• RSS
  • Text Size:
  • -
  • irishtimes.com - Posted: April 2, 2009 @ 8:34 am

    Competition – predict The Ticket’s best Irish music act right now and win an awesome Vestalife Ladybug iPod speaker!

    Jim Carroll

    In The Ticket tomorrow, we will be counting down the 50 Best Irish Acts Right Now. Yes, this is what I was on about earlier in the week when I said to make a date with the blog on Friday morning.

    Anyway, a bunch of Ticket writers have put their heads together and have come up with a list of acts, which goes all the way from fifty to one. There will probably be fun and games galore when this list is published tomorrow so strap yourselves in.

    Ahead of the publication of that list, here’s a competition for On The Record readers to see if they are on the same wavelength as The Ticket’s music writers: who do you think will be at number one?

    And if there’s a competition, there has to be a prize. Thanks to Vestalife and Future Sounds, I picked up one of these Vestalife Ladybug speakers at SXSW a few weeks ago.

    lb2.jpg

    Vestalife’s Ladybug is, as you can see, a super-duper iPod speaker which comes with snazzy flip-down speaker wings, a digital amp and built-in sub woofer for lots of bad-ass bass, unlike some of the biscuit-tin speakers I’ve used over the years. The Ladybug works with a ton of different generation iPods, will recharge your player when it is plugged in and has won a ton of design awards . Having tried the speakers out for the last week or so when I was away, it comes with a big thumbs-up from me. It’s a damn nifty piece of kit (man, I should be writing for Stuff magazine).

    The rules: simply tell us in the comments field below who you think will be at number one in The Ticket’s Best 50 Irish Acts Right Now list, which will be published in the paper tomorrow (Friday). Acts must have played a gig, released an album or recorded since the beginning of 2008. Entries closes at 6pm GMT today (Thursday). One entry per reader. Competition is not open to my colleagues in The Ticket or The Irish Times because they probably already know the answer (sorry folks). If there are several winning entries, the names will be placed in a hat and one name will be selected at random. The judge (ie me) will not enter into any discussion or correspondance with anyone about anything to do with this competition. And no, the prize does not come with an iPod.

    Best of luck to y’all.

  • 101 Comments

    1.
    April 2, 2009
    8:56 am

    50 best Irish acts is alot easier to compile than 50 GOOD Irish acts.

    Comment by Peter81
    2.
    April 2, 2009
    8:58 am

    RSAG

    Comment by P&M
    3.
    April 2, 2009
    8:58 am

    Mick Flannery….

    Comment by Gary M
    4.
    April 2, 2009
    9:05 am

    Seeing as I was waaaay off with what I thought tomorrow’s announcement was going to be, I don’t hold much hope of predicting this one but I’ll have a stab.

    Jape?

    Comment by Joe
    5.
    April 2, 2009
    9:08 am

    Joe (and a ton of other people) – I never mentioned anything about an announcement! People just saw the line and assumed it was an announcement. Sure, it could have been a funny video involving two hedgehogs wrestling over a packet of Fig Rolls.

    Tsk – and people say the media always jump to the wrong conclusion? ;-)

    Anyway, back to the guessing…….

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    6.
    April 2, 2009
    9:21 am

    With her burgeoning american fanbase, Lisa Hannigan has my vote!!

    Comment by Lynam
    7.
    April 2, 2009
    9:26 am

    Villagers.

    No act is blowing socks off feet (in a gentle manner) more than Conor O’ Brien and co.

    Comment by Niall
    8.
    April 2, 2009
    9:28 am

    fiight like apes

    Comment by Neil C
    9.
    April 2, 2009
    9:30 am

    The Mulkerrin Brothers

    Comment by JD
    10.
    April 2, 2009
    9:34 am

    it’s gotta be The Skinny Wolves Jazzercise Brass Band.

    Comment by ruan // nick thinks...
    11.
    April 2, 2009
    9:43 am

    If you’ve had the chance to see them play live recently One Day International would win

    Comment by Tycho
    12.
    April 2, 2009
    9:47 am

    @ ruan: ha ha!

    I’m with Niall on Villagers.

    Comment by Fiona
    13.
    April 2, 2009
    9:50 am

    U2, of course

    Comment by Smoothie
    14.
    April 2, 2009
    9:52 am

    Fight Like Apes!

    Comment by PaulMc
    15.
    April 2, 2009
    9:53 am

    villagers

    Comment by caroline
    16.
    April 2, 2009
    9:54 am

    Reemo

    Comment by rachel
    17.
    April 2, 2009
    9:55 am

    Oppenheimer

    Comment by Pete
    18.
    April 2, 2009
    9:57 am

    U2

    Comment by Jack
    19.
    April 2, 2009
    9:57 am

    Jape

    Comment by Ian
    20.
    April 2, 2009
    9:58 am

    For ‘right now’ I’ll go with David Kitt. New album is great

    Comment by flynnduism
    21.
    April 2, 2009
    9:59 am

    Well, it won’t be Abeiski Shank…..

