• RSS
  • Text Size:
  • -
  • irishtimes.com - Posted: August 13, 2009 @ 1:54 pm

    Dear reader, do you even exist?

    Conor Pope

    I passed on just some of Ryanair’s “faults” submitted by “readers” on to its head of communications this morning and got the following response. I’ll say nothing about it…

    Dear Conor

    Thanks for your latest email received at 10:18am this morning claiming a “very tight deadline” and seeking a response by lunchtime. We never realised that a consumer column had such tight deadlines! We trust that our responses will receive equal prominence.

    Firstly, we asked you (not claimed readers) to set out what you meant by “all its (Ryanair’s) faults” and note that you have failed to do so. Instead you have sought subjective and patently unrepresentative “things” from claimed Price Watch readers. Since you won’t/can’t back up your claim may we respond to these so called “readers” claims as follows:

    1. The claim that Ryanair “does not provide what the consumer wants” is absurd when 67million consumers will fly with us this year.

    2. Lack of communication during rare flight delays is equally untrue when any flight delays are updated in real time on our website and on airport flight information boards.

    3. The only reason why our on-time jingle is infuriating is that it is played so regularly on our on-time flights. How can one reader seriously complain about our on-time jingle and in the same breath claim that we don’t provide flight delay info???

    4. Our passengers are not charged any web check-in fee if they travel on one of our four lowest promotional fare classes. If a passenger does not want to pay our web check-in fee just travel on one of our promotional fares (€10 one way or under). Why is our web check-in service which allows millions of passengers to avoid airport check-in queues a “fault of Ryanair”?

    5. Visa Electron is our free of charge payment mechanism which will be used by over 20 million passengers this year, including many thousands of Irish residents (including myself for example). Why is a free of charge payment mechanism a “fault of Ryanair”?

    6. Our name change fee is designed to allow passengers who have bought non-refundable promotional fares the opportunity to transfer it to friends or family (without losing the cost of their original booking) if for any reason they can’t travel on their original itinerary. Why is this a “fault of Ryanair”?

    7. Our €40 boarding card re-issue fee is only levied on those passengers who fail to arrive at the airport with their web check-in boarding pass, which they agreed they would bring with them at the time of booking. This re-issue fee is a better alternative than not allowing these passengers to travel at all, which is what would otherwise happen. Why should passengers “forget” to bring their boarding card? Do they “forget” to bring their passports?

    8. Our all leather seats are extremely comfortable and our onboard advertising and yellow livery are much beloved by our passengers, which is why 67 million of them prefer to fly with Ryanair rather than any other competitor airline this year.

    Since your claimed readers can’t identify “all its (Ryanair’s) faults” and since you won’t say what you see our “faults” to be, perhaps you might in future confine your coverage of Ryanair to facts, fares and service figures and not to subjective and inaccurate rubbish such as the above.

    Many thanks

    Stephen McNamara, Head of Communications

  • 69 Comments »

    1.
    August 13, 2009
    2:18 pm

    That was very entertaining.

    Conor, please do continue to publish any correspondance you get from Ryanair. It’d be worth checking back for. :-)

    Comment by hetch
    2.
    August 13, 2009
    2:22 pm

    Wow, he really is a tool. As I’ve said before, I’ve never had any particular problem with Ryanair’s service and even the slightly underhanded presentation of charges only irks rather than enrages me. I do wonder though if Stephen genuinely believes ‘our onboard advertising and yellow livery are much beloved by our passengers, which is why 67 million of them prefer to fly with Ryanair rather than any other competitor’? The leather seats are an improvement certainly but the yellow livery would make me wish for blindness if only Ryanair weren’t so apparently unfriendly to the disabled. I genuinely respect their business model and it is borne out by their passenger numbers but again have to wonder if their deliberately boorish attitude will ultimately be their downfall

    Comment by Tom Ennis
    3.
    August 13, 2009
    2:26 pm

    I bet they had a competition in the office to see who could come up with the best retort. The winner? “Our all leather seats are extremely comfortable”.

    This is even funnier than RTE’s new autumn TV schedule

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    4.
    August 13, 2009
    2:27 pm

    Conor,

    You’re wasting your time, they just don’t get it… It’s like arguing against creationism with the religious nuts, or the Obama birthers. Instead of reasoned debate, they stick their fingers in their ears and shout ‘la la la la la la’ at the top of their lungs.

