Screenwriter

  • But not for viewers in Northern Ireland.

    December 21, 2009 @ 11:09 pm | by Donald Clarke

    Armando Iannucci used to do an excellent routine in which — remembering his childhood — he’d impersonate a BBC continuity announcer detailing the array of delights set to be broadcast that evening. I can’t remember the exact details, but I think he described unseen episodes of Star Trek featuring John Coltrane interspersed with in-depth interviews between Fidel Castro and James Dean. That sort of thing. Then, after raising expectations to breaking point, the imaginary announcer would say: “But not for viewers in Scotland”. A trailer  featuring Andy Stewart bawling at a frolicking haggis would then manifest itself before the young Armando.

    uncle_andy.jpg

    “Alex Maskey! Do you get it? Do you?”

    He had it lucky. Most readers will now have access to several hundred channels on their televisions. Who cares if the stunningly unfunny May McFetridge is occupying the space that BBC London (say) has allocated to Noam Chomsky? You can always switch to BBC 4 or Sky Movies or the ferret-stuffing channel. A few older, more Northern punters may, however, remember the enormous disappointment when, during the three-channel 1970s, some science-fiction epic or raunchy inner-city drama failed to come the way of “viewers in Northern Ireland” because the people of Ulster insisted on watching f**cking motor f**king sports all the f**king day long. “And now, in place of coverage of our Lord’s second coming, we have go-kart racing from Downpatrick.” If it wasn’t f**king motor f**king sports it was the feeble comic stylings of some witless cretin who would barely get a job cleaning the lavatories in an English — or even Welsh — television station.”How’s about ye! See yer wee woman from the Shankill? Maisie ye call her. Gawd she’d make ye want to boke.” Shut up! Why  do you think being Northern Irish is funny in itself? Do a joke!

    In short, we ached for the likes of Andy Stewart.

    Some excellent television programmes have, of course, come from Northern Ireland. Indeed, you could argue — with absolute sincerity — that BBC Northern Ireland and UTV together delivered the most cutting dramas, the most incisive current affairs programmes and the most thrilling action shows of the last hundred years. Like Fermat when announcing his proof, I do not have space to list the evidence here, but I will do so in a future post. You can count on that, readers.

    I do, however, have a teeny, tiny issue with Northern Irish comedy programmes. Ms McFetridge is on my television as we speak and the grey pall of non-humour emerging from the device is so thick and fetid that I can barely breathe. What year is it? Is there anywhere else in the world where such a singularly awful drag act could find work? Surely, even the comedy troupes of Turkmenistan have got beyond this now.

    The tribunes of Northern Irish TV comedy remain, of course, the team behind the jaw-droppingly extraordinary Give My Head Peace.  This ghastly sit-com, now happily deceased, offered a terrifying practical demonstration of the delusions that define the province’s unlovely comedy culture.

    1. Being Northern Irish is, in itself, funny.
    Saying “’bout ye” or  “Ulster fry”stands as a joke.

    2. Simply mentioning any well-known local politician deserves a laugh.
    Whatever the set up, “Alex Maskey” will work as a punchline.

    3. High culture of any sort is also inherently hilarious.
    Ballet or “modern art” will always raise a laugh.

    4. The English wear bowler hats and say “jolly good” all the time.
    “Oh, I say! What do you mean, Uncle Andrew?”

    5. Americans wear cowboy hats and say “howdy” all the time.
    “This here little country ain’t big enough to park ma Cadeeelac in. Yee ha!”

    6. Being Northern Irish is, in itself, funny.
    Yeah, I know we said this before, but it really does explain all you need to know about this horrific, horrific movement.

    Oh, and, since you ask, I was raised in South Belfast.

  • 24 Comments »

    1.
    December 22, 2009
    1:59 am

    Surely May McFettridge is merely an Ulster version of Brendan O’Carroll’s Mrs Brown? I would rather eat my own hair than watch either of them.

    Comment by Tom
    2.
    December 22, 2009
    2:26 am

    Ah The Hole In The Wall Gang… is it in bad taste to suggest some weapons should have been decommissioned on them?…

    Normally a post like yours will fall victim to some outraged whataboutery on the part of some thin-skinned Northerner. So we’ll wait and see.

    However it is fair to say that comedy in the Republic is in a hole too after being barely tolerable for a few years. The Panel is a pathetic mishmash bastard child of infinitely superior British shows, Podge and Rodge are bad one-joke ponies, Killinaskully and every other RTE sitcom ever are all wojius. The stand-ups - Tiernan, Byrne(s), O’Hanlon, Delamere, Maxwell, Spain et al - are now about as funny as a kick in the testicles. David O’Doherty is the only remotely saving grace.

    In fact, as an island, we’re not half as funny as we think we are, but sure we’re great craic and everyone loves us.

    Comment by dealga
    3.
    December 22, 2009
    9:25 am

    the ‘Billy Trilogy’ is a distant memory

    Comment by petee
    4.
    December 22, 2009
    9:52 am

    The only remotely funny thing happening in Irish comedy these days is Hardy Bucks. The Panel was once okay, but I can’t stand seeing that same group of unfunny men interrupt each other any more.