    I’m going with The Frames

    Comment by RoRo
    22.
    April 2, 2009
    10:00 am

    I’m guessing Lisa Hannigan.

    Comment by Soc
    23.
    April 2, 2009
    10:04 am

    JK ensemble

    Comment by The Dog Warden
    24.
    April 2, 2009
    10:04 am

    jape

    if bell x1 win i’m emigrating.
    if phantom play that talking heads rip off load of wank tune of theirs one more time i will tut loudly as my collegues sing along with it

    Comment by petee
    25.
    April 2, 2009
    10:04 am

    Jinx Lennon FTW

    Comment by Eileen
    26.
    April 2, 2009
    10:09 am

    Given that the blogmaster himself gave her a ‘big up’ in his review of acts at SXSW, I’ll join the queue for Lisa Hannigan

    Comment by Chalkie
    27.
    April 2, 2009
    10:10 am

    The Script

    Comment by trolley
    28.
    April 2, 2009
    10:10 am

    Hmmmmm……Fight Like Apes.

    Comment by Anthony McG
    29.
    April 2, 2009
    10:14 am

    thats got to be Jape
    the nicest man in irish music and all that – the one thing i will say is that he should bring back that moustache.

    Comment by gavin w.
    30.
    April 2, 2009
    10:23 am

    If its the script its gonna make for a very entertaining comments day tom!!…….

    i’ll go with villagers

    Comment by Ron
    31.
    April 2, 2009
    10:23 am

    i’m reckoning it’s gonna be villagers

    Comment by Ciarán
    32.
    April 2, 2009
    10:28 am

    The Rags
    (with Villagers a close second)

    Comment by andy
    33.
    April 2, 2009
    10:33 am

    It will be either Enya or The Script

    Comment by Rasputin
    34.
    April 2, 2009
    10:50 am

    Just wondering, did you only include bands you’re already aware of in the list of or did you scour myspace etc to find any new acts you might not have heard of yet? 50’s a big number to fill

    Comment by Laura
    35.
    April 2, 2009
    10:50 am

    Wow, the Villagers are getting alot of responses. Not bad for a band/songwriter that hasn’t put out an LP yet!

    The EP is very good though.

    Comment by Peter81
    36.
    April 2, 2009
    10:57 am

    Laura – you will find out tomorrow morning ;-) And 50 is nothing! I could easily come up with a list of 75 top ranking Irish bands without much effort.

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    37.
    April 2, 2009
    10:59 am

    You’re Only Massive

    Comment by No TV
    38.
    April 2, 2009
    11:00 am

    This truly is the musical equivalent of Sophie’s Choice…

    What do yo base your decision on? Is it someone who you personally think is the best (argh who to pick!) or who commercially (e.g. Script, Westlife), artistically (Lisa Han, Jape) or otherwise has left the best corpse of late? Do you go with someone who has had the best ‘last 15 months’ or do you go with someone who is on the verge of something enormous?

    Equally do you go for one of the old guard who has some crackers in the back catalogue and have released or played something not necessarily their best (Eg Van, U2)?

    This is like something out of the Krypton Factor…can you give us any idea of what the basis for selection was for the top 5?

    Comment by James D
    39.
    April 2, 2009
    11:08 am

    I’m a big Lisa Hannigan fan so I have to go with her.

    Comment by Tommy
    40.
    April 2, 2009
    11:08 am

    can you give us any idea of what the basis for selection was for the top 5?

    Nope, that discussion is for tomorrow James – today, it’s all about taking a guess and seeing if the readers and writers are on the same planet.

    Go on, I know you want to say Sinead O’Connor

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    41.
    April 2, 2009
    11:11 am

    Lisa Hannigan

    Comment by Alan
    42.
    April 2, 2009
    11:16 am

    “Acts must have played a gig, released an album or recorded since the beginning of 2008.”

    I see a shitstorm brewing over this :D

    What’s to say, for example, that despite My Bloody Valentine not releasing anything since 1991, Shields and co aren’t the best Irish act right now?

    Just stirring it really. And as much as I love the Villagers EP and was well impressed by them live I think it’s too soon to put them up there just yet.

    Comment by Joe
    43.
    April 2, 2009
    11:21 am

    hhmmm..villagers..

    Comment by ciaran
    44.
    April 2, 2009
    11:21 am

    Adrian Crowley

    Comment by Michael
    45.
    April 2, 2009
    11:26 am

    “Acts must have played a gig, released an album or recorded since the beginning of 2008.”

