• RSS
  • Text Size:
  • -
  • irishtimes.com - Posted: August 14, 2010 @ 12:19 am

    Inception and Scrooge McDuck

    Donald Clarke

    Thanks to Ms T Brady for uncovering a curious Inception-related document at (of all things) a Thomas Pynchon discussion group. It seems that some years before Christopher Nolan delivered the script for his mind-bending psychological thriller, the good people at Disney devised an eerily similar — I mean eerily similarplot for a Scrooge McDuck comic. It really gets going on page two of Uncle Scrooge in Dream of a Lifetime.

    In the story, The Beagle Boys, a pack of canine hoodlums, seek the combination for Scrooge’s biggest. most over-stuffed safe. Their plan is to use a device that allows psychiatrists to “mentally enter into the dreams of their subjects”. The Beagles — who would be a lot less conspicuous without the burglar masks and prison overalls — duly don the headsets and find themselves propelled into a world of surreal and unpredictable terrors.

    Ah, the Nolanistas. On at least one website, a member  of that famously fanatical Christian (get it?) sect has taken offense at the snarky suggestion that the director stole his idea from the Disney comic. Enjoy Anklepat’s explanation of  ”Just one little glaring hole in your claims that Nolan thefted the inspiration behind Inception form Disney” on Videogum.

    Calm down, mate. I don’t think anybody really believes that Nolan owes Scrooge McDuck a cheque. It’s just that there are only so many stories in the world.

  • 14 Comments »

    1.
    August 14, 2010
    7:21 pm

    What the dickens……….that’s uncanny

    Here’s more:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fQCY-Zax11s

    Comment by ixmein
    2.
    August 15, 2010
    9:13 am

    ‘thefted’…??? ! How VERY grammatically incorrect…Or as Mr Fowler might say…grammar dear boy…grammar!

    Comment by grammatrix
    3.
    August 15, 2010
    9:51 am

    can’t believe YouTube removed that mash-up — v funny, it was called IN-DUCK-TION

    Anyway, Oliver Stone’s at it too — Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps — original? Or Scrooge McDuck again

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qL6hT0EI4Jc

    Comment by meixni
    4.
    August 15, 2010
    10:31 pm

    @2 — It’s Aussie rules for the yanks when it comes to speaking the Queen’s English, mate

    Comment by mel crowe
    5.
    August 16, 2010
    8:50 am

    Yep, I love little things like this – and that over-reaction from fans is hilarious. I’m waiting for the frivolous lawsuit from Scrooge McDuck.

    Comment by Darren
    6.
    August 16, 2010
    10:07 am

    It’s one thing bringing a graphic novel superhero character to the big screen as in Nolan’s Duck…er…Dark Knight but it’s another thing altogether taking a comic strip cartoon character out of it’s exact context and presenting this as original on the big screen, with humans replacing the quacky characters. Don’t know if anyone has scrutinised the credits but maybe Nolan does reference Scrooge McDuck for Inception somewhere in the fine print. Anyway, I prefer “Uncle Scrooge: Dream of a Lifetime” – less unresolved – and it’s flat, one-dimensional character doesn’t detract from it in the least…

    You’d think, though, when a film is practically a shot-for-shot adaptation of a graphic fiction novel/comic book, for example, Snyder’s 300 (2007) or Miller’s Sin City (2005), a director of live action movies would normally first acquire the film rights, as in examples given. It’s not like Nolan wouldn’t know this, so either he couldn’t get the film rights or he actually never heard of Scrooge McDuck – or didn’t realise that the old quacker was the primary source of his inspiration all along

    Comment by dreamcatcher
    7.
    August 17, 2010
    10:01 am

    I actually enjoyed that McDuck Comic… good way to kill 20 mins.

    But anywhere, as you said Mr Clarke, there are only so many stories in the world.
    I found when i watched Inception I saw some similarites in Ideas with the film animated ‘Paprika’, though I didnt see this in anyway as Nolan ripping off the idea… though sadly there are plenty of people who do.