    Comment by Jonathan
    5.
    August 13, 2009
    2:31 pm

    Communication at it’s best. Flying to Rome this weekend, guess who I’m not flying with?

    Comment by Finian
    6.
    August 13, 2009
    2:34 pm

    I don’t know Jim, looking forward to Pure Mule – The Last Weekend!

    Comment by Finian
    7.
    August 13, 2009
    2:34 pm

    Well he certainly is earning his crust at Ryanair eh?

    Stephen, on the off-chance that you are monitoring this thread, hitting refresh every few minutes and watching the venom spew forth from Ryanair users both irate and otherwise… Perhaps you could enlighten us:

    Where did you get your visa electron card? Was it from MBNA? If not, from where? And when you say “many thousands” – how many is that? Two? Twenty?

    Communicate with us.

    -dan

    Comment by dan c
    8.
    August 13, 2009
    3:15 pm

    Conor,

    why are you so mean to Ryanair when it is patently clear from the above response that EVERYTHING they do they do to benefit the customer & not themselves? Take no. 7, ok you pay an extra €40 for a bit of paper, but sure isn’t that better than not flying at all? It’s all for the customer’s good, not to line O’Leary’s pockets.

    They’re are gas though aren’t they? As Hetch said, very entertaining….or at least it would be if I actually existed and wasn’t a “claimed reader”

    Keep up the good work.

    Comment by Sally
    9.
    August 13, 2009
    3:24 pm

    That exactly confirms what I said in my response to the previous Pricewatch article re Ryanair: Ryanair or at least the arrogant and ignorant Stephen McNamara treat their customers with contempt and think that we are all stupid idiots. It infuriates me to read his reply and while I am regularly defend Ryanair when people complain about the lack of service with the reply that I want low prices not luxurious service, reading McNamara’s insulting outburst really makes me wonder if I should change my stance.

    I wouldn’t expect McNamara to agree with his customer’s opinion, but I would expect him to stop insulting our intelligence.

    Comment by JSG
    10.
    August 13, 2009
    3:28 pm

    “Our passengers are not charged any web check-in fee if they travel on one of our four lowest promotional fare classes.” – What if you’re not on a promotional fare? Would he care to elaborate how many of the 67 million passengers every year are promotional and non-promotional.

    “Lack of communication during rare flight delays is equally untrue when any flight delays are updated in real time on our website and on airport flight information boards” – Ever tired using WiFi in an airport (that is if you can bring your laptop in your single piece of carry-on luggage) – the eye-watering prices are nearly more costly than Ryanair’s charges. Additionally, airport information displays are not always the most reliable. I have heard of people jogging from Pier D to Pier B in Dublin airport with minutes to go due to flight change. Anyone who is familiar with the airport will know how far that is.

    and finally…

    “The claim that Ryanair “does not provide what the consumer wants” is absurd when 67million consumers will fly with us this year” – Actually, Ryanair is not what the consumer wants. It is, however, one of few choices, so it’s more a case of the consumer being willing to suck it up in return for cheapish fares.

    Comment by Joanne
    11.
    August 13, 2009
    3:29 pm

    Given how the Jason Roe vs Ryanair controversy went, it’s quite funny how Ryanair will immediately assume that any blog comments are made up rather than being from real people.

    Comment by valueireland
    12.
    August 13, 2009
    3:43 pm

    Ha! That was entertaining indeed.

    Since point 2 may apply to my complaint about absence of information during a flight delay in Edinburgh airport, I will be delighted to (re-)supply Mr.McNamara with photo evidence of the departure boards displaying the flight as “on time”, four hours after it was due to leave. I can also send him photographs of the co-operative art project created during that delay; all the passengers wrote their thoughts about Ryanair on the display board at the departure gate.

    However he will have to prove to me that he exists first, perhaps by engaging in some actual Communication.

    Comment by Karin H
    13.
    August 13, 2009
    3:50 pm

    “our onboard advertising and yellow livery are much beloved by our passengers, which is why 67 million of them prefer to fly with Ryanair”

    I don’t think there’s actually a causal relationship there. I never heard anyone says they’re flying Ryanair because of the fabulous in-air advertising and sexy yellow decoration.