    I see a shitstorm brewing over this

    What’s to say, for example, that despite My Bloody Valentine not releasing anything since 1991, Shields and co aren’t the best Irish act right now?

    All this is for TOMORROW. What’s to say,for example, that My Bloody Valentine are even on the list, eh?

    Bring your own coffee, popcorn and a clean pair of trousers

    In fact, I’m going to delete or edit any comments from now on which are not just guesses because it will spoil all tomorrow’s fun

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    46.
    April 2, 2009
    11:34 am

    Best Irish bands. Halves, 3epkano and Go is an Astronaut. We’ll see what dry county do next before making the call on them.

    Comment by uncle
    47.
    April 2, 2009
    11:39 am

    I say Villagers

    Comment by Cian O' Connell
    48.
    April 2, 2009
    11:45 am

    RSAG

    Comment by Colm
    49.
    April 2, 2009
    11:47 am

    Fascist!

    (One more for Villagers)

    Comment by Joss
    50.
    April 2, 2009
    11:50 am

    I’m going to go with Mike Slott, making the most creative and funky music coming out of this island right now. And OMG he is just like soooo now, in our post-hiphop, skwee-ed up world. Thankfully I’m happy enough with my stereo at home so I can take a principled-yet-doomed stance…

    Comment by Chris
    51.
    April 2, 2009
    12:11 pm

    Top 50 is a bit a ridiculous when it’s hard enough to come up even with a top 5.

    My Bloody Valentine/David Holmes/God Is An Astronaut are the best Irish acts ‘right now’ (all have gigged/released albums etc since 08)

    Who will get number 1? Someone entirely predictable..one of the following usual suspects like Jape, Lisa, Bell X1, etc….I’ll go for Bell X1.

    There’ll be some shit-storm tomorrow.

    Comment by Quint
    52.
    April 2, 2009
    12:14 pm

    Fight Like Apes

    Comment by JB
    53.
    April 2, 2009
    12:16 pm

    I’d have to go for…… aaaaahhhhh…… jeeeze…. this is harder than i thought. Lisa Hannigan???

    Comment by Morgan Quinn
    54.
    April 2, 2009
    12:18 pm

    I reckon it’s Jape

    Comment by Andy Ardonia
    55.
    April 2, 2009
    12:22 pm

    Róisín Murphy

    Comment by Ken
    56.
    April 2, 2009
    12:29 pm

    I’m gonna go with….

    Katie Kim or R.S.A.G.

    Comment by Aisling
    57.
    April 2, 2009
    12:30 pm

    You tart Jim “Gordon Burns” Carroll. Why would I say Sinead O’Connor when Dolores O’Riordan is miles better….and has a better hairstyle?

    Hmmm I’m gonna have to plum for ….. Lisa Han.

    Comment by James D
    58.
    April 2, 2009
    12:36 pm

    villagers

    amazing gig in spirit store this year

    Comment by tom
    59.
    April 2, 2009
    12:36 pm

    Roisin Murphy

    No album since 2007 but still gigging

    Comment by Eoin
    60.
    April 2, 2009
    12:41 pm

    Not a guess obviously, but just wanted to point out that My Bloody Valentine would certainly qualify on the grounds of blowing the ears off everyone at last year’s Electric Picnic/London gigs (ie playing a gig since the beginning of 2008).

    Comment by Sinéad
    61.
    April 2, 2009
    12:46 pm

    if republic of loose make it in there then we all know that jim has more than one vote on the panel :)

    Comment by petee
    62.
    April 2, 2009
    12:48 pm

    Enya, should be the only name on the list

    Comment by Spacey
    63.
    April 2, 2009
    12:50 pm

    Imelda May

    Comment by JohnB
    64.
    April 2, 2009
    12:51 pm

    Top 50 is a bit a ridiculous when it’s hard enough to come up even with a top 5.

    Quint – you lost your point when you followed up that line with a list of 6 Irish acts!

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    65.
    April 2, 2009
    12:53 pm

    Jape, with FLA a close second!

    Comment by Ciaran L
    66.
    April 2, 2009
    12:57 pm

    After missing out on the Choice Music Prize I’m now convinced that Declan Nerney will at least top this particular poll.

    Comment by Matt Vinyl/The Golden Maverick
    67.
    April 2, 2009
    12:59 pm

    With the rumor that they’re supporting U2 I might just have to go with Republic of Loose… this wouldn’t be my vote, but hey for the ladybug’s sake!

    Comment by JLA
    68.
    April 2, 2009
    1:21 pm

    It’s got to be a toss-up between Jape & Villagers, in my opinion, with loads of acts coming close.

    Those two are currently the most exciting… and while I’d probably go for Villagers myself, I reckon Jape will take it because Villagers could still be considered a work-in-progress.

