Michelle O’Neill says the law is ‘wrong’ in Orange Order Drumcree march row

Court of Appeal in Belfast has reserved judgment on a fresh legal challenge to Portadown march

A PSNI vehicle at the Garvaghy Road. Photograph: Brian Lawless/PA Wire
A PSNI vehicle at the Garvaghy Road. Photograph: Brian Lawless/PA Wire

Main Points

  • The Court of Appeal in Belfast has reserved judgment on a fresh legal challenge to the Orange march at the centre of the Drumcree standoff in Portadown
  • The two sides remain deadlocked despite days of talks facilitated by Northern Ireland secretary of state Chris Bryant last week
  • First Minister Michelle O’Neill says the law is “wrong” in the Drumcree case as she faces criticism of her stance in dispute
  • Irish rap trio Kneecap visited the Garvaghy Road to show their support for the protesters on Sunday
  • Church leaders have called for calm in a joint statement

Key Reads


Ronan McGreevy - 34 days ago

Judgment reserved in latest legal challenge to Orange parade

Judgment has been reserved in the latest legal challenge to the Orange parade at the centre of the Drumcree standoff in Portadown, writes our Northern editor Freya McClements.

Three senior judges at the Court of Appeal in Belfast heard submissions on Monday from barristers representing the Garvaghy Road Residents’ Coalition and the Parades Commission.

The residents are challenging an earlier High Court decision to refuse leave to apply for a judicial review of the determination by the commission to permit the Orange Order to parade from Drumcree church along the Garvaghy Road on September 27th.

They were not able to proceed after the road was blocked by residents, and the standoff is continuing in the area with protesters maintaining a presence.

Denise Kiley, appearing for the residents, argued the Parades Commission had failed to “properly weigh” information from the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) around the potential for disorder.

She said it “didn’t properly understand the police assessment”, and therefore reached an “irrational conclusion” in permitting it to go ahead.

The barrister for the Parades Commission, Tony McGleenan, said the body was “fully briefed” by police, including “about the police resource and their ability to contain any disorder or reaction that occurred”.

He said the suggestion it had made a legal error “doesn’t bear scrutiny” and that just because people disagree with the outcome “doesn’t make it irrational”.

Richard McConkey, who represents a member of the Orange Order from Portadown, said: “Our position is obviously that the appeal should be dismissed.”

You can read the full report from McClements here.


Ronan McGreevy - 34 days ago

Church leaders call for calm over Drumcree standoff

In a joint statement, the Catholic Archbishop of Armagh Eamon Martin and his Church of Ireland counterpart, Archbishop John McDowell, have appealed for peace and respect for the rule of law to build trust between communities.

The standoff at Drumcree Church sees no sign of ending. A ruling in the legal challenge against the decision to allow an Orange Order parade along the Garvaghy Road has been reserved by the Northern Ireland Court of Appeal.

Three judges heard the appeal by an applicant on behalf of residents who live on the route of the contentious parade.

In their joint statement, the archbishops posed the question: “How can we be good neighbours to each other?”

They also encouraged Christians to consider what would be generous and for the common good.

“We acknowledge the real hurt left by past violence, and the fragility of the present situation. We caution against language that inflames division and urge people to make space for a peaceful way forward,” they said.

“We call for an urgent, constructive, inclusive and reconciling initiative to help find a way through this crisis.

“We ask all Christians, and all people of good will, on the island and beyond, to pray for peace, healing and reconciliation at this time. This prayer offers a way to pray, and a challenge to live: to let the love of God and neighbour shape our words and actions.”

Orange Order representatives Carla Lockhart, Jamie Bryson and TUV Leader Jim Allister speak to the media outside the High Court in Belfast following a reserved judgment. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire
Orange Order representatives Carla Lockhart, Jamie Bryson and TUV Leader Jim Allister speak to the media outside the High Court in Belfast following a reserved judgment. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire

Ronan McGreevy - 34 days ago

O’Neill vows to continue to support Garvaghy Road residents

Northern Ireland First Minister Michelle O’Neill has said she would continue “turning up” for residents of the Garvaghy Road and described the law as “wrong”.