    Comment by Derek
    5.
    December 22, 2009
    10:04 am

    Rarely has anyone hit the nail on the head so accurately.

    Comment by Brock Landers
    6.
    December 22, 2009
    10:08 am

    The fallout of such regional scheduling was experienced down here too. I well remember my Dad settling in to watch Match of The Day with the heady expectation of enjoying an end-of-season thriller between, say, Liverpool and Leeds to find that BBC NI was instead broadcasting from Windsor Park where Glentoran & Linfield were about to do battle. My husband confirms that such a travesty frequently reduced his 7-year-old self to bitter tears of disappointment.

    Comment by Eleanor
    7.
    December 22, 2009
    11:38 am

    Thank goodness we in the republic are producing comedy gold like the Panel, Republic of Telly and Val Falvey T.d. I am however, despite my better judgement laughing quite a lot at the Savage Eye. Just think how hilarious a Northern Podge and Rodge could be. We can only live in hope that the bright sparks in the UTV comedy development team have a brainstorming session soon.

    Comment by bateman
    8.
    December 22, 2009
    1:41 pm

    The insularity and parochialism of local broadcasters seems to bind us all together. I recall acutely the torment suffered while immobilised within the foul tractor beam cast by showjumping at the RDS, the John Player Tops and the Castlebar Song Contest, compounded by the knowledge that there was no escape, as one’s own corner of the cultural desert was deprived of the magical signal emitted by the makers of ‘Seaside Special’ and its ilk. Youngsters nowadays won’t have a notion what I am blathering about, but think of a nerdish whippersnapper like myself trying to visualise ‘Doctor Who’ through the prism of ‘Wanderly Wagon’, (RTE’s closest equivalent), and you have the aetiology of a damaged generation.
    Dealga’s preference of a maimed gusset over most Irish comedy is one I share, although I wouldn’t exclude Mr. Doherty, an illusionist who cods paying customers into thinking slouching is a form of wit. If it is any consolation to Mr. Clarke, in the spirit of cross-border co-operation, we have all been and continue to be in this morass together.
    P.S. John Coltrane on ‘Star Trek’? If they soundtrack the next film to ‘Interstellar Space’ then I guarantee my attendance. However, I will accept the odd parp and skronk from Sun Ra as a compromise.

    Comment by Nam Citsale
    9.
    December 22, 2009
    4:42 pm

    All very true! Now that I can get RTE via SKY I can see that un-funny TV comedy must be a part of the all-ireland agreement that I missed. The Panel - give me strength! Podge and Rodge - what a joke (not), our fathers worked for 50 years to change such perceptions of being ‘Irish’.

    Comment by patrick
    10.
    December 22, 2009
    4:56 pm

    May McFettridge isn’t a woman?!

    Comment by David
    11.
    December 23, 2009
    12:56 pm

    Sliding slightly sideways into RTE Radio - what can you say about Joe Duffy’s “Funny Fridays” - who the #UC* are these people…? And, more importantly, who authorised this abominable waste of licence fee spondulix?

    I suppose it at least serves to make Derek Mooney appear relatively competent by comparison - if only once a month…

    Comment by Gerry
    12.
    December 23, 2009
    1:17 pm

    On the money once again Donald. I lived in Belfast for nearly two years and sometimes it felt like being stuck in a Harp commercial. The emphasis is always on getting a laugh at someone elses expense and the more humiliation that can be inflicted the better. I seem to recall May McFetridge being held in reverence up there as a much-loved institution and also recall gawping at the telly in confusion at someone called Wee Jimmy or Our Jimmy or something? He was telling jokes about Bangor, well not tellin jokes but talkin about someone and Bangor was the punchline. Still confused. Definitely didn’t get it. And that was my same reaction to a lot of northern ‘comedy’. All the big laughs are in-jokes and if its not about NornIron, it just aint funny for them up there.

    Comment by william
    13.
    December 23, 2009
    1:35 pm

    Wee Jimmy or Our Jimmy or something

    That would be James “Jimmy” Young, William. He had an “hilarious” routine about Cherryvalley that he exploited for decades.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Young_(comedian)

    Even some quite sensible people still think him a genius. But not me…

    Comment by Donald Clarke
    14.
    December 23, 2009
    1:37 pm

    Your mistake there, Gerry, is listening to Joe Duffy.

    The comedy landscape is barren across the island. Anyone good jumps ship to the Premier League in London.

    To get on to the first rung of the comedy ladder in Ireland you just have to be able to shout loud or get dressed up as an auld wan. I often wonder how the hell people bring themselves to sit in studio audiences for podge and rodge or the panel.

    Comment by Padjo
    15.
    December 23, 2009
    2:17 pm

    Jesus, a lot of truth on here alright, but it’s not going far enough at all.

    There should be a national inquiry into the commissioning of the following shows: The Byrne Ultimatum, Republic Of Telly,The Savage Eye, Val Falvey TD, The (revamped) Panel.

