Psychotherapy group files complaint to EU against Minister for Health over sector standards

Formal complaint ‘not an action we have taken lightly, says IACP chief executive

Four representative organisations have raised concerns over the new counselling and psychotherapy standards. Photo: Tom Werner/Getty
Four representative organisations have raised concerns over the new counselling and psychotherapy standards. Photo: Tom Werner/Getty

An organisation representing counsellors and psychotherapists has filed a formal complaint to the European Commission against the Minister for Health over new standards for the sector.

Last year, Coru, the regulator for health and social care professionals, published new training standards for psychotherapists that will be brought into law after years of the sector calling for Government regulation.

However, four representative organisations have raised concerns that the new standards will lower the quality of training, creating risks for the safety of clients as well as the employability of therapists outside of Ireland.

The organisations are: the Irish Council for Psychotherapy, the Irish Association of Humanistic and Integrative Psychotherapy, Irish Association of Counsellors and Psychotherapists (IACP) and the European Association of Psychotherapy.

The four organisations raised concerns that under the new standards, there is no requirement for personal therapy, no clinical supervision, that clinical practice of only 200 hours is required and that there is no minimum education course length.

The IACP said its complaint to the European Commission relates to its view that the “legally-required proportionality assessment was not properly carried out”.

Lisa Molloy, chief executive of the IACP, said the formal complaint was “not an action we have taken lightly”.

“The IACP has consistently supported robust statutory regulation of counselling and psychotherapy, but regulation must strengthen public protection in practice, not inadvertently weaken established standards or reduce access to services,” she said.

[ Should therapists be in therapy? Unpacking the rift over psychotherapy standards in IrelandOpens in new window ]

“Our legal advice raises questions about whether the EU proportionality requirements were properly addressed in the development of the standards and criteria.”

Molloy warned that if the requirements proceed unchanged, there is a “real risk” of reducing future practitioners “at a time when access to counselling and psychotherapy is critically important”.

“The consequences for accessibility, quality and public protection could be significant and long-lasting,” she said.

“We are calling on the Minister and Coru to pause further implementation while the complaint is examined, engage meaningfully with the profession, educators and placement providers, and ensure that the regulatory system strengthens, rather than destabilises, Ireland’s counselling and psychotherapy services.”

A spokeswoman for the Department of Health said it was aware the IACP has submitted a complaint in relation to the proportionality test and will “engage with the commission as required”.

The spokeswoman said Coru submitted an assessment report to the department, which was then sent to the Department of Further and Higher Education “in line with the proportionality test directive”.

[ Psychotherapy regulator cited ‘wider implications’ in rejecting personal therapy proposalOpens in new window ]

“Throughout its work to regulate designated professions, Coru has continued to work with the Department to ensure compliance with EU requirements under the Directive,” she said.

“Coru and the board are now moving into the next phase of work to introduce regulation of both professions, with a focus on preparing for the approval and monitoring of education and training programmes.”

Coru has consistently defended its standards in response to criticisms from the professional bodies, describing them as “robust” and adding they ensure those entering the profession have the qualifications to provide “safe and effective care”.

“Coru has extensive experience in introducing regulation, having already done so for 12 professions. This has been a universally positive development,” a statement by the regulator previously said.

However, it also noted that concerns regarding the length of education programmes reflect “a misunderstanding of Coru’s role” as it does “not dictate how courses are delivered”.

Furthermore, Coru said that concerns that the standards will make it harder for practitioners to move between EU countries is “inaccurate” and the “opposite is true”.

Shauna Bowers

Shauna Bowers

Shauna Bowers is Health Correspondent of The Irish Times