‘The monster that haunts our nightmares’: Parents address Bouchaker in sentence hearing

52-year-old convicted of eight offences, including attempted murder of three children at Parnell Square

Riad Bouchaker was found guilty of the attempted murder of three children in November 2023 on Dublin’s Parnell Square. Photograph: Gareth Chaney/Collins
Riad Bouchaker was found guilty of the attempted murder of three children in November 2023 on Dublin’s Parnell Square. Photograph: Gareth Chaney/Collins

A mother whose young daughter is severely disabled after being stabbed by Riad Bouchaker during an attack at Dublin’s Parnell Square in 2023 said her family’s life had changed “unrecognisably” and she “wouldn’t wish this on anyone”.

“A child is forever but every parent’s hope is that you build up their strength to take on life once they are old enough,” the woman told the Central Criminal Court in a victim impact statement on Monday.

She and her husband will be caring for their daughter, now aged eight, for the rest of their lives “and we need to be sure she will be looked after when we are gone”.

“Learning about disability has been eye-opening, but I wouldn’t wish this on anyone.”

Her statement was read by Det Garda Shimna Ní Mháirtin during a hearing to decide the sentence to be imposed on Bouchaker.

A CCTV recording of the 15-second attack on the children and a childcare worker was played in court. Bouchaker (52), a native of Algeria of no fixed abode, was convicted by a jury at the Central Criminal Court last July of eight offences, including the attempted murder of three children, connected with the attack.

Judge Tony Hunt, who heard several impact statements, said he would give his sentencing decision at a later date. The maximum for attempted murder is life imprisonment.

Another mother whose daughter suffered a head injury described Bouchaker as a “monster” who had “stolen the innocence” of the 13 children.

“He is the monster that haunts our nightmares,” she said.

Childcare worker Leanne Flynn, who suffered serious stab injuries while trying to protect the children, said her life and that of her partner and two young children had changed drastically.

She had been called “a hero” but should never have had to be one, and hated that her name “will forever be tied to Riad Bouchaker”, she said. Addressing Bouchaker directly, she told him: “Harming innocent children is unforgivable” and she hoped his God “will never forgive you”.

Det Sgt Padraig Cleary said the prosecution case was that Bouchaker intended to kill the children.

The offence relating to Flynn should be considered in the higher range of the maximum sentence – life imprisonment – prosecuting counsel Karl Finnegan said.

Bouchaker’s barrister said his client’s “very clear cognitive limitations” and intellectual limitations should be considered, including in relation to why he contested the case. Bouchaker was unable to understand the concept of legal guilt, counsel said.

The three attempted murder charges related to the severely injured five-year-old girl and to a six-year-old girl and five-year-old boy. He will also be sentenced for assault causing harm to two other children.

Bouchaker was found guilty of intentionally inflicting serious harm on Flynn, who underwent life-saving surgery.

In a victim impact statement, another mother said her injured daughter had told her while lying on the ground at Parnell Square that the attacker “looked like a real man but he was actually a bad man”. Her daughter continues to be afraid of crowds, loud noises, the sight of blood and noise of sirens, and the family have had to stop visiting places such as Croke Park, she said.

Another mother, in her statement, told Bouchaker he had left her son and the other children with “terrifying memories that haunt them to this day”. Addressing him in Irish, the woman said she, like him, was an immigrant to Ireland, which she said was “the best country in the world”.

Bouchaker had also been convicted of assault causing harm to a French teenage chef, Alan Lorena Guille, who had minor scratches to his hand and face after wrenching the knife from Bouchaker’s hand; and of producing a 36cm kitchen carving knife, including a 24cm blade, capable of inflicting serious injury.

During a pretrial hearing, two psychiatrists disagreed on Bouchaker’s fitness to plead arising from an acquired brain injury, caused by pre-existing cognitive impairment combined with injuries suffered during interventions by members of the public. He spent about three weeks in hospital after the incident.

Hunt ruled he was fit to stand trial with assistance of an interpreter and an intermediary.

On Monday, Cleary said gardaí did not know a lot about Bouchaker’s background. He had some relations in Ireland and had not worked since he arrived in the country. He had no previous convictions.

Cleary agreed with counsel that Bouchaker had said a number of times he was grateful nobody had been killed.

“He brought it back to himself every time,” Cleary said. He agreed Bouchaker had made statements that did not make sense and were “completely at odds” with his actions that day.

  • Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date

  • Sign up for push alerts to get the best breaking news, analysis and comment delivered directly to your phone

  • Listen to In The News podcast daily for a deep dive on the stories that matter

Mary Carolan

Mary Carolan

Mary Carolan is the Legal Affairs Correspondent of the Irish Times