Budget 2027 falls short of preventing public sector industrial action, say unions

Coalition moves to benefit middle-earning workers and provide for pay increases next year disappoint representatives

Irish Congress of Trade Unions chairman Kevin Callinan said Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers failed to 'move the dial' on pay issues. Photograph: Gareth Chaney/Collins
Irish Congress of Trade Unions chairman Kevin Callinan said Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers failed to 'move the dial' on pay issues. Photograph: Gareth Chaney/Collins

Public service unions have said Budget 2027 was a missed opportunity for Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers to signal his seriousness about preventing an escalation of ongoing public sector industrial action.

Representatives have said that moves to benefit middle-earning workers and to provide for pay increases next year fell well short of what they had hoped for.

Irish Congress of Trade Unions chairman Kevin Callinan, who will lead the union side in any negotiations, said during the summer the unions would take account of whatever measures were in the budget when it came to framing a pay claim in talks. But on Wednesday he said the Minister had failed to “move the dial”.

[ Public sector unions reject Jack Chambers’ call to enter talks as disagreement remainsOpens in new window ]

“We noted the inclusion in the budget statement of provision for additional public service pay of €1.2 billion next year. It’s a long way from the €2 billion that was mooted in recent weeks. And you’ll see that that’s inclusive of public service pensions and carry-over costs from the deal that expired in the summer,” he said.

“We’re still stuck in the same situation that we’ve been in since June, with Government looking to negotiate a multiannual deal of the type that we have had to date ... and while we are open to that we have to say again that the cost of living would have to be addressed first.”

Adrian Kane, Siptu deputy general secretary with responsibility for the public service, echoed those remarks and, like Callinan, noted the lack of any obvious provision to address pay in the second half of this year despite rising inflation.

“In terms of the amount set aside for next year, the net amount could be under 3 per cent at a time when the CPI [consumer price index] for September was 3.9 [per cent],” he said.

Both said support for the action remained strong among their public sector members, about 170,000 between them. Callinan said about 10,000 Fórsa members had registered for a webinar the union has organised on the mechanics of what would be the first one-day stoppage across the public service since 2009.

Budget 2027: buying the  peace by pouring fuel on the fire

Listen | 51:19

A string of other unions reacted negatively to the budget, with Association of Secondary Teachers in Ireland general secretary Linda Kelly saying there was nothing in it to solve the dispute. Irish Medical Organisation president Matthew Sadlier suggested funding for health “will not be sufficient to meet existing demand, not to mind improve services or tackle waiting lists”.

In his budget speech, Jack Chambers again called for talks, saying the Government “wants to work constructively with workers’ representatives to secure a new public service agreement that is fair to public servants, fair to taxpayers and sustainable for our economy”.

[ Public sector has consistently failed to deliver but feels entitled to better payOpens in new window ]

In addition to the €1.2 billion, another €1.6 billion was allocated to a contingency fund which could bolster the funds available for pay.

“Government, unions and representative associations must now refocus on delivering an agreement without further delay,” said the Minister. “Industrial action in the public service has been ongoing for almost a week now and while I understand the strength of feeling, every effort should be made to avoid further disruption of services to the public.”

Fórsa, meanwhile, has said its school secretaries and caretakers have overwhelmingly voted to back a deal on pensions that officially ends the dispute that prompted strike action in schools a year ago.

  • Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date

  • Find managing your money a struggle? The Better with Money podcast will guide you on how to control your finances

  • Get the On the Money newsletter for insights on saving money and smart spending decisions

Emmet Malone

Emmet Malone

Emmet Malone is Work Correspondent at The Irish Times