The last thing French president Emmanuel Macron needs right now is a letter from me. With lycées (upper secondary schools) blockaded and students and teachers out on the streets from Paris to Marseilles, I reckon he’s occupied enough without my two cents.
I do have two cents to offer though, and until the eruption of these protests, I had assumed that it was only under our roof that the national education system was debated.
In 2019, the same year I emigrated to France, a law was passed which made school compulsory for all children from the age of three. The idea is to place everyone in the same starting blocks, thereby levelling the playing field when it comes to primary school and beyond.
A quick investigation of the complaints from the current school protesters would make you question whether that has had any effect. Dilapidated buildings, absent teachers, diminished resources in places with the greatest need, large classes in urban areas, and long hours don’t sound much like a level playing field to me – much less a fair one.
READ MORE
When I dug a bit deeper, I learned that my own son could stay in school next September from 8.30am until 4.30pm, admittedly with a lunch break and nap included in those hours. And while the very youngest children in the petite section, as it’s called, can leave after the morning session, from age four the length of the school day is cemented. I feel this gives the state a sizeable presence in my toddler’s childhood.
That’s where I become unstuck. France is my family’s home. We go to the local market on Sundays; my son asks for a baguette in the village boulangerie, his French is without an accent. Although I have adopted France and feel adopted in turn, my uncertainty about enrolling my son raises a different question: do I consent to what feels like a co-parenting relationship with the state?
I am a product of the Irish system. The Leaving Certificate, some 17 years ago, still morphs into the occasional nightmare. I find myself asking how far the shadow of those anxious hours of memorisation, ingrained competition for points and university places has stretched across my own life.
What is the equivalent French shadow?
In freezing winter temperatures, my classmates and I wore our Regatta coats over our uniforms for the majority of our lessons, but it would have been a considerable leap to imagine coming together to protest attending those lessons in the first place.
And while I disagree with the violence of the protests, I’ve always admired a certain force in French society: that change is a very tangible thing, not merely an intellectual pursuit held behind closed doors, and that it can be effected by anyone who considers themselves a citizen.
It’s one of the reasons I probably felt I could write to the president about my concerns.
When education begins at three years old, is this one of its shadows?
I am not without options for next year. Montessori, forest schools, private and international schools remain alternative, if expensive, avenues. But I’m not convinced.
If I put my son into the public system, I am consenting for the state to play a significant role in what his education means. If I choose a different route, am I creating a chasm that will make him, though a French national, a citizen without the codes that collective experience provides, school being one of them?
I have until enrolment begins in March to make a decision. For now, the letter on the dresser remains stamped but unsent.
- Are you Irish and living in another country? Would you like to share your experience in writing or by interview? You can use the form below, or email abroad@irishtimes.com.We do not accept submissions written or modified by AI. Irish Times Abroad submission guidelines here.
- Follow us on Instagram to keep up with the latest
- Sign up to The Irish Times Abroad newsletter for Irish-connected people around the world.