    Comment by Jamie Lawrence
    14.
    August 13, 2009
    4:31 pm

    Stephen, please let me know where I can get my Electron card that you and “thousands” of others apparently are using without having to open an offshore bank account.

    “Why is a free of charge payment mechanism a “fault of Ryanair”?”
    Because you dont offer Laser which is actually used by hundred of thousands of Irish residents.

    Stop been a tool and treating your customers like eejits. Just acknowledge that:
    1) Ryanair engage in price gouging at every available opportunity.
    2) Charging €40 for a boarding card is effectively discriminating against the elderly.
    3) All flight times are overstated so that nearly every flight manages to arrive “on time”. Amazing how some airlines travel the same routes in 30mins less time.
    4) The offensive yellow livery is probably “much beloved” by the blind and noone else.
    5) There is zero communication during flight delays. If you’re lucky the flight might be labelled as “delayed” on the departures board.
    6) The name fee, costing ryanair zero, is just more price gouging.
    7) Ryanair actively deceives customers with airport names that are miles from the name. eg “Frankfurt”

    I managed to fly with five different airlines this year. None of them ryanair. One thing flying ryanair has done for me is made me appreciate the little things with other airlines – helpful staff, allocated seats, no bull**** charges, arriving at my destination and not 30mins drive away, stress free travel ….

    I’ve seen the future. And its not yellow.

    Comment by DG
    15.
    August 13, 2009
    4:37 pm

    As a frequent Ryanair user I am used to their “rules” but I discovered the most beautiful of “rules” the other day. If you do ever want to check a bag in then the limit is 15Kgs, fair enough, but if you need to check in a second bag then the limit is still 15Kgs for both (not each!).. 3, 4,5 bags and all bags added together must weigh less than 15Kgs.. absurd. Why would anyone want to check in 5 bags with a max average of 3 kgs in each bag. Who are these people? Pillow salesmen?

    Comment by Ste - statusireland.com
    16.
    August 13, 2009
    5:05 pm

    I’m interested in the comment from DG above- how is the €40 check-in charge discriminatory towards the elderly?

    Comment by valueireland
    17.
    August 13, 2009
    5:30 pm

    I’m guessing discriminatory against the elderly as they are less internet savvy.
    It occurs to me that Ryanair would get an awful lot less flak if they inverted the pricing structure- if instead of adding on charges to a low headline figure they had a high headline figure but offered huge discounts (eg knocked €40 off of an expensive ticket if you print your own boarding card). The end result would be the same for them but people would be praising them for offering ways to reduce travel costs rather than feeling gouged.

    Comment by Tom Ennis
    18.
    August 13, 2009
    6:03 pm

    @Tom Ennis – I guess that’s where DGs comments were heading – but I wonder how did the poor old non-internet savvy dears get their Ryanair tickets in the first place if they didn’t book online?

    I’d probably take issue with a few more of the points raised by DG, but first I’d be interested to know the 5 other airlines that they’ve flown with this year that are angelic enough not to contravene any of the points raised – particularly point 1 (price gouging = supply & demand = profit making = good business?).

    Comment by valueireland
    19.
    August 13, 2009
    6:10 pm

    @valueireland
    Previously when booking flights for parents all had to do was print ticket for them and they handled the rest. Now also have to check them in closer to the time of the flight. When generally isnt always possible to do.

    Hence just book them on aerlingus where possible now. Plus can book an assigned seat so its stress free. The “cattle boarding” process of a ryanair can be quite intimidated for some people.

    Comment by DG
    20.
    August 13, 2009
    7:42 pm

    @DG – So Ryanair are really discriminating against you, as you’ve to do two things for your aged parents now, instead of just the one?

    It’s actually easier for them now since they don’t have to check in – just take the boarding pass from you and go straight to the gate rather than standing on their aged feet for ages in the check-in queue.

    Comment by valueireland
    21.
    August 13, 2009
    10:17 pm

    Is ValueIreland the 3rd clone of Micheal O Leary

    Comment by ALAN
    22.
    August 13, 2009
    11:37 pm

    Ryanair are not a charity. They are a business. They offer a very basic service for a reasonable fee, with non-essential add-ons being charged considerably higher.

