than have those of less-educated, low-income parents, giving the children who have heard more words a distinct advantage in school. New research shows that these gaps emerge as early as 18 months.

According to a federal government survey of children’s health, 60 per cent of American children from families with incomes at least four times the federal poverty threshold – $95,400 (€70,132) for a family of four – are read to daily from birth to five years of age, compared with about one-third of children from families living below the poverty line, $23,850 (€17,533) for a family of four.

With parents of all income levels increasingly handing smartphones and tablets to babies, who learn how to swipe before they can turn a page, reading aloud may be fading into the background.

“The reality of today’s world is that we’re competing with portable digital media,” says Dr Alanna Levine, a paediatrician in Orangeburg, New York state. “So you really want to arm parents with tools and the rationale behind it, about why it’s important to stick to the basics of things such as books.”

Reading aloud is also a way to pass the time for parents who find endless baby talk tiresome.

“It’s an easy way of talking that doesn’t involve talking about the plants outside,” says Erin Autry Montgomery, from Austin, Texas, who has a six-month-old son.

Reduce disparities

The pediatricians’ group hopes that by encouraging parents to read often and early, they may help reduce academic disparities between wealthier and low-income children as well as between racial groups.

“If we can get that first 1,000 days of life right,” says Dr Dipesh Navsaria, an assistant professor of paediatrics at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, “we’re really going to save a lot of trouble later on and have to do far less remediation.”

Navsaria is the medical director of the Wisconsin chapter of Reach Out and Read, a nonprofit literacy group that enlists about 20,000 pediatricians nationwide to give books to low-income families. The group is working with Too Small to Fail, a joint effort between the nonprofit Next Generation and the Bill, Hillary and Chelsea Clinton Foundation that is aimed at closing the word gap.

Scholastic, the children’s book publisher, has donated 500,000 books to Reach Out and Read. Too Small to Fail is also developing materials to distribute to members of the American Academy of Pediatrics to help them emphasise the read-aloud message to parents. (New York Times)

We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Standards. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or by filling out this form. New comments are only accepted for 3 days from the date of publication.