    Jason Byrne is straight up dreadful. Loud and annoying.
    I once saw Neil Delamere effectively bullying people in the front 3 rows at a show in UCD. Enough said.
    I once saw McSavage racistly abusing people in town. Not funny at all.
    Arthur Matthews and Father Dougal should hang their heads in total shame.
    And The Panel. THE PANEL??? WHO SAID MCWILLIAMS COULD PRESENT A COMEDY SHOW???!!!!

    Anyone found guilty of commissioning this absolute barrel scrapery should be sacked. We pay licence fees for this!!!

    Comment by Jesus O' Reilly
    16.
    December 24, 2009
    2:56 am

    I’m from Northern Ireland and I’ve been complaining about the tv here for years. How frustrating is it on occasions like comic relief when they cut away from some global stars in London to newsreaders in Belfast being ‘gunged’ by a bunch of surly firemen.
    The comedy is actually a national disgrace. “You’re a Catholic. I’m a Protestant. We don’t get along. Hahaha……” and yet it continued to be commissioned year after year. I agree with all the points you raised especially the being funny just because you’re from Northern Ireland. It really sickens my hole.

    Comment by Ó' Dalaigh
    17.
    December 24, 2009
    10:47 am

    Very true. Although in my childhood it was S4C and BBC Wales we had in Waterford. Probably from a deflector when cable companies could legitmately steal cable from the Brits. I’d be gearing up for a racey french movie at 14 with my box of tissues handy when some godawful Welsh program with come on with their flagrent disrespect for vowels.

    Comment by Ozziej
    18.
    December 24, 2009
    11:44 am

    Podge & its evil twin Rodge are revolting, disgusting, repellent, repulsive, sickening, nauseating, horrible, horrendous, awful, dreadful, terrible, dire, appalling, unpleasant, bad and I am running out of synonyms. As for that Panel debacle — disaster, catastrophe, fiasco, shamble………..How, I ask again more stringently, harshly, sternly, strictly — how do we, the TV licence payers, who every five minutes have to listen to the RTE Stasi threatening us if we do not pay the exorbitant licence fee, put up with this garbage, trivia, nonsense, rubbish……….

    Comment by barbera O'Shcokenzy
    19.
    December 24, 2009
    11:44 am

    Katherine Lynch, anyone? May McFetridge is finger-on-the pluse, scalpel-sharp, comedy gold in comparison.

    The fact that RTE saw fit to devote an entire series to lazy, unfunny stereotypes of (choose one from the following list depending on the ’sketch’ in question) travellers, slappers, overweight women, or sometimes, hilariously, all three simultaneously, suggests commissioning editors were done away with in the first round of cuts at our national broadcaster. Either that or getting your own series is simply a matter of asking for it.

    Comment by Brendan Needham
    20.
    December 24, 2009
    11:59 am

    Yea, we should rejoin the British Empire and we could all enjoy an honest day’s japing at the expense of culturally, linguistically, racially inferior peoples and their funny looking hair.

    Give me a break. The 0.00001% of people who think Joe Duffy’s Friday crew are not funny (and they’re not) and complain about it online are the same people who still believe that endless hours of Melvyn Bragg holding forth on 14th Andalucian sexual mores is good television.

    Comedy is only ever as good as the culture that it produces and many of the comments here are evidence of “you mean you haven’t heard of Spindly Thomas?! he’s focking hilarious!”

    Comment by Eoin
    21.
    December 24, 2009
    1:16 pm

    the same people who still believe that endless hours of Melvyn Bragg holding forth on 14th Andalucian sexual mores is good television.

    Have you seen the South Bank Show recently?

    Alas, he’s more likely to be holding forth on the glories of Coldplay or the wonders of Phil Collins.

    Comment by Donald Clarke
    22.
    December 26, 2009
    5:03 pm

    Hi,

    I am from near the top of Inishowen in County Donegal which is the most northernly point in the island of Ireland. Am I therefore according to the Northern Irish and the Eastern British, someone from Southern Ireland? The whole thing is a joke but not very funny.

    Comment by Frank Jameson
    23.
    December 30, 2009
    3:06 pm

    ‘Sliding slightly sideways into RTE Radio - what can you say about Joe Duffy’s “Funny Fridays” - who the #UC* are these people…? And, more importantly, who authorised this abominable waste of licence fee spondulix’?

    Gerry, hilarious, and so true! Im sure they fetch Brush Shiels, or whatever his name is, from his coffin every month, its the only time you ever hear from him, and Joe is so cringy when he makes his 400,000 euro accent ever so slightly more dublinese to be down with the comedians.

    Val Falvey is a sick joke, the Panel is gone rubblish with `mcwillians at the helm, The Republic of Telly is funny, except its really just a version of Harry Hills show, Killnascuddy cast needs to humanely put down, and The Savage Eye will, I predict, go like Fr Ted, slow burner. The scabrous wit of McSavage is uncomfortable which is how good comedy should be.

    oh, and can someone take Brendan Carroll out and shoot him at dawn, please……………..

    Comment by shellshock
    24.
    January 2, 2010
    12:34 pm

    I had no idea that Ugly Man Woman Man had an official name.

    Comment by Simon McGarr

    Leave a comment


    • (will not be published)


Close
E-mail It