    You want features that Ryanair charge extra for… either pay the extra or go with an airline that includes them in the ticket price.

    If you object so strongly to Ryanair’s way of doing business then simply don’t do business with them, that is your perogative. If you object strongly yet still choose to do business with them then you put quite a cheap price on your principles.

    Personally, I generally avoid doing business with Ryanair… but when I do, much like when I choose to buy a hotdog from a street vendor in the early hours of Saturday morning, I know what I’m letting myself in for. And I embrace it.

    Comment by Rob Burke
    23.
    August 14, 2009
    12:19 am

    The credit card charge on Ryanair is simply a backdoor method to increase income and profits. Their spokesman knows this and is fooling no-one by saying that Irish people can get a Visa Electron Card here. The Visa Electron card availability is a side issue anyway as the €5 charge for using normal Visa/MasterCard is “price gouging” too. Ryanair only pay the credit card companies around 2% for the transaction – that’s only 10 cent for a €5 fare. Yet they charge their customers €5 and try to justify by saying that is is due to “substantial administration costs”. It is pure profiteering plain and simple and it should not be allowed by the consumer rights authorities.
    Until it’s outlawed, Irish customers can bypass the credit card charge by getting a virtual Entropay Visa Electron card.

    Comment by Al
    24.
    August 14, 2009
    1:52 am

    He’s at it again…

    ”While I do not expect any editorial favour to be shown to Ryanair I request that our good news stories be given the same consideration and space in your business pages as those of other leading Irish companies or small regional airlines such as Aer Lingus” says the right honourable McNamara..

    Didn’t they want to move to eastern Europe to save on minimum wage costs? The Irish flag is no more than a flag of convenience to these people.

    Comment by Toronto Icarus
    25.
    August 14, 2009
    6:44 am

    Consumers will really need to decide what they really want – and what they are prepared to pay for it!
    Unless the message goes back to the company (whatever company, in whatever industary) that the consumer will not support a poor product just because it is cheap, nothing will change. Why should it? The company is raking in the revenue without any pressure to deliver a proper service.
    In the US, JetBlue have taken steps to enhance their overall product in the belief that passengers are willing to pay a little extra for a good service. It will be interesting to see if their model works.

    Comment by AB
    26.
    August 14, 2009
    7:50 am

    Ryanair clearly know that not many people have Visa Electron. What they are doing is creating a veil of decency by saying “Well if you chose this way of paying then you wont be charged” even though it is virtually unavailable in virtually all states, including Ireland. We also know that Ryanair, always desperate to find extra charges would probably end this if they needed to increase their revenue stream.

    There was a time when their mantra was about increased efficiency. The baggage charge was implemented they said to quicken turn around times. However it is now a vital revenue stream for them. This has resulted in fact in slower times when getting on the plane as people desperately attempt to stuff bags into overhead lockers.

    Charging for online check in is absurd and a blatant means to extract more revenue. It is again diluted somewhat, like the visa electron by Ryanair saying “You should go on one of our promotional fares”. Sometimes there are none, simple as that. End this farce please at least.

    What really irks me about Ryanair is the horrendous amount of spin that is involved in attempting to justify nonsensical extra charges. If they would just be a bit more honest about things, then people would not be so annoyed.

    Finally all these extra charges have been at the expense of customer services and the general experience of traveling with Ryanair. AS stated in the news a few weeks ago concerning the debacle of Stansted August bank holiday weekend, Ryanair at the best of times has not enough bag drop off points and a horrendous lack of people at their desks to cope with people forgetting to pay one of their myriad of charges. If service was increased, more bag drop off counters open, more people at the desks things could-shock horror!-be tolerable.

    Comment by Conor O Neill
    27.
    August 14, 2009
    8:13 am

    Next Wed I’ll be taking my first Ryanair flight all year. I used to fly Ryanair all the time, but the lure of cheap flights wore off after a while. Now I tend to avoid Ryanair if possible, even if I have to pay more money to use another airline, to the extent that when I got married in April in Sicily, I organised all my family and friends to fly Aer Lingus or BA. Even though Ryanair fly direct Dublin to Sicily, no-one used Ryanair because everyone knows, if you really need to get somewhere on time, you don’t risk flying with Ryanair. Let me tick Ryanair’s faults as personally experienced by me;

    Worst Customer Service; check. 2 weeks of daily faxes to get a refund after Ryanair.com failed to send me flight confirmation.

