A year after Wuhan, China spins a tale of heroism and triumph

No mistakes admitted as Beijing portrays pandemic narrative as a Communist Party-led victory

People dance in a public area along the Yangtze River in Wuhan on Monday  as the city marks the first anniversary of when China confirmed its first death from the Covid-19 coronavirus. Photograph: Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images

People dance in a public area along the Yangtze River in Wuhan on Monday as the city marks the first anniversary of when China confirmed its first death from the Covid-19 coronavirus. Photograph: Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images

 

At a museum in Wuhan, China, a sprawling exhibition paints a stirring tale of how the city’s sacrifices in a brutal 76-day lockdown led to triumph over the coronavirus and, ultimately, rebirth.

No costs appear to have been spared for the show, which features a hologram of medical staff members moving around a hospital room, heart-rending letters from frontline health workers and a replica of a mass quarantine site, complete with beds, miniature Chinese flags and toothbrush cups.

But the exhibition is also striking for what is not included. There is no mention of the whistleblowing role of Ai Fen, one of the first doctors to sound the alarm in Wuhan, where the virus is believed to have originated, or the decision by Zhang Yongzhen, a Shanghai doctor, to share its genome with the world against official orders.

Visitors are invited to lay a virtual chrysanthemum at a wall of martyrs that includes Li Wenliang, the ophthalmologist at a Wuhan hospital whose death from the virus led to nationwide mourning. But missing from his brief biography is a crucial fact: that Li was reprimanded by the government for warning colleagues about the virus from which he later died.

A vigil in Hong Kong on February 7th, 2020, for Dr Li Wenliang, the ophthalmologist at a Wuhan hospital who died from Covid-19. Li was reprimanded by the Chinese government for warning colleagues about the virus. Photograph: Lam Yik Fei/New York Times
A vigil in Hong Kong on February 7th, 2020, for Dr Li Wenliang, the ophthalmologist at a Wuhan hospital who died from Covid-19. Li was reprimanded by the Chinese government for warning colleagues about the virus. Photograph: Lam Yik Fei/New York Times

China has spent much of the past year trying to spin the narrative of the pandemic as an undisputed victory led by the ruling Communist Party. The state-run news media has largely ignored the government’s missteps and portrayed China’s response as proof of the superiority of its authoritarian system, especially compared to that of the United States and other democracies, which are still struggling to contain raging outbreaks.

Those efforts have taken on new urgency as the January 23rd anniversary of Wuhan’s lockdown draws closer. In recent weeks, the government has deployed an army of censors to scrub the internet of critical coverage of the Wuhan outbreak. Terms like “first anniversary” and “whistleblower” have been deleted at times from Chinese sites.

A recent propaganda directive explicitly banned coverage of the anniversary of the outbreak, according to journalists at state-run news outlets who were briefed on the order. Instead, propaganda agencies have pushed feel-good videos and adulatory articles that depict Wuhan as a city reborn, while playing down residents’ lingering grief and anger.

Rebranding campaign

The praise for Wuhan’s success is well deserved. Since the lockdown ended in April, life in the city – long known as a bustling commercial hub where tourists flock to eat fiery sesame noodles, listen to punk music and catch a glimpse of the mighty Yangtze River – has largely returned to normal, as it has in most of China.

While many people in virus-ravaged countries rang in 2021 alone in their homes, images of crowded New Year’s Eve celebrations in Wuhan were splashed across Chinese state media.

People stand around a giant 3D screen on Jianghan street in Wuhan on Sunday, the eve of the first anniversary of China confirming its first death from the Covid-19 coronavirus. Photograph: Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images
People stand around a giant 3D screen on Jianghan street in Wuhan on Sunday, the eve of the first anniversary of China confirming its first death from the Covid-19 coronavirus. Photograph: Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images

But with nationalism and public support for the party apparently on the rise, the assertive rebranding campaign is a sign that China’s leaders have little interest in dwelling on the past or revisiting their mistakes. Their goal, experts say, is simple: to ensure that nothing undermines the party’s triumphant narrative.

“China’s response was portrayed as a huge victory for the Chinese Communist Party,” said David Bandurski, co-director of the China Media Project, a research programme affiliated with the University of Hong Kong. “For China’s leaders, the story is written.”

Long wary of sensitive anniversaries, Chinese authorities have released few details about how they will mark the sombre occasion. So far, the only event on the official calendar is the January 22nd release of a state-backed documentary, Days and Nights in Wuhan.

Billed as a moving tribute to the city’s “ordinary heroes”, it features a song called You Are So Kind by the well-known Chinese actor Zhou Xun, whose gentle lyrics, in the words of one state media outlet, are meant to convey “warm power.”

