• -
  • irishtimes.com - Posted: October 12, 2010 @ 9:24 am

    The greatest band in the world ever …

    Laurence Mackin

    … is the Fallopian Tubas. That’s right, peeps, the Fallopian Tubas.

    Introducing on vocals, Nina Simone. Drums, Brian Blade. Bass, Reid Anderson. Guitar, Ryan Adams. And trumpet, Miles Davis.

    This is most rock and roll outfit ever to call stage home, and is the product of the Irish Times Fantasy Band challenge. A few weeks ago, I asked a few Irish Times critics to name their ultimate five-a-side musical line-up. The rules were simple. The band had to have one front person, drummer and bass player, and two others; No more than two dead people for the starting five; No more than one person from one band (players in crossover bands are allowed); Each band must have a name and a short explanation as to why this is the best band ever. This is not a list of the best musicians – this is the best band as a unit working effectively together.

    My line up is above, and the other chancers’ two-bit part time bunch of wastrels are below. You can read our justification for picking the players we did here, and we’ll be printing a number of readers’ selections online in the coming days, but know this – you won’t improve on my perfect unit.

    TALKING HEADERS
    Manager Sinéad Gleeson
    Vocals Prince
    Drums Tony Allen
    Bass Tina Weymouth
    Guitar PJ Harvey
    Keys/other Noah Lennox

    BALLYMUN FACELIFT
    Manager Tony Clayton-Lea
    Vocals Nina Persson
    Drums Larry Mullen Jr
    Bass Nicky Wire
    Guitar Tom Verlaine
    Cello Jacqueline du Prè

    VELLA’S CAULIFLOWERS
    Manager Jim Carroll
    Vocals Ella Fitzgerald
    Drums Elvin Jones
    Bass Tina Weymouth
    Guitar Steve Cropper
    Other stuff Flying Lotus

    THE QUOTAS
    Manager Anthea McTeirnan
    Vocals Beth Ditto
    Drums Meg White
    Bass Tessa Pollitt
    Lead guitar Joan Armatrading
    Rhythm guitar/vocals Chrissie Hynde


Search Pursued by a Bear