    Worst Inflight Service; check. A 4 hour flight Trapani-Dublin with no water or food onboard!

    Worst Plane; check. Flickering lights on a Stansted-Dublin flight indicating a loose wire or short circuit. Staff unconcerned…

    Worst Staff; check. One wonders how disinterested staff with terrible English comprehension will cope in an emergency…

    Worst Delays; check. 09:30 flight delayed to 21:45.

    Worst Website: check.

    Of course, why do I fly? They’re cheap and sometimes convenient.

    Comment by sean
    28.
    August 14, 2009
    9:36 am

    There’s the exact point- if you don’t like the price, book with another airline. There are virtually no destinations Ryanair flies to that are without an alternative carrier (which probably goes to a more convenient airport). If you find that a non promotional fare, booked with a CC and checking luggage on Ryanair is more expensive than another carrier then book it. I haven’t personally ever had a problem with their punctuality but equally would be lairy about relying on Ryanair either to get me there on time or help if they don’t.

    Comment by Tom Ennis
    29.
    August 14, 2009
    9:43 am

    Hey conor – did you see this? http://www.irishtimes.com/letters/

    Madam, – I am contacting you in relation to the large article which appeared in your business section (“Aer Lingus passenger numbers rise 8.2 per cent”, August 11th). There was no reference to Ryanair’s passenger numbers for July, which reported growth of 19 per cent to over 6.7 million passengers.

    Ryanair, Europe’s largest airline, is one of only a few indigenous companies to lead its sector in Europe and it is worrying that our July passenger numbers, which were six times those of Aer Lingus and detailed our remarkable and newsworthy July growth, were overlooked by The Irish Times.

    While I do not expect any editorial favour to be shown to Ryanair I request that our good news stories be given the same consideration and space in your business pages as those of other leading Irish companies or small regional airlines such as Aer Lingus. – Yours, etc,

    STEPHEN McNAMARA,
    Head of Communications,
    Ryanair,
    Dublin Airport,
    Co Dublin.

    No mention of the leather seats, sadly

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    30.
    August 14, 2009
    10:36 am

    If I was the DAA I would install printers in the departures area of Dublin airport and I’d charge two euro to passengers to log on to the internet, enter their booking details and print their boarding card. That would really really annoy Ryanair and would allow DAA to get one over on them. It would be hilarious to listen to Ryanair spewing froth on the subject of the DAA ensuring they couldn’t make a pure forty euro profit on re-issuing a boarding card. :-)

    Comment by Laura
    31.
    August 14, 2009
    10:45 am

    Good grief, I am constantly amazed at all the gripes people have with Ryanair.

    You do know that you are not forced to fly with them, you can fly other airlines you know.

    However I suspect, like me, you don’t do that, you fly Ryanair.

    Why, simple. Ryanair might levy all sorts of fees and restrictions, but at the end of the day they get you there and are significantly cheaper than the alternative.

    I live in Stockholm these days and last May flew home with my wife and 2 children for a wedding (it was over the May bank holiday weekend).

    Cost with Ryanair for 2 adults + 2 children ~€280 + “the price gouging” for checking in 2 bags + Visa card + priority Q etc., add another ~€95. Total: ~€370

    Cheapest alternative airline: ~€1400 (just because it was a bank holiday weekend, but even if it were a normal weekend it usually costs about ~€700 to 800).

    The math is simple.

    So stop whining, you get what you pay for.

    Comment by Mike B
    32.
    August 14, 2009
    12:05 pm

    Ryanair are an enigma.
    The basic service they provide of cheap European travel is wonderful and has gone a long way to making the true integration of Europe a reality. But they do so in manner that is both antagonistic to and dismissive of their customers.
    The combative stance they take to all critics, be they individuals or governments, is regrettable and surprising. For all their success they can still improve and the first step would be to stop shouting and listen.
    I am a real customer who spends a considerable sum annually traveling between Sweden and Ireland. Their discontinuation of the Goteborg route for ‘political’ reasons has caused me, and many like me, great inconvenience. For the last year I have been trying to get an answer from the company as to whether they intend to re-instate this route but to no avail.
    A simple question but simply no reply.

