The best of times, the worst of times

The death of Seamus Heaney seemed to unite the country. Photograph: Aidan Crawley

The death of Seamus Heaney seemed to unite the country. Photograph: Aidan Crawley

Fri, Dec 27, 2013, 11:50

One January morning, Julie Howley from Dublin noticed that a homeless man who had been sitting in a doorway every day, had disappeared. In his place were flowers. Not knowing who he was, yet seeking to make sense of his death, she wrote a letter to the Editor of The Irish Times, suggesting that in the centenary year of the Dublin Lockout, his story posed the challenge of our time. “As a society we collectively share a responsibility to challenge the systemic issues that stack the odds against certain people and lead to them living, and sometimes dying, in appalling conditions,” she wrote. “But it is also our job to enable the individual’s story to be heard so that they won’t be just a statistic but a real and full human being.”

In a way, she was articulating an important element of the Letters page: allowing readers’ individual stories to be heard.

She was not alone in drawing attention to the wider political dimensions of a personal story. Among the many letter- writers who did so, Ade Stack in September highlighted how the lack of a homecare package for sick children had impacted on the last months of her son’s life, her message sparking a debate in the news and health supplement pages.

While letters such as these led to news stories, the majority of letters were written in response to major news events. The death of Margaret Thatcher, Seamus Heaney, Nelson Mandela each evoked a large and varied response from our readers. Thatcher divided comment in death as she had in life, summed up by two letters: “From iron to ashes, the Lady’s not returning!” (Eileen Hahessy, Ennis) and “As a mother and teacher of young girls throughout Margaret Thatcher’s long term in office, I feel her greatest legacy was as an example to them that a woman could be a leader,” (Jean Farrell, Athlone).

On the other hand, the death of Seamus Heaney seemed to unite the country in a grief summed up by John Threadgold of Carlow: “Did the world stop turning there for a moment? Rest in peace, Seamus, your digging is done.” A stream of personal memories of gracious encounters with our Nobel laureate; and an outpouring of readers’ verse (which was carried on the Features page) continued for several days. Nelson Mandela’s long-expected death, later in the year, evoked a less personal, but nonetheless wide-ranging response, including letters from an ex-commander of a commando unit in Durban, and those who had campaigned in the Irish Anti-Apartheid Movement.

Throughout the year, the question of legislating for abortion, and the inquest into the death of Savita Halappanavar generated a sometimes heated debate, in which some of the country’s foremost medics, legal experts, nuns and priests participated on the letters page.

It was perhaps predictable that the referendum on the Seanad would draw in many multiple-signatory letters (on both sides of the debate and from at home and abroad); as well as missives penned by legal experts and present and former politicians, from Alan Dukes to John Robb; while the Court of Appeal amendment generated a far more muted response.

Sometimes it was the seemingly trivial political story, such as Pat Rabbitte’s comment (relating to the broadcasting charge), that there were “no cavemen in Ireland” that provoked letter-writers to respond most rapidly, angrily and wittily. After many letters from those who claimed to be cavemen or cavewomen, Angela McCarthy from Co Waterford suggested “Judging by the quality of the replies to Pat Rabbitte’s ill-judged remarks, the cavemen should be running the country.”

We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Standards. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or by filling out this form. New comments are only accepted for 3 days from the date of publication.

Irish Times News



News - direct to your inbox

Which Daily Digest would you like?