Guys and Dolls review: Blue Eyes and Brando

Guys and Dolls
    
Director: Joseph L Mankiewicz
Cert: Club
Genre: Musical
Starring: Marlon Brando, Jean Simmons, Frank Sinatra, Vivian Blaine
Running Time: 2 hrs 30 mins

Inveterate gambler Nathan Detroit (Sinatra) would like to go straight and marry his showgirl fiancée, Miss Adelaide (Blaine), some 14 years into their engagement. Trouble is, Nathan’s only real talent is for organising illegal crap games, much to the chagrin of his intended and various New York authorities.

In the hope of kick-starting a garage business Nathan makes a bet with his old pal and compulsive gambler, Sky Masterson (Brando) – $1,000 says the latter can’t whisk a girl of Nathan’s choosing off to Havana for a dinner date. Trouble is, Nathan names upstanding Sgt Sarah Brown (Simmons) of the local Salvation Army rescue mission.

Guys and Dolls was not a career best for most of its illustrious personnel. It's not up there with Joseph L Mankiewicz's best pictures. One would almost hesitate to mention it in a roll-call that includes All About Eve, Suddenly, Last Summer or Dragonwyck. Set-bound, overly talky and 150 minutes long, Guys and Dolls rarely breezes along, despite Michael Kidd's tremendous choreography and the odd historic toe-tapper (Luck Be a Lady, Sit Down You're Rockin' the Boat).

Viviane Blaine originated the role of Miss Adelaide and, by golly, she owns it. Jean Simmons is solid, though one must wonder what the film might been with first choices Grace Kelly and Deborah Kerr.

READ MORE

The male casting is more interesting. We have a theory about Sinatra's hand-in-pockets, staring-off performance. Ol' Blue Eyes may have done sterling work in The Man with the Golden Arm and The Manchurian Candidate but this isn't his best turn. He wanted the role of Sky and looks ticked off throughout.

Surprisingly, Brando, who was only cast because of his box office bankability, turns out to be a splendid romantic lead, with a light, deft touch and a decent voice.

Tara Brady

Tara Brady

Tara Brady, a contributor to The Irish Times, is a writer and film critic