    Comment by Michael Higgins
    33.
    August 14, 2009
    12:25 pm

    Hear, hear Mike B
    I’ve flown with Ryanair quite a bit. I accept what they do & how they do it. My requirement is to get from A to B within a reasonable time-frame & for as cheap as possible…and without crashing a lot :>)

    When they stop delivering that service, I’ll fly with someone else. But I won’t whinge about it.

    Comment by Seamus
    34.
    August 14, 2009
    1:27 pm

    Mr McNamara states: “Lack of communication during rare flight delays is equally untrue when any flight delays are updated in real time on our website and on airport flight information boards”

    On Wednesday Aug 6th, Ryanair cancelled many flights from Pisa airport because of a routine runway system technical check which they had been informed about on the 31st July by Pisa Airport. No other airline that day had to cancel their flights. The flight to Dublin due to leave at 17.30 was delayed for six hours.

    Fortunately for me I wasn’t flying that day: I had checked the Pisa Airport web and Ryanair’s site because I was flying to Dublin the next day and it’s always good to check when travelling Ryanair because they are never bothered to tell you anything.

    Next morning, the day of my flight, I checked the Ryanair site first thing. Everything OK. At midday before setting off to Pisa from Florence, I checked again. Everything fine. I arrived in Pisa at 3.30pm to find a six-hour delay announced on the flight to Dublin. What a coincidence! Suited them, I suppose, for some reason. Scammed once again by Ryanair.

    Ryanair’s response: a drink and a snack (please queue for voucher) at 8pm. No offer of re-routing (fat chance) or provision of free phone calls was made as should have been according to EU regulations applying to delays on flights of more than five hours.

    I travel frequently with Ryanair because it gets you from A to C which is sometimes quite close to B where you want to go. Mostly the flights are on time but I have never left a Ryanair plane without feeling slightly tainted and sour. And when a flight goes wrong, one thing is guaranteed: Ryanair does not care about you and, to put it rather crudely, has you by the knackers and intends to swing you about a bit. Frequent passengers are used to this and accept it stoically but that does not make the humiliation any less – the realisation that you cannot afford a proper airline.

    Ryanair’s airline code is FR. Clearly this is another error: it should have been FU

    Comment by Petrus Hibernicus
    35.
    August 14, 2009
    1:34 pm

    Hi Stephen (in case you ever read this page looking for some more snide comments to make in defense of your company),
    maybe 67 million fly with ryanair this year. However, my OH and I, who fly about 3-4 times a month between us, have long since given up ryanair and exclusively use Aer Lingus now. I’m sure you can figure out why. Oh and by the way – Ryanair aren’t actually cheaper for those flights. They work out about the same price.

    Regards,
    b.

    Comment by bluewolf
    36.
    August 14, 2009
    1:46 pm

    Rob Burke seems confused about the purpose of hot dogs, can we trust his judgement on airlines?:
    ‘when I choose to buy a hotdog from a street vendor in the early hours of Saturday morning, I know what I’m letting myself in for. And I embrace it.’

    Comment by Gordon
    37.
    August 14, 2009
    2:04 pm

    I despise Ryanair with the heat of a thousand burning nuns. The last time I flew with them, over a year ago and not by my choice, I was rudely yelled at by an attendant to go up the back stairs of the plane. A polite request because there was a hold up would have been appreciated, but no, a Ryanair harpie screeched at me (and others) and our flight was delayed by almost 2 hours.

    I’m heading to Barcelona next month and I hemmed and hawwed over whether to be gouged by Ryanair or Aer Lingus on stuff like baggage fees etc. Eventually, I went with Aer Lingus because at least they fly to Barcelona itself. Unfortunately, no other Dublin based airlines fly directly there, otherwise, I’d have opted to go with one of them.

    I’d dearly love to see Aer Arann expand. I fly with them from Waterford to the UK and it’s a pleasure. Aside from being only an hour away from me, I don’t have to be there 2 hours before the flight to check in and the flight always leaves on time.

