Donna Leon: ‘I had the good sense to make Brunetti someone I liked’

Donna Leon’s much-loved crime series centring on nice guy policeman Commissario Guido Brunetti is 22 years old. The new novel discusses the very nature of books

Donna Leon: ‘I don’t see any reason to be optimistic about our world. But I’m very optimistic about my life.’ Photograph: David Levenson/Getty Images

Donna Leon: ‘I don’t see any reason to be optimistic about our world. But I’m very optimistic about my life.’ Photograph: David Levenson/Getty Images


She wrote her first murder mystery in the early 1990s as “a kind of joke”. Some 22 books later, Donna Leon has notched up sales of well over two million, been translated into 35 languages and made the Times list of the 50 greatest crime writers. Her beloved series about Commissario Brunetti has inspired spin-offs including a mouth-watering cookbook, a historical guide to Brunetti’s Venice and a real-world business that offers tours of the city to visiting fans.

Guido Brunetti is not your typical shambolic, hard-drinking, over-worked policeman. He’s presentable and well-read. He gets home for dinner. He actually seems to enjoy the company of his wife, Paola, and their kids. He enjoys his wine and his glass of grappa, too – but not to excess.

Was this a bit of mischief on Leon’s part: to deliberately make him the antithesis of the crime-fiction stereotype? “It was pure chance,” she says. “All I wanted to do was write one book. I had no idea that there would be 23 of them. I got the idea of the murder of a conductor, and I wondered if I could write a murder-mystery about it. And so I did. But I had the good sense, even then, to make him someone that I liked. A nice guy and an intellectually and ethically interesting man.”

Affable and enthusiastic
The description might apply just as well to Leon herself. At 71 she is affable and enthusiastic, as passionate about Henry James and Handel opera as she is about the ravages mass tourism has wreaked on her adopted city. But she is also very much her own woman. She won’t allow her books to be published in Italian, so that she can live as close to a normal life as possible in her beloved Venice.

“People I deal with in shops treat me the way I should be treated: that is, as someone who comes in to buy cheese or milk or fruit,” she says. “There’s no hi-de-ho. The thing that upsets me more and more is the terrible inequality of fame. I see it in myself. I do it with opera singers. I am automatically deferential to opera singers because I admire what they do so much – and that’s not right. Everybody should be the same. You should treat everybody the same.”

This democratic strand is very strong in the Brunetti books. Their version of civilised life is not just a matter of drinking coffee and eating soft-shell crabs and ravioli con funghi. They are angry books, too. Many things make Leon – and by extension Brunetti – angry. Environmental degradation and toxic-waste scandals; people- trafficking and sex slavery; illegal adoptions and child abuse; corruption in the Catholic Church; blood diamonds.

“The paradox that one sees in Brunetti is the same paradox that I observe in my own life,” she says. “In terms of the world around me – politics, religion, art, music – I’m absolutely, deeply cynical and suspicious and black. But in my personal life I’m a happy person. I was just born a happy person. As I get older and see more, and view it with the accumulated information that comes with age, I don’t see any reason to be optimistic about our world. But I’m very optimistic about my life and my friends. Thank God it’s not the other way around,” she adds, laughing. “Imagine that.”

The new Brunetti book, By Its Cover , deals with the theft of valuable literary texts. “I’m really not interested in whodunnit,” she says. “I’m interested in why they done it. In this case I was interested in why the books were stolen – and why one person was killed as a result.”

Over the course of the investigation, there is much discussion about the nature of books – a major concern for readers in the digital age. “Is a book simply a text, so that you could read it chalked on a wall if you had a big enough wall?” asks Leon. “Or is it a physical object which has a historical and financial value because of the quality of its production? And I don’t think the book answers that question, because there is no answer. People, depending on their disposition or their spirit, opt for one or the other.”

A major factor in the Brunetti series has been the strong female characters. From the start, Brunetti’s wife, Paola – a university lecturer and the daughter of wealthy Count and Countess Falier – has played a key role in teasing out the wider implications of Brunetti’s cases. Then, out of nowhere, a secretary named Signorina Elettra swanned in, complete with high heels, glam outfits and serious computer street-cred. And now, an able young southern cop, Claudia Griffoni, is edging closer to the centre of the investigative stage.

Hints about Brunetti’s future
These days, there are intriguing hints about Brunetti’s future. In By Its Cover , he pulls social rank on his superior, Vice- Questore Patta, reminding him which of them would one day move into the stunning Palazzo Falier “and look across at the facades of the palazzi on the other side of the Grand Canal”.

For the moment, however, Brunetti fans need not worry: number 24 in the series is already written. It will take Leon back to the world of baroque opera, where she set her first novel, Death at La Fenice .

“I’ve told myself for years and years and years: ‘Donna, your passion for music is not transferable. Your passion for baroque opera doesn’t mean that other people will be interested.’ Then I thought, ‘Well, I can have a little fun, can’t I?’ ”

She surely deserves it.

By Its Cover is published by Heinemann , £12.99

Sign In

Forgot Password?

Sign Up

The name that will appear beside your comments.

Have an account? Sign In

Forgot Password?

Please enter your email address so we can send you a link to reset your password.

Sign In or Sign Up

Thank you

You should receive instructions for resetting your password. When you have reset your password, you can Sign In.

Hello, .

Please choose a screen name. This name will appear beside any comments you post. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our community standards.

Thank you for registering. Please check your email to verify your account.

Your Comments
We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Standards. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or by filling out this form. New comments are only accepted for 3 days from the date of publication.