State paid out almost €315m on medical negligence claims last year

Total cost of all claims falls 7% compared with previous year's figures

The single biggest award for damages was for more than €22.6 million to an individual who suffered cerebral palsy during birth complications in hospital.  Photograph: Chris Maddaloni/Collins

The single biggest award for damages was for more than €22.6 million to an individual who suffered cerebral palsy during birth complications in hospital. Photograph: Chris Maddaloni/Collins

 

Almost €315 million was paid out in damages in settlement of medical negligence claims together with associated legal costs last year, according to new figures released by the Department for Health.

More than €245 million was paid out by the State in awards for clinical care cases in 2020 with related legal and expert witness costs adding almost €70 million to the total bill for processing such claims.

The figures contained in response to a parliamentary question from Social Democrat co-leader Catherine Murphy show that legal costs for claimants amounted to just more than €47 million, with the State’s own legal costs totalling almost €22.7 million.

The total cost of all claims at €314.8 million is a 7 per cent decrease on the bill for handling similar claims in 2019, which totalled €339.6 million.

Biggest award

The latest figures provided by Minister for Health Stephen Donnelly show the State Claims Agency, which handles all personal injury cases on behalf of State bodies, paid out awards for medical negligence totalling €245,066,025 in 2020.

The top five largest individual payouts amounted to a total of €77.2 million – almost a third of all awards made by the agency under the Clinical Indemnity Scheme.

The single biggest award for damages was for more than €22.6 million to an individual who suffered cerebral palsy during birth complications in hospital.

Three other awards of €18.4 million, €14.8 million and €12 million were also made to people who suffered cerebral palsy during delivery in a maternity hospital.

The fifth largest award of €9.4 million was made to a person who suffered catastrophic non-brain injury in hospital.

The figures relate to cases settled during 2020, although the claims can date back over a long period of time.