    It’s the difference between a massage and a slap.

    Comment by Caroline
    38.
    August 14, 2009
    2:10 pm

    Agree with Laura, that would be a fantastic idea for DAA (or is it The AA, as I keep thinking the radio advert is saying :-) )

    Also, thanks to person who mentioned the Entropay Visa Electron card.

    Comment by Cristin
    39.
    August 14, 2009
    2:11 pm

    Hot dogs have a purpose?

    Comment by Tom Ennis
    40.
    August 14, 2009
    3:35 pm

    Stephen McNamara has proven himself to be Michael O’Leary’s Rottweiler – I remember his comments after Ryanair staff had engaged into the online bullying of Jason Roe, something about “that’s what you get when you mix the big boys” – truly obnoxious.

    We’re flying to Italy soon – not with Ryanair of course. Having to look at their “morning-piss” yellow and “blurple” (blue-purple) decor was just too much to contemplate. With all the ads, and ridiculously low-spec seats, their planes more closely resemble a LUAS – now complete with idiots on their mobiles.

    Comment by John in Celbridge
    41.
    August 14, 2009
    3:36 pm

    I fly Ryanair every week….so am I a Ryanair fan? No, I am just taking the carrier that gets me nearest to where I have to go, at the time closest to what I am looking for, and at the price that is the cheapest. There is an old saying…..pay peanuts…get monkeys.

    But without them, I would not be working as I need to fly every week to London for my job. I used to complain in the line when the gate was changed, the air-conditioning was not working in the departure hall, etc……but it is all relative…now I am just so delighted when they managed to get home to Ireland.

    I could complain about their 1 cent fairs costing €33 after fees, but in the end, I am going to travel with the cheapest option….and so far…that is Ryanair.

    Comment by William
    42.
    August 14, 2009
    5:00 pm

    If Ryanair are so bad why are so many people flying wth them? Surely we all have free will

    Comment by Ted O'Connor
    43.
    August 14, 2009
    5:08 pm

    looks like the moral of the story is nobody likes Ryanair but we’ll continue to use them until a better deal comes along, at which point they’ll realise goodwill is actually a valuable asset

    Comment by Tom Ennis
    44.
    August 14, 2009
    5:25 pm

    I have to say considering all the “faults” Ryanair have they are good at one thing. Forcing 67 Million people to buy there tickets and board the planes must be very difficult but they seem to be doing an amazing job!

    Comment by Trevor
    45.
    August 14, 2009
    7:31 pm

    I do believe that things will change soon. The increasing amount of extra charging and uncalled for charges such as €40 for forgetting your boarding pass will make people go for what is convenient and only a little bit more expensive. To say that you can fly with someone else discards the fact that Ryanair flies to certain airports only (and I am not talking about 90m away airports like Frankfurt).

    I think DAA should put in printers in the airport. Of course Ryanair will try and prevent it by placing a time limit that prevents you from accessing it so close to your departure in the airport but you can always make a program that when you book your flight you can send a copy to a DAA website and print it if you forget it at the airport.

    Comment by Conor O Neill
    46.
    August 14, 2009
    10:13 pm

    I am no fan of Ryanair, and have enough experience of their foibles (on on flight they had no spoons and I had to stir my coffee with a biro!!) but… when I buy tickets for Ryanair no one is holding a gun to my head. You know what you get (or don’t get in many cases) when you book Ryanair so I think it’s pretty rich to criticise them afterwards, if you want better service, etc then use some other airline… that said there is an opportunity for an airline that charges higher fares but gives a better service!

    Comment by Noel Fitzpatrick
    47.
    August 15, 2009
    12:08 am

    I’ve had a really stupid idea. How about one chooses not to fly Ryanair. I did once in 1998 and have never done so since. Take O’Leary’s own terms and use them to your advantage – “vote with your pocket”. I have and choose AerLingus (brilliant), BA (good) and KLM (excellent) and have never had a bad experience in 10 years of weekly European and Trans-Atlantic flights. I once went from Dublin to Rome with BA cheaper than Ryanair and was not spat at once by AerLingus staff – fancy that!?
    To those who can’t afford the flag-carrier airlines, maybe you can’t afford Ryanair either?