Appearing for an urgent oral question in the Northern Ireland Assembly, O’Neill said that “when the law is wrong, I will stand firmly against it”.

“It is morally wrong what’s happening to the people on the Garvaghy Road,” she added.

The First Minister has been accused of “breaking the law” for supporting the Garvaghy Road residents who opposed a determination by the Parades Commission to allow an Orange Order parade along the road for the first time in almost 30 years.

The parade has not taken place because police said they could not facilitate it with the crowds gathered on the Garvaghy Road in opposition.

Sinn Féin Ministers and elected representatives from Sinn Féin, the SDLP and People Before Profit have also been criticised for being present on the Garvaghy Road.

Earlier at Parliament Buildings, DUP leader Gavin Robinson insisted it cannot be “business as normal” at Stormont following alleged “law breaking” by Sinn Féin Ministers, claiming 40 political representatives had “broken the law”.

There were sharp exchanges between MLAs over Drumcree during questions for the Executive Office in the Assembly, which were taken by Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly.

Sinn Féin MLA Deirdre Hargey challenged her on the Loyalist Communities Council giving evidence to the Parades Commission.

Little-Pengelly responded saying Sinn Féin’s “brass neck beggars belief” after the party stood “shoulder to shoulder with dissidents, with Provos, with those with appalling convictions”.

SDLP MLA Justin McNulty said he was “very proud to stand with the residents of the Garvaghy Road”, and Little-Pengelly responded that she was “disappointed” by him “justifying your actions” and “dancing to the beat of a dissident drum”.

“I do think it’s deeply disappointing, and I would suggest that you should apologise for that,” she added.

TUV leader Jim Allister challenged the DUP to ensure consequences for Northern Ireland’s “First Minister of lawlessness” by withdrawing its Deputy First Minister, Emma Little-Pengelly, from the Executive.


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Mac Cionnaith: ‘I don’t think we have anything to regret so far’

Breandán Mac Cionnaith from the Garvaghy Road Residents’ Coalition said it had been made very clear to Appeal Court judges what the situation is in relation to the Drumcree parade.

He said: “We believe all the arguments have been made, have been listened to.”

“Our legal team put forward all the arguments.

“They were very clear on what the situation was in relation to the parade and I don’t think we have anything to regret so far.”

He added: “I am not going to pre-judge the outcome.”


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

‘Whatever the decision is, we will abide by it,’ says Bryson

Jamie Bryson said there was a contrast between Orangemen in Drumcree and what he described as a “mob” on the Garvaghy Road.

He said: “What has happened today is that those who have disobeyed the law all week, defied the law, stood in defiance of it, have come back before the court and are now trying to use the law.”

Bryson added: “We will abide by the law, we have abided by the law from the start and whatever the decision is, we will abide by it.

“We approached this as a question of law.

“Last night, while more mobs were brought on to the Garvaghy Road, Orangemen were holding a prayer meeting, praying for the people who hate them.

“That is what is going on.

“The contrast we have here is the law and the mob and we stand on the side of the law.”


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Bryson says abuse towards DUP MP Carla Lockhart is ‘absolutely vile’

TUV leader Jim Allister (left), DUP's  Carla Lockhart and Orange Order legal representative and Loyalist spokesperson Jamie Bryson (far right) outside Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire
TUV leader Jim Allister (left), DUP's Carla Lockhart and Orange Order legal representative and Loyalist spokesperson Jamie Bryson (far right) outside Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire

DUP MP Carla Lockhart has had to receive security protection due to abuse received over the Drumcree parading dispute, Jamie Bryson has said.

Speaking outside the Appeal Court in Belfast, Bryson, who acts as legal adviser for the Portadown Orange Order, was loudly booed and heckled as he tried to speak to the media.

