That’s all from me for now, Gordon Manning will have a report on proceedings later.
Ladies Gaelic Football Association CEO Lyn Savage and Camogie Association president Brian Molloy discuss how, when integration is achieved, it’s important that women’s football and camogie are properly represented and that it has to be seen as a “new GAA”.
GAA president Jarlath Burns says he will not be president for when it will happen but would love for it to be achieved by 2028. He says they need to move from aspiration to action.
He says it would be difficult to achieve the three congresses and have it ratified by 2028 but he thinks it’s better to do it incrementally, unlike Molloy, who believes the focus should be on structures first and then the rest.
Brennan says that some of the people in the room will no longer be here next year and the next president has said it could take eight years, that leaves a feeling of disconnect, he asks for reassurance? He says it would go down like a lead balloon if they have to wait another eight years.
Burns says he can’t speak for Derek and needs to be cool and calm, they’ve missed one deadline, they haven’t abandoned integration. He said at all those congresses next year, they should have more concrete deadlines.
Alan Kelly brings up the plan Burns mentioned earlier about three different congresses, in three organisations – one on membership, one on structures and one on the lightbulb moment.
Molloy says that was a suggestion by the GAA, not by the Camogie Association. He says it hasn’t been ratified and not the opinion of all organisations. He said that it was their opinion that all could be agreed within a 12-month period, with the two congresses next year so that it was all done by 2028.
Savage says they haven’t set a position on their timeline on congresses.
Alan Kelly speaks for the case of Mary McAleese that as a former president she would have felt like she was promising things to the people and when timelines weren’t met she was letting people down.
He asks the Department of Sport what the timeline is, but Cian Ó Lionáin, assistant secretary general with responsibility for sport, says he is waiting on the three organisations but it has been agreed it is important that there is action at congresses in 2027.
Ahearn asks Sport Ireland what can it do to ensure timelines are hit?
Nora Stapleton of Sport Ireland says it has a lot of experience to guide and it’s important there are key milestones inserted where they can track, follow and see transparency in what is happening.
Garret Ahearn of Fine Gael says there is an undercurrent of messaging from certain people in the GAA regarding it being difficult to work with Mary McAleese.
Burns says strongly that he wouldn’t say that and that didn’t come from himself or GAA director general Tom Ryan Ryan. He says he is not responsible for what other people might say.
He says that McAleese is a woman of the utmost integrity, erudition and academic ability, and they worked well with her on the process.
GAA president Jarlath Burns speaks about the federation model concept that the GAA has with handball and rounders, and how it was explored as a concept.
The Camogie Association was against the model and want full integration, whereas LGFA was more open to it. He says whatever definition you want to give integration is up to the people.
Some clever wordplay on the Bon Jovi reference by Senator Rónán Mullen as he says they were “living on a prayer” from August 30th thinking everything would be fine. He says why didn’t they tell us some of their fears in a previous meeting with the Oireachtas?
Burns keeps the Bon Jovi references going by saying the line “we’re halfway there”, which gets plentiful laughs. He says McAleese said there were “pockets of resistance” and he said there were some “anxieties”.
Peter “Chap” Cleere from Fianna Fáil asks how would life be different for an 11-year-old girl for example after integration.
GAA president Jarlath Burns says it depends whether she is in a one-club model. If she is in a one-club model with fairness and equality already then it won’t change, he says.
But those who experience unfairness with facilities will see a change when they bring in infrastructure under the new organisation, he says.
Aengus Ó Snodaigh of Sinn Féin asks what is the timetable, similar to earlier questions.
GAA director general Tom Ryan says it will take years for it all to come together. He says it is a huge undertaking, the biggest thing the organisation has ever done. He says it cannot be done quickly and simply and needs to be done right.
Burns is asked what are the “insurmountable challenges” that are delaying things.
He says what the exact structures would be at the highest level. He says they had plans where there would be a GAA president and two vice-presidents from the other two organisations to make sure all the power was not resting solely with the GAA.
That was seen by some as the GAA getting the president and that was a long-term set structure, which would not have helped people in the LGFA and Camogie to agree. Burns and Savage say they are looking to improve their communication.
Ennis asks what supports are given to county boards regarding alleviating fears.
Ryan says supporting the intercounty game is a challenge financially, but it brings a big benefit. He says he has a new licensing programme next year, to seek to codify the level of backroom staff that goes into a team and to help counties to manage costs.
He says it would be remiss not to deal with those issues first before transporting them on to a new organisation.
Daniel Ennis of the Social Democrats asks what the deadline is for integration?
Burns says there will never be a deadline because they are a constantly evolving movement. That whenever they think they have enough facilities there will always be something else.
Ennis talks about a female charter for minimum standards for Gaelic sports players, there was talk of a €1 million funding three years ago, which expires this year, and it wasn’t to be negotiated as integration was supposed to be done by 2027.
Savage says the charter is up to the end of this year and they asked for it to roll over. She says they have added to it – €1.6 million, over 10 per cent of their income for the charter. Support for all the workings of the organisation.
Ní Chuilinn says false narratives and some GAA figures that went out to the public were damaging to the process. She asks were they discussed in the Steering Group on Integration to Molloy.
Molloy says the €90 million figure (double the €45 million currently) mentioned by Burns was a factual statement. He said they received feedback from the GAA into the steering group that there was significant concern. The primary perspective was the cost of elite intercounty teams and how that was going to be dealt with post-integration.
Evanne Ní Chuilinn of Fine Gael, speaking about the GAA, says that a previous motion was too vague. Tom Ryan says motions have to be forensic in detail. She asks about the day the position paper was written up. Ryan says he is not sure of the date but it was about the time of the Bon Jovi concert.