    Comment by Tom
    48.
    August 15, 2009
    12:15 am

    Go on Stephen. You get it into them…, they just don’t get it!
    I on the other hand ‘get it’ and never use your airline or never will; no hard feelings I’m sure? I would rather chew off my own arm and use it as a flotation device – your airline really is that bad. But then, I don’t eat at McDonalds either.

    Comment by Tom
    49.
    August 15, 2009
    11:31 am

    I love ryanair…I get exactly what I pay for. I know when a flights costs ‘1c’, that it will actually cost quite a bit more because I’ve a very good understanding of the fees.

    People who get ‘ripped off’ by ryanair are just asking for it by assuming it’s the same as your normal carriers. It isn’t. It’s a low-fare carrier…expect to pay for everything above basic fare…

    Comment by Neil
    50.
    August 15, 2009
    2:31 pm

    @Neil it’s the high price of the charges for the extras that Pees people off. Making everyone on a booking check in when there is only one bag to check in thats €80 return for a family of 4. If your printer is low or out of ink €40 euro for them to reprint it. it’s this kind of extortion that everyone objects to. The charging to the aircraft to ensure you can sit with family or friends. No helping of passengers with young children and charging extra to help someone to the boarding gate with a wheelchair (a charge we all pay for now no choice). And if some one else tries to charge for extra services at the airport who’s the first to complain Ryanair. Take the bag for gels and shampoos the DAA where issuing them for free and then started charging €1 who was the first to complain.

    Comment by ALAN
    51.
    August 15, 2009
    9:20 pm

    New Ryanair policy seems to be to bully anyone who complains or seeks to point out their faults.

    There is a serious issue over credit card charges, and Visa Electron is patently NOT available in Ireland.

    Mr McNamara comes across as arrogant and unwilling to listen, as he did in the recent RTE report on a member of the public who spotted a flaw on Ryanair’s website.

    Small wonder more people are purposely AVOIDING Ryanair completely, and returning to Aer Lingus and others, who clearly know what customer service is.

    And as for “our onboard advertising and yellow livery are much beloved by our passengers”, is this guy for real?! If he can find a survey conducted to back that up, he needn’t worry about the Irish Times letting readers send in their comments!

    Comment by David O'Hara
    52.
    August 15, 2009
    10:06 pm

    stephen McNamara says because 67million passengers fly with ryanair and This is a sign of they love Ryanair. millions Smoke does this make it healthier

    Comment by ALAN
    53.
    August 15, 2009
    11:03 pm

    A number of people have posed the general question: why fly with Ryanair, no one is pointing a gun to your head?

    Not a single one of the complaints on this post deals with that point. The only people making any sense are those who say ‘I was treated this way, I haven’t used them since’. The rest of you are being daft.

    If you forget your boarding pass then you should consider the €40 a fine for stupidity, it’s a very fair question – what would you do if you ‘forgot’ your passport? Or you ‘forgot’ your ticket to a gig or a match?…

    And really how hard is it to remember to mentally add approx 32 quid in charges, and whatever for baggage, to whatever fare they’re quoting for an international flight?

    I said it on the other piece – I fly both Ryanair and Aer Lingus regularly and Ryanair are simply better – cheaper and more punctual.

    Comment by dealga
    54.
    August 16, 2009
    12:56 am

    It’s becoming increasingly clear that Stephen McNamara and Michael O’Leary are not the only obnoxious tools in the shed; this whole “stop whining and don’t fly Ryanair” excuse is ridiculously obnoxious BS.

    Allow me to draw an analogy: you have to get your appendix out and can’t afford private healthcare / don’t have insurance. You do it via the State and the hospital is dirty, the doctor is rude and the aftercare is non-existent. Are your complaints null and void because you “could have voted with your pocket”?

    Some people have little choice but to fly with Ryanair unless they want to stay stranded in Ireland for the rest of their lives and read about travelling via AA Gill and various IT journos who seem to spend an awful lot of time going to Berlin.

    It hardly seems too much to ask that you be treated with some respect, and that there be some transparency from Ryanair itself. We all know that they’re going to attempt to drain every last drop of money from you; why can’t they just admit it?

    The last time I flew Ryanair, it was right after the “one bag to include handbag” rule came in – previously, you were allