Markets

Investors underestimate Trump risk - US ex-treasury secretary

Lawrence Summers says likely protectionist policy creating ‘extraordinary uncertainty’

Harvard professor Lawrence Summers: Donald Trump’s arguments “are so far out of the mainstream of any kind of responsible economic thinking that they are the economic equivalent of creationism”. Photograph: Nicholas Roberts

Tue Jan 3 2017 - 14:53

Former US treasury secretary Lawrence Summers said investors are being far too sanguine about the risks associated with Donald Trump’s incoming administration. The Harvard professor, a Democrat who was treasury chief under Bill Clinton, cited the possibility of protectionist measures by the US as well as changes to foreign policy and domestic social policy as issues creating “extraordinary uncertainty”.

With just over two weeks to go before Trump’s inauguration on January 20th, the S&P 500 is close to a record high, having risen almost 10 per cent in 2016 on optimism over fiscal stimulus and stronger economic growth. While the Dow Jones Industrial Average has struggled to close at the 20,000 level, it rose 13 per cent last year. “This is probably the largest transition ideologically and in terms of substantive policy that we’ve seen in the US in the last three-quarters of a century,” Summers told Tom Keene in a Bloomberg Television interview on Tuesday.

“Those kinds of transitions have to be – given the central role of the US in the global system – matters of enormous uncertainty. I don’t think that’s fully recognised by markets.”

'Voodoo economics'

READ MORE

Summers was also critical of a paper jointly written by economist Peter Navarro, who will lead a newly formed White House National Trade Council, and commerce department head Wilbur Ross.

“The Navarro-Ross paper is well beyond voodoo economics,” Summers said of the September report on Trump’s growth plans. “The logic of it, the arguments made, are so far out of the mainstream of any kind of responsible economic thinking that they are the economic equivalent of creationism.”

Summers dismissed the idea any tax policy introduced to encourage US companies to repatriate profits would boost investment and hiring.

“The vast majority of the companies who have large overseas cash also have substantial amounts of domestic cash,” he said. “The reality is that cash that is brought home will be used to pay dividends, to buy back shares, to engage in mergers and acquisitions, to rearrange the financial chessboard, not to invest in large amounts of new capital. It is a chimera to suppose that there will be large increases in capital investment as a consequence of that repatriation.” – (Bloomberg)

LATEST STORIES