He said: “Those who stood on the steps of this court and called the mob down here have to take responsibility for what the mob has done.”

Turning to Lockhart, he added: “The abuse this woman has taken is absolutely vile. The behaviour at the weekend is absolutely vile.

“This woman now requires protection.

“Those who called this mob to this court have to take responsibility.

“I don’t care about me, but what has happened to this female politician is absolutely scandalous.”

Lockhart said: “It is a sad reflection on society when you stand outside court and you are abused, threatened.

“It has been utterly disgraceful, some of the behaviour over the last week.

“I want to say to all of those abusing, they won’t deter me from doing what I do and for standing up for Portadown Orange District LOL Number 1 who deserve the right to fulfil their legal determination to walk the Garvaghy Road.

“It is a difficult day for Northern Ireland whenever you see lawbreakers trying to flout and use the courts,” she said.


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Deputy First Minister claims Sinn Féin ‘flooded Garvaghy Road for electioneering’

Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly said Sinn Féin "flooded the Garvaghy Road for electioneering". Photograph: Liam McBurney/PA Wire
Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly said Sinn Féin "flooded the Garvaghy Road for electioneering". Photograph: Liam McBurney/PA Wire

Northern Ireland’s Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly has accused First Minister Michelle O’Neill of choosing not to issue a joint statement with her calling for calm at Drumcree.

Speaking during questions for the Executive Office, Little-Pengelly claimed Sinn Féin “flooded the Garvaghy Road for electioneering”.

“I reached out to the First Minister and I asked her to put out a statement to call for calm,” she said.

“I reached out to the First Minister and asked her to stand with me to call people off the streets and in terms of moving forward together – and this is the reality – she chose to follow the law of the mob instead of the law of the land.

“She chose Sinn Féin politics over her responsibilities as Minister, and that is shameful.”


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Judgment reserved in fresh legal challenge to Orange march

Judgement has been reserved in the fresh legal challenge to the Orange march at the centre of the Drumcree standoff in Portadown, reports Northern Editor Freya McClements.

Lady Chief Justice Siobhan Keegan told the Court of Appeal in Belfast she hoped to give a decision “within a swift enough timeframe” but could not give a date at the conclusion of Monday’s hearing.

Breandán Mac Cionnaith, of the Garvaghy Road Residents’ Coalition, which opposes the march, is seeking leave to apply for a judicial review of the decision by the Parades Commission to allow it to proceed.

More to follow.


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Memory of what happened in the 1990s relates to something ‘categorically different’

Members of the Garvaghy Road Residents' Coalition arrive at Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire
Members of the Garvaghy Road Residents' Coalition arrive at Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire

Barrister Tony McGleenan, representing the Parades Commission, said the residents were attempting to “make some forensic play” in asserting a difference between what the police told the commission and what the commissioners then recorded as the police assessment.

He said “one accurately reflects the other”.

The barrister said legal jurisprudence placed a positive obligation on facilitating the right of assembly.

McGleenan said the residents’ contention that the commission had made a legal error “doesn’t bear scrutiny”.

He described the determination as an “expert judgment by the body set up by Parliament to make these evaluations”.

The barrister said that legal precedent made clear that considerable “deference” should be afforded to statutory decision making bodies.

On the residents’ case that the commission should have explained why it was changing its determination after almost 30 years of prohibiting the parade, McGleenan insisted the commissioners had explained why.

He said the reason lay in the fact that what was proposed by the Orange lodge was very different to what had been applied for before, including in respect of numbers, time of year and symbols and emblems displayed.

McGleenan added: “The folk memory of what happened in the 1990s relates to something that’s categorically different.”


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

DUP will ‘not abdicate its responsibilities’

The DUP said it would “not abdicate its responsibilities” in the political fallout over the Drumcree dispute.

However, DUP leader Gavin Robinson insisted it cannot be “business as normal” at Stormont following alleged “law breaking” by Sinn Féin Ministers, claiming 40 political representatives had “broken the law”.