    Comment by Clockwork Rob
    69.
    April 2, 2009
    1:23 pm

    RSAG

    Comment by Jamie H
    70.
    April 2, 2009
    1:36 pm

    Lisa Hannigan

    Comment by Aonghus
    71.
    April 2, 2009
    1:39 pm

    I’m going to saaaaay Roisin Murphy!!

    Comment by Brian
    72.
    April 2, 2009
    1:42 pm

    i’m guessin Bell XI

    Comment by OC
    73.
    April 2, 2009
    1:45 pm

    GREAT to see the Irish bands getting a look in!

    And So I Watch You From Afar vs BATS. Don’t ask me to choose!

    Comment by Naomi
    74.
    April 2, 2009
    1:52 pm

    Want to say The Redneck Manifesto but not sure if they’d be eligible so gonna go with Jape…

    Comment by Tony
    75.
    April 2, 2009
    2:06 pm

    David Holmes

    Comment by Rocky TM
    76.
    April 2, 2009
    2:07 pm

    The Blizzards

    Comment by roisin
    77.
    April 2, 2009
    2:09 pm

    At this moment in time it’s The Ambience Affair

    Comment by hugger
    78.
    April 2, 2009
    2:12 pm

    Jape.

    Comment by Dave
    79.
    April 2, 2009
    2:34 pm

    Jape

    Comment by adam
    80.
    April 2, 2009
    2:52 pm

    U2 – Can’t see any other Irish act selling nealy a million tickets or having a No. 1 album in 30 countries this year, then again if this is a critics award it may well go to a band who nealy sold out a gig in Whelans and spent 3 weeks at No. 8 in the Irish charts, cause the critics know best and they’re cool don’t ya know.

    Comment by Peter
    81.
    April 2, 2009
    2:57 pm

    Can’t see any other Irish act selling nealy a million tickets or having a No. 1 album in 30 countries this year

    Peter – new Westlife album due in Oct/Nov

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    82.
    April 2, 2009
    3:00 pm

    1. My Bloody Valentine

    2. The 202s

    3. Fight Like Apes

    Comment by Ken Smith
    83.
    April 2, 2009
    3:16 pm

    Is it just me or could Jim’s comment @ 81 be considered a hint as to who is no.1….?

    Comment by James D
    84.
    April 2, 2009
    3:21 pm

    I’d love it to be Iain Archer, Pony Club or Martin Finke however my (un)educated guess would be Jinx Lennon.

    Comment by Peter N
    85.
    April 2, 2009
    3:21 pm

    Is it just me or could Jim’s comment @ 81 be considered a hint as to who is no.1….?

    It’s just you

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    86.
    April 2, 2009
    3:27 pm

    R.S.A.G.

    Comment by Brian
    87.
    April 2, 2009
    3:28 pm

    Fight Like Apes

    Best at the second of the day.

    Comment by Gabriel CC
    88.
    April 2, 2009
    3:29 pm

    Fight Like Apes
    Yeah

    Comment by Gabriel CC
    89.
    April 2, 2009
    3:30 pm

    BATS FTW!!!

    Comment by Liam
    90.
    April 2, 2009
    3:33 pm

    Gonna jump on the bandwagon….Jape.

    Comment by Lyn
    91.
    April 2, 2009
    3:44 pm

    Lisa H, Jape, or R.S.A.G… Hmmm I dunno… Lisa me thinks

    Comment by Martin
    92.
    April 2, 2009
    4:26 pm

    RSAG or Katie Kim?… hmmmm…

    Katie Kim it is!!

    Comment by eoiny
    93.
    April 2, 2009
    4:35 pm

    I have a feeling in me waters that tomorrow is going to be GREAT!

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    94.
    April 2, 2009
    4:38 pm

    Another Lisa Hannigan vote here…

    Comment by Eric
    95.
    April 2, 2009
    4:38 pm

    Imelda May!!

    Comment by Caroline
    96.
    April 2, 2009
    4:53 pm

    1. ilya k
    2. giveamanakick

    Comment by cd
    97.
    April 2, 2009
    4:53 pm

    I suppose i;ll plum for FLA.Great to se so many different choices.
    Says alot.

    Comment by guckletis
    98.
    April 2, 2009
    4:54 pm

    jinx lennon

    Comment by Gray
    99.
    April 2, 2009
    4:58 pm

    Villagers!

    Comment by Jenkon
    100.
    April 2, 2009
    5:14 pm

    Competition is now closed. Thanks to everyone for entering. Result will be announced tomorrow morning. Bet you can’t wait!

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    101.
    April 3, 2009
    7:29 am

    Congrats to Rocky TM who was the only one to predict that David Holmes would top the poll – email on the way to you right now, dude.

    Comment by Jim Carroll

    Comments on this article are now closed.


Search On The Record