Muslim cultural centre for Clonmel gets go ahead

Pleanála rejects appeal claiming development a mosque with traffic and noise issues

Clonmel locals claim the proposed development is a mosque as it would be used for prayers five times daily. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw

Clonmel locals claim the proposed development is a mosque as it would be used for prayers five times daily. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw

 

Planning permission has been granted for a new cultural centre, including prayer rooms, for Muslims living in Clonmel, Co Tipperary, despite strong opposition from a large group of local residents.

An Bord Pleanála rejected an appeal by the residents against the decision of Tipperary County Council to approve the proposed development by the Tipperary Islamic Cultural Centre at Irishtown in Clonmel.

Locals claimed the proposed development should more correctly be described as a mosque as it would be used between 6am and 10pm with prayers five times daily.

However, the TICC said a building had to have certain requirements to be classified as a mosque under Islamic sacred law which excluded other activities taking place inside it.

“A building is not a mosque simply because five daily prayers are performed in it,” the TICC said.

An inspector with An Bord Pleanála said the building was not a traditional mosque and its description as a cultural centre was “accurate and acceptable”.

The plans provide for the demolition of an existing derelict building and the construction of a new two-storey centre which will provide for a number of activities including prayers, mother and toddler groups, breastfeeding facilities, a library, canteen and youth club.

The board ruled that the centre, subject to a number of planning conditions, would not seriously injure residential or visual amenities of adjoining properties.

Congested area

It claimed the proposed building represented “an appropriate type and scale of development at this location and would be acceptable in terms of pedestrian and traffic safety and convenience”.

Residents from Irishtown, Albert Street and St Mary’s Place in Clonmel complained the centre including the prayer rooms would generate a lot of additional noise and disturbance as well as traffic in an already congested area.

More than 200 local residents had signed submissions which also raised concern that the new building would overshadow other houses.

They claimed older people living in Irishtown would be nervous that people would be in their area late at night or in the early hours of the morning.

The objectors said the council’s decision to approve the project was “outrageous” and “absolutely mind-boggling”, especially as it had refused planning permission for four two-bed townhouses a short distance away because it would create a traffic hazard.

“There are so many more suitable sites in Clonmel where overdevelopment, overpopulation, traffic hazard and public safety are not an issue,” said the main appellant, Bernie Reidy.

The TICC, a registered charity, which is currently based at a smaller premises in Clonmel, provided reassurance to the planning authorities that there would be no amplified call to prayer from the new centre.

Potential misunderstandings

It claimed the largest number attending prayers would be up to 50 on a Friday afternoon.

The centre pointed out that half the Muslim community in Clonmel consisted of doctors working in South Tipperary General Hospital where there was also a room for prayer.

The TICC said there were a number of potential misunderstandings about the sort of activities that would be carried out in the centre and concerns that there would be hordes of people accessing the building throughout the night were “incorrect and unfounded”.

It claimed two-thirds of people using the facility were living within one mile of the site, which would eliminate the need for them to use cars

The TICC said the centre would generate significantly fewer vehicles than when the building was the location for a large car showroom.

It also noted the height of the cultural centre would only be slightly higher than the existing building on the site.