He was speaking at Parliament Buildings as the parading standoff enters its second week and another legal challenge is being heard.


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

O’Neill called ‘First Minister of lawlessness’ by TUV leader

Jim Allister of the TUV arriving at Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire
Jim Allister of the TUV arriving at Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire

The DUP has been challenged to ensure consequences for Northern Ireland’s “First Minister of lawlessness”.

TUV leader Jim Allister said the DUP should withdraw its Deputy First Minister, Emma Little-Pengelly, to “ensure political consequences for law breaking”.

Allister said the “First Minister of lawlessness says: ‘We’re above the law, the law does not apply to us, we do not accept the law’.”

Michelle O’Neill has said she is standing by the residents of the Garvaghy Road in Portadown, and “it’s up to all of us to collectively and unequivocally stand with the Garvaghy Road residents and to say no to a sectarian, unwanted march”.

The First Minister is scheduled to face an urgent oral question from DUP MLA Phillip Brett on Monday afternoon. - PA


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Parades Commission was ‘fully briefed’ by police

Barrister Tony McGleenan, representing the Parades Commission, told the Court of Appeal that the determination to permit a limited parade down the Garvaghy Road should be read in its entirety.

“It is a detailed 31-paragraph written analysis,” he said.

“And it has to be read in its totality. And there is a grave danger of cherry-picking sentences here and sentences there to suggest a wrong legal test or a misdirection, or that something hasn’t actually been considered.”

McGleenan said police had given an assurance to the commissioners that they had the capacity to deal with any disorder that may have been triggered if a parade was permitted.

He insisted that the commission was “fully briefed” by police on the uncertainty around what might happen.

“They met with the PSNI on the 23rd [September] at a lengthy meeting with them. They were read intelligence briefings. They were briefed about the police resource and their ability to contain any disorder or reaction that occurred. So they have all of that.” - PA


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Drumcree ‘one of the most polarising parades in history of Northern Ireland’

Breandán Mac Cionnaith of the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition outside Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire
Breandán Mac Cionnaith of the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition outside Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire

Barrister Denise Kiley, representing the Garvaghy Road residents, described the Drumcree parade as “one of the most polarising parades in the history of Northern Ireland”.

She said the Parades Commission had a duty to promote an understanding of parading and it had failed to explain why it had reached its determination to permit the parade, particularly as it was the first time in 28 years it had not been banned.

“There is a duty to explain decisions,” said the barrister.

“And where a decision has consistently been made on one basis for 28 years then a change cries out for explanation.”


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Parades Commission reached an ‘irrational conclusion’

The residents’ barrister Denise Kiley said the Parades Commission failed to “properly weigh” what the police had told it about the potential for disorder if the parade was given the go-ahead.

She said the commission’s assertion that there was no specific information from police about a risk of violence did not fully reflect what a senior commander had told it.

The barrister said PSNI Assistant Chief Constable Ryan Henderson told the commission although police had no clear intelligence about any planned disorder, he had also stressed that officers were dealing with an “unclear picture” and that, as a result, police were planning for various scenarios – from a peaceful passing of the parade to an outbreak of violent disorder.

Kiley said the commission’s subsequent conclusion that there was no specific information about the prospect of disorder was “only part of the picture”.

“It doesn’t go on to record the uncertainty and the fact that the position remained unclear,” she said.

The barrister added: “It is clear that what the police were telling the commission was this is unclear, it’s uncertain, and we are preparing for all eventualities.”

She said the commissioners “didn’t properly understand the police assessment” and this impacted their decision to permit the parade.

Kiley said the commission had therefore reached an “irrational conclusion”.


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Human rights and justice groups say ‘rights-based’ approach key to Drumcree resolution

The International Federation of Human Rights (FIDH) and the Committee on the Administration of Justice (CAJ) have issued a joint statement on the ongoing standoff at Drumcree, saying a “transparent and rights-based approach is essential to prevent further escalation”, reports Northern Editor Freya McClements.