    Comment by Smurphette
    8.
    August 17, 2010
    10:03 am

    I’m sick, just sick of all the whining about what is THE GREATEST MOVIE OF ALL TIME, (better than ‘Avatar’, way deeper than ‘The Matrix’, even more awesome than ‘The Fifth Element’ and that was pretty wild), just because none of you have like the I.Q. to appreciate what Nolan is doing here. Don’t you get it? The guy’s a PHILOSOPHER. You think he wastes his time reading some kid’s comic books? No way. He reads graphic novels dude. That’s GRAPHIC. NOVELS. And he doesn’t just read them man. After he’s done with them he like, contemplates them and stuff. That’s what he does. He sits with his chin on his fist like The Watcher on a lunch break and just, you know, sees BEYOND.
    You all have to just GROW UP and learn like what the man is trying to TEACH you. You know, just because you’re like, stuck in the post-room of a major Hollywood studio doesn’t mean that you like can’t have DREAMS or something and like those dreams can be so sweet and so powerful man that they can like become REALITY. In fact, even BETTER than REALITY, I swear. That’s what he’s trying to say. Don’t stop believing, dude.
    And you don’t just have to take my word for it. Ask my best friend Waldo Jeffers. He spent at least three months in college on a screenwriting course so he’s like practically QUALIFIED and he is like the deepest, most philosophical dude I know. One time he stared so hard at a ‘Where’s Waldo’ book after huffing liquid paper that a blood vessel burst in his eye. True story. I asked him afterwards what happened, like what did he SEE and he kind of just looked at me like he was peering way down in my PSYCHE man and said in a low, low whisper, “ What do you want me to do? Draw you a picture? Spell it out? Don’t ever ask me! As long as you live, don’t ever ask me more!” So if anybody should know, I figure he should know man. So just shut your yaps, that’s all. You whiners know NOTHING.

    Comment by Nam Citsale
    9.
    August 17, 2010
    10:04 am

    Also similar ideas in Dreamscape and The Cell…. to a very lesser extent,

    Comment by Smurphette
    10.
    August 17, 2010
    10:51 am

    An absolutely perfect pastiche, Nam. I particularly like the friend on the scriptwriting course.

    Comment by Big Louise
    11.
    August 17, 2010
    11:59 am

    @ 10, hey thanks Louise, Waldo really is the coolest guy I know, although he’s been having some relationship problems recently, some chick from out of state is giving him the runaround I think, so he’s been kind of depressed recently.
    I caught him gazing into a hole in his back yard the other day, like totally focussed and I asked him what’s he doing and he says nothing, just keeps staring like an extra in a My Chemical Romance video, you know, like total melancholy, AGONY. So I ask him again and he sniffs and mumbles something like, “The longer I look, the deeper and darker it gets.” And I say “What, you mean the hole man?” And then he gets real angry and shouts “Hole? It’s an ABYSS you worthless, puny knucklehead!”
    And you know what, after about five minutes hunched over this hole, I started to see his point. Not only that, but I got the strangest feeling that like the hole was kind of checking me out too. I got spooked after that and went back inside to watch the Cameron marathon on t.v., (even though I got them all on dvd anyway dude, you know it).
    So now Waldo is so down that he’s talking about wrapping himself up in shiny paper and like sending himself in the mail to this chick like some kind of GIFT. I hope he’ll be o.k.

    Comment by Nam Citsale
    12.
    August 17, 2010
    3:06 pm

    Side-spliffing toke on the topik, Nam……….but you gotta wonder if the dude is trying to duck out of something…
    No doubt about it, anyway… that Scrooge is one mean motherquacker

    Comment by imexni
    13.
    August 18, 2010
    3:37 pm

    Went to see Inception last night. Visually stunning but it’s too long, too convoluted and too in love with itself – all surface, no feeling. I had forgotten about it 10 minutes after I left the cinema.

    Comment by Quint
    14.
    August 26, 2010
    11:05 am

    A+ would read again

    Comment by mode20100

    Leave a comment

    When submitted, your comment will be moderated and, once approved, will appear on the site.

    The Irish Times reserves the absolute right not to publish comments.


Search Screenwriter