She says the GAA has done a body of work on integration so how is the GAA not prepared in its words?
He says there is the staff part, but there is also the voluntary part.
GAA director general Tom Ryan says they have agreed to nominate someone to lead the process and that person will be formally ratified in the next 24 hours and will be announced in the next few days.
Joanna Byrne TD from Sinn Féin talks about equality for pitches, fixtures and other things for men and women. She asks how they go forward in that regard and about timelines?
Burns says the February 2027 congresses will have much more specific motions. On equality, he says there was a lot of comment and misunderstood comment. Equality, he says, is that all 32 counties can go into the Liam MacCarthy Cup. He says equity is putting the strongest counties in the Liam MacCarthy Cup and using money to fund the other counties in other competitions so that there is full participation.
He says he has two daughters who play Gaelic football and two granddaughters who will play camogie. He says he wants to get to the situation where they have a rightful place within the GAA but says they have to do it in a way that is right.
Malcolm Byrne of Fianna Fáil says he heard that the timeline being rushed could have scuppered the project and the worst thing would be to bring proposals that were defeated. He asks why there is a fear that the proposals were being defeated.
Tom Ryan, GAA director general, says people were fearful and it is a tricky process. He said he listened to people and you have a responsibility to hear the feedback. He said he would have been approaching something that they wouldn’t have been comfortable with, based off feedback from the roadshows.
Lyn Savage, CEO of LGFA, said it was a brave decision to halt things as they knew there was going to be a backlash but they had to make sure things were right. They needed more time to make sure the structures were there. Brian Molloy, president of the Camogie Association, says for them there was no point in having a special congress if the GAA wasn’t having one. He says they got to a point, where the three organisations realised they weren’t ready.
Brennan asks what the timeline is again. He says if it was up to Tom Ryan and him, it would have been in 2016 when it was first proposed. Brennan says they don’t know how much it costs?
Burns says if they want to address everything properly, it is going to cost a lot of money for infrastructure. He says he is not going to give exact costs but he met the Minister for Sport.
He says if they give out costs today, it will be used against them as the GAA is throwing out costs to be prohibitive and not supportive of the process.
He says he has proposed a plan to get that money in. He said he doesn’t want to get all the Government’s money.
Brian Brennan of Fine Gael talks about the importance of the GAA in small towns and villages. He asks Burns why McAleese left. Brennan said she made a strong statement that the GAA had no vision for the future.
He talks about 22 infrastructure projects and says the GAA gives the Camogie Association a €500,000 grant every year and it has committed €2 million for accommodation for integration on the Croke Park campus. He says they do various things together like broadcasting, advertising, commercial and ticketing. He says they put out a statement to get people to come to the camogie final and that there are many double-headers with the two organisations.
He says what McAleese said is not characterised by reality or on the ground.
He says she resigned because she was adamant they were going to reach every deadline that they had. And once she realised they were going to miss the first deadline, she decided she was going to walk away from the process, which was disappointing, he says.
Comyn says there have been concerns about resistance to women having a meaningful role in senior decision making, is that a myth?
Burns says it is regrettable that it is seen by some as a gender issue, he says some of the best females are working in the GAA and some of the best males are working in the other two organisations. He says women have genuine influence.
Cian Ó Lionáin, assistant secretary general with responsibility for sport says the department is satisfied that women have influence in the GAA.
He says there will be three congresses each for it to happen and if there are any doubts, then they have to go back and revise. He says a nightmare scenario would be if they were getting messages that one county wasn’t ready.
Comyn asks what are the timelines then?
He says not to get caught up on timelines, but he says camogie are keen by 2028. He says he hopes by 2027 Congress, they would have motions going to the floor that are very specific where you can take an implementation committee to start working on what is agreed. He hopes they would lead out a very navigable path where everyone knows where they stand.
Alison Comyn of Fianna Fáil says McAleese is not prone to hyperbole, and that she said the situation was “devastating” and “heartbreaking”. She asks why did McAleese say that?
Burns says he thought the last meeting before McAleese stepped down was positive and they were surprised. He says there were differing perspectives when they spoke to people on the road. He says they were not ready to have a special congress on structures.
He says the Camogie Association and LGFA were voting themselves into extinction and had to have structures in place for what they were going into. He says they are back on the wagon and they want it happen.
The meeting is under way now.
Chaired by Labour TD Alan Kelly, who is explaining parliamentary privileges.
The leadership of all three Gaelic games associations are braced for an interrogation on integration when they sit before an Oireachtas committee on this afternoon, writes Gordon Manning.
The foremost officials from the GAA (director general Tom Ryan and president Jarlath Burns), LGFA (CEO Lyn Savage and president Trina Murray) and Camogie Association (CEO Karen Dessain-Gelinet and president Brian Molloy) will attend the 12.30pm meeting
Rather than submitting separate opening statements, the three organisations – in a clear desire to demonstrate solidarity – will deliver joint opening remarks.
Read Manning’s full report here.
The Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport will meet to examine the ongoing process to integrate the GAA, LGFA and Camogie Association.
The meeting takes place between 12.30pm and 2.30pm at Leinster House.
It will examine where the process stands, the reasons for the revised timetable and hear how the organisations intend to address the outstanding issues.
The committee will also discuss the reasons behind Mary McAleese’s decision to step down as chair of the Steering Group on Integration.
The former president of Ireland launched a stinging criticism of the GAA’s leadership last month after stepping down.
She criticised the GAA’s management committee as being “less than impressive” and “lacking in vision”, adding that the decision to resign had left her “devastated”.


