“The protection of human rights must remain at the centre of any resolution to the Drumcree dispute,” the organisations said.

In their statement on Monday, the FIDH and CAJ stressed “the authorities have a duty to balance competing rights under the European Convention on Human Rights, including freedom of assembly and the rights of others.

“In this context there have long been recommendations for the ‘right to freedom from sectarian harassment’ affirmed within the Good Friday Agreement to be expressly incorporated in the parading decisions framework,” the bodies said.

“Freedom of assembly is a fundamental right for both those who parade and counter protestors. Where necessary in a democratic society it can be proportionately restricted to protect the rights of others,” said Daniel Holder, vice-president of FIDH and director of CAJ.

“The Parades Commission decision did not properly consider that the Drumcree parade was inevitably going to require balancing two competing rights of assembly, nor is there consideration of the risks of sectarian intimidation.

“Transparency and a human rights-based approach across all relevant issues are essential for future decisions,” he said.

FIDH and CAJ welcomed that to date all assemblies have been peaceful and that there has been no use of force by the police, but raised “concerns at the continued discourse of ‘illegality’ being applied to counter-protesters.

“We also draw attention to ECHR-case law which has held that in certain circumstances rights to hold spontaneous peaceful protests in immediate response to events where the protest would be pointless if delayed may override notification requirements,” they said.


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

It is in the public interest to ensure the Parades Commission came to ‘correct’ decisions

Orange Order legal representative and loyalist spokesperson Jamie Bryson (centre) arrives at Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire
Orange Order legal representative and loyalist spokesperson Jamie Bryson (centre) arrives at Laganside Courts in Belfast. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire

A barrister for the Garvaghy Road residents, Denise Kiley KC, has told the Court of Appeal in Belfast that it was in the public interest to ensure the Parades Commission came to correct decisions on parading applications.

The residents are challenging a decision of a High Court judge – made in the early hours of Sunday, September 27th – to refuse leave to apply for a judicial review of the commission’s determination to permit an Orange Order march down the predominantly nationalist road in Portadown later that Sunday.

Opening the case, Kiley said the question of whether the determination remained live – given the time and date of the originally permitted parade have now passed – remained an unresolved issue. However, she said the residents were not currently seeking a court determination on that point.

Outlining the basis of the appeal court challenge, she added: “There is a public interest in ensuring that the Parades Commission – a body charged with making these significant decisions on contentious parading issues – comes to correct and lawful determinations.”


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

Legal challenge to the Orange march in Portadown under way

The fresh legal challenge to the Orange march at the centre of the Drumcree stand-off in Portadown is under way at the Court of Appeal in Belfast, reports Northern Editor Freya McClements.

Breandán Mac Cionnaith, of the Garvaghy Road Residents’ Coalition, which opposes the march, is seeking leave to apply for a judicial review of the decision by the Parades Commission to allow it to proceed.


Katie Mellett - 34 days ago

McDonald accuses Dublin and London governments of creating a ‘vacuum’

Sinn Fein president Mary Lou McDonald speaking at a community event in support of the Garvaghy Road residents in the Drumcree parade dispute. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire
Sinn Fein president Mary Lou McDonald speaking at a community event in support of the Garvaghy Road residents in the Drumcree parade dispute. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire

On Sunday, Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald rejected Taoiseach Micheál Martin’s suggestion that her party has an “overly simplistic” view of how to resolve the Drumcree dispute.

Sinn Féin has repeatedly called on the British government to intervene and stop the Orange Order march.

Martin, on Saturday, said he did not agree with Sinn Féín’s assessment that “Drumcree could be sorted by me simply telling Andy Burnham what to do” and accused the party of lacking “sincerity”.

Asked on the BBC’s Sunday Politics programme if she accepted that “the reality is, it’s not that simple”, McDonald replied: “Well, it is, actually.”

