The Book Club »

  • Last post on Brooklyn

    February 26, 2010 @ 3:15 pm | by Rosita Boland

    Hi folks. This is the last post about Brooklyn, as from Monday we’ll start discussing Alice Sebold’s The Lovely Bones, which is the book for March.

    If you haven’t read Colm’s terrific replies, they are in the post directly below this one, and an edited version will be in the books pages Saturday 27th. 

    Early in February, Colm did an interview with Warwick TV, whom I think are American, judging by the way the questions are framed.

    YouTube Preview Image

    It’s in two parts (You Tube only loads nine minutes of video at a time), so the second one is below. Colm talks about Brooklyn, writing, and answers questions about Ireland. It’s a good wrap to the month’s discussion. I look forward to our next one – kicks off Monday.

    YouTube Preview Image
  • Answers from Colm Tóibín – and next month’s book

    February 22, 2010 @ 5:20 pm | by Rosita Boland

    Hi folks. Colm has been working his way through your questions over the last few days, and I will post all his replies tomorrow – Tuesday. I can promise you some really interesting, thoughful responses on his part.

    The book we’re reading for March is The Lovely Bones, by Alice Sebold (and currently in the cinemas starring our own marvellous Saoirse Ronan). So get your hands on that, or dig it out if you already have it. Discussion will kick off on March.

  • Your questions for Colm Tóibín

    February 13, 2010 @ 11:40 am | by Rosita Boland

    We’re halfway through February now, and while there’s plenty more discussion ahead about Brooklyn, we’re at the stage when I’m asking you to post questions for Colm Tóibín. 

    Colm has agreed to answer questions about Brooklyn, so let’s keep this thread for that purpose. You have one week from today, Saturday 13th Feb, to start posting questions here, or to be thinking about what you’d like to ask him about Brooklyn. What’ll happen is that Colm will then look at what everyone has posted and give some answers and responses online, which will be sometime during the final week of February.

    Meanwhile, be thinking about what you’d like to ask Colm! (Please keep the questions focused on Brooklyn, though, since that is the book we’re looking at this month.)

  • Colm Tóibín’s Writing Room – and Robert Frost’s bed

    February 8, 2010 @ 11:53 am | by Rosita Boland

    The creative process is an endlessly fascinating one. How does the book emerge from the head and onto the page? Nobody really know that, apart from the individual writer. This is the study where Colm Tóibín works. He writes long-hand, which is highly unusual these days when most writers of novels opt for computers – however, lots of poets still write longhand.

    Speaking of writers’ homes, I once spent a month as writer-in-residence at The Frost Place in New Hamphire in the US. Robert Frost had lived there from 1915-1920, and it is now a museum and a foundation for poetry. My rooms in the musuem were downstairs – where Elinor’s (his wife) piano and stove still remained – and outside were the woods that inspired both the poems, The Road Not Taken and Stopping by the Woods on  a Snowy Evening. Among the upstairs rooms was Frost’s bedroom, with his large brass bed.

    Downstairs was also Frost’s armchair and a piece of wood that fitted across the two arms of the chair, which was how he liked to write. He used to take the armchair to the veranda, which overlooked the glorious White Mountains, place the wood over the arms, and write. His study, if you will, was outdoors.

     I had the run of the place for a month, and the museum items became as familiar to me as the table I ate at each day. They became absorbed into my daily routine. Each evening, I too sat in Frost’s chair, with the piece of wood in place, writing my diary and looking at the view he had seen. There was a skunk under the verandah, a bear in the woods, and strange sounds in the basement where the boiler roared, other noises thrummed from, and where I dared not venture.

     On my final night, there was a mouse in my bedroom. I fled. Fled upstairs to the museum rooms, where I spent the last night of my first visit to the US sleeping in Robert Frost’s bed.

  • Father Flood – His Motivation?

    February 5, 2010 @ 5:38 pm | by Rosita Boland

    So what’s in it for Father Flood to be so helpful to Eilis? You remember that just prior to disembarking the ship in New York, Georgia – who we know is a very savvy lady, so we can believe her – looks at Eilis’s passport and is surprised that she has “a full, rather than a temporary, work permit. She did not think it was easy to get such a document any more, even with the help of a priest.”

    So he gets her the full work permit. He finds her somewhere to stay. And when Eilis later asks him why he is helping her with accountancy classes – tuition fully paid – (page 77 of the book I have) – he answers “I was amazed that someone like you would not have a good job in Ireland. When your sister mentioned that you had no work in Ireland, then I said I would help you to come here. That’s all. And we need Irish girls in Brooklyn.”

    Do you believe him, that it was as simple as that? It’s clear Eilis had a special work permit, a place to stay organised, a contact to a job – and he arranges for her education. Why would he do that? Do you think there is a back story of history with him, some connection to Enniscorthy?

  • Is Brooklyn a “female book”?

    February 3, 2010 @ 3:20 pm | by Rosita Boland

     Hi to all

     For those of you who might not have heard Colm Tóibín reading from his work, here’s a 10 minute video of him reading a piece from Brooklyn – it’s the part where Eilis helps out at the Christmas party. Even if you haven’t got that far in the book, there are no spoilers in there! YouTube Preview Image

    One of the more recent comments was from O Cuin, and he asks: “I’m about halfway through Brooklyn right now and while I’m engaged with it and will finish it I’m getting slightly irritated with Eilish and worry that as time goes on she is going to find it hard to win me back. She’s just having too easy a time of it – decent job, home, social life, support, studying, seems to have met a man, but she’s not terribly happy… Am I not being sensitive enough? Maybe this is a “female book”? (I’m male). I’m not convinced such a thing exists but would like to know what people think.”

    What do you think, readers male and female? We’re not talking about genre fiction here, ie something that is definitely chick lit (some of which is very good indeed).

    Do you think -male readers – that Brooklyn is a book for all, or do you think – female readers – that it appeals more to female readers?

  • New York in the 1950s – your own families

    February 1, 2010 @ 12:58 pm | by Rosita Boland

    Hi to all, and thanks for all your contributions to the discussion on Brooklyn.

    We have a few weeks to develop the discussion, and this is very much a learning experience for me – so I would really welcome your feedback as we go along on what you’re enjoying, what elements of the discussion are working, and by all means suggest topics you’d like to see discussed.

    For the next few days, I thought it would be interesting to talk about the social history element to the novel: being Irish in Brooklyn or New York in the 1950s. Did you have relatives who lived there at that time? What kinds of stories do they tell about that time? Why did they go? Did they stay, or did they return eventually? What did they work at? Did they marry within the Irish community, or outside it? Have any of your relatives who lived in New York at that time read Brooklyn, and how believable do they think the social history is?

    For instance, Rosemary M commented that her aunt thought it was unlikely that Eilis would have come home at such short notice from Brooklyn (I won’t say why she came home – spolier alert). “It was entirely unrealistic – hopping on a boat home because her sister died! People didn’t come home from America back then; when you were gone, you were gone, and there was neither the money nor the time for home visits.”

    So let’s discuss the social history of the time in Brooklyn for the next few days, and let’s hear your stories of your own families and their experiences in New York in the 1950s. Pitch in!

    PS Look in archive on right hand side to see comments from first post


Search The Book Club