Recent state media coverage of Wuhan has mostly focused on the city’s booming tourism and economic revival. A video produced by CCTV, the state broadcaster, draws on interviews with workers at one of the city’s railway stations to spin a tale of courage and sacrifice during the lockdown. Within three days, it had more than 2.5 million views on Weibo, a popular social media platform.

Another widely circulated video, recently posted by the state-backed Changjiang Daily newspaper, features business managers from companies such as Lenovo and Gree extolling the city for its rapid recovery. “What doesn’t kill me will only make me stronger,” the narrator says as dramatic orchestral music swells in the background.

Propaganda

Officials, too, are playing up the themes of revival and rebirth. Wang Zhonglin, the city’s top party official, spoke loftily of Wuhan’s ambitions at a December forum promoting economic development along the Yangtze River. “Do not slow down efforts to work toward becoming an international metropolis,” he said of Wuhan. “Rise up from the ashes and achieve glory once again.”

The upswell in propaganda has been carried out alongside tightened controls on the media. A year ago, Chinese news outlets – which are sometimes censored less heavily than usual in the first days of a crisis – published some of the hardest-hitting exposés of the government’s sluggish response to the virus and failures in the health care system.

But in recent weeks, Chinese journalists say, editors have told them to avoid drawing attention to the lockdown’s anniversary on social media sites. Some said they were also instructed to abandon plans to interview people who lost relatives in the earliest stages of the outbreak.

People walk on a street in Wuhan on Sunday, J the eve of the first anniversary of China confirming its first death from the Covid-19 coronavirus. Photograph: Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images
People walk on a street in Wuhan on Sunday, J the eve of the first anniversary of China confirming its first death from the Covid-19 coronavirus. Photograph: Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images

The government underscored its message to the media last month when it sentenced Zhang Zhan, a 37-year-old citizen journalist who documented Wuhan’s ordeal, to four years in prison. She is the first person known to have faced trial for chronicling China’s outbreak.

The censorship around the anniversary is part of an ongoing campaign to purge voices that question the official narrative. Activists have been detained, and outspoken relatives of people who died from the virus are routinely harassed. A study last year by the Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto found that thousands of keywords related to the pandemic were censored on WeChat, a popular messaging app; many of the deleted posts were critical of Chinese officials.

People walk on Jianghan street in Wuhan on Sunday, the eve of the first anniversary of China confirming its first death from the Covid-19 coronavirus. Photograph: Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images
People walk on Jianghan street in Wuhan on Sunday, the eve of the first anniversary of China confirming its first death from the Covid-19 coronavirus. Photograph: Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images

Authorities are particularly sensitive about efforts to pay homage to Li, the Wuhan ophthalmologist whose death prompted rare calls for freedom of speech in China. Several recent articles recalling Li’s actions have been erased from the internet.

At the same time, Global Times, a state-backed nationalist tabloid, has sought to reframe the legacy of the doctor, who has become a hero to many Chinese. “Observers said that for Chinese mainland people, Li was not a figure representing an opposition or confrontational force with Chinese authorities as some international politicians and media have reported,” a recent article read. “Rather, Dr Li was an ordinary hero with the courage to speak out the truth, Chinese observers said.”

Heroes

The government’s aim is “to create a state-approved version of the collective memory of the coronavirus pandemic for the public,” said Lotus Ruan, a researcher at the Citizen Lab.

Within the official narrative of the pandemic, there are many heroes. But China’s top leader, Xi Jinping, is undoubtedly the star. At the cavernous exhibition hall in Wuhan, visitors are greeted with a large photo of Xi, looking stern as he presides over a meeting.

A nearly 15m-long timeline chronicles the heroic measures that Xi is said to have taken during the crisis, day by day. Throughout the show, he is portrayed as having been a resolute leader in control of the outbreak almost from the beginning, although there is limited evidence of that.

“The Chinese people have shown resilience, diligence and bravery,” the show’s concluding text reads. “And the Communist Party of China, like always, has put people and their lives first.” – New York Times

The Irish Times Logo
Commenting on The Irish Times has changed. To comment you must now be an Irish Times subscriber.
SUBSCRIBE
GO BACK
Error Image
The account details entered are not currently associated with an Irish Times subscription. Please subscribe to sign in to comment.
Comment Sign In

Forgot password?
The Irish Times Logo
Thank you
You should receive instructions for resetting your password. When you have reset your password, you can Sign In.
The Irish Times Logo
Please choose a screen name. This name will appear beside any comments you post. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our community standards.
Screen Name Selection

Hello

Please choose a screen name. This name will appear beside any comments you post. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our community standards.

The Irish Times Logo
Commenting on The Irish Times has changed. To comment you must now be an Irish Times subscriber.
SUBSCRIBE
Forgot Password
Please enter your email address so we can send you a link to reset your password.

Sign In

Your Comments
We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Standards. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or by filling out this form. New comments are only accepted for 3 days from the date of publication.