She also accused the Dublin and London governments of creating a “vacuum” by not working towards Irish unity.

While they “sit on their hands and fail to create the democratic space and dynamic for all of us to engage, to discuss, to plan about Ireland’s future, while there is a vacuum there, we are sitting ducks for this kind of reactionary sideswipe from small elements in society who want to upend our progress.”


Katie Mellett - 35 days ago

NI Secretary believes a ‘mutually agreeable solution’ is ‘still possible’

Northern Ireland Secretary of State Chris Bryant said he is continuing to speak with “people of goodwill on all sides,” in a post on X

He believes “a mutually agreeable solution is still possible if people can show leadership based on openness, compromise and magnanimity.”

He was “pleased that events have passed this weekend in Portadown without major incident.”


Katie Mellett - 35 days ago

First Minister to be questioned on her protest participation in Stormont

Northern Ireland First Minister Michelle O'Neill  on stage during a community event in support of the Garvaghy Road residents in the Drumcree parade dispute. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire
Northern Ireland First Minister Michelle O'Neill on stage during a community event in support of the Garvaghy Road residents in the Drumcree parade dispute. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire

On Monday, the ninth day of the sustained stand-of, Northern Ireland First Minister and Sinn Féin deputy leader Michelle O’Neill is expected to face an urgent question on her participation in the protest during plenary business at Stormont.

Under parading laws in Northern Ireland, protests must be notified to and approved by, the Parades Commission adjudication body.

Police have confirmed the protest was unnotified to the commission and therefore unlawful.

Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald has said she and her party will “of course” co-operate with the PSNI over any potential investigation into the Garvaghy Road protest. – PA


Katie Mellett - 35 days ago

Kneecap visit Garvaghy Road to support protesters

(Left to right) Mo Chara (Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh),  DJ Próvaí (J. J. Ó Dochartaigh) and Móglaí Bap (Naoise Ó Cairealláin ) from the band Kneecap at the Garvaghy Road to show support for the Garvaghy Road residents. Photograph: Brian Lawless/PA Wire
(Left to right) Mo Chara (Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh), DJ Próvaí (J. J. Ó Dochartaigh) and Móglaí Bap (Naoise Ó Cairealláin ) from the band Kneecap at the Garvaghy Road to show support for the Garvaghy Road residents. Photograph: Brian Lawless/PA Wire

On Sunday, Irish rap trio Kneecap visited the Garvaghy Road to show their support for the protesters.

They went to a local school before meeting residents at the Drumcree Community Centre on Sunday evening.

In a statement after the visit, the trio said: “Kneecap support the residents of Garvaghy Road, they’re a determined and strong community.

“No community should have to live with sectarian intimidation, racism or hatred. Not here, not now, not anywhere.”


Katie Mellett - 35 days ago

Fresh legal challenge to be heard today

Breandan Mac Cionnaith of the Garvaghy Road Residents coalition  on stage during a community event in support of the Garvaghy Road residents in the Drumcree parade dispute, as a stand-off between the Orange Order and Garvaghy Road residents continued for a seventh day. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire
Breandan Mac Cionnaith of the Garvaghy Road Residents coalition on stage during a community event in support of the Garvaghy Road residents in the Drumcree parade dispute, as a stand-off between the Orange Order and Garvaghy Road residents continued for a seventh day. Photograph: Mark Marlow/PA Wire

A fresh legal challenge will be heard at the Court of Appeal in Belfast on Monday regarding the Orange march at the centre of the Drumcree stand-off in Portadown.

Breandán Mac Cionnaith, of the Garvaghy Road Residents’ Coalition, who oppose the march, is to seek leave to apply for a judicial review of the decision by the Parades Commission to allow it to proceed.

The hearing was originally listed for Friday but was postponed until Monday.

The two sides remain deadlocked despite days of talks facilitated by Northern Ireland Secretary of State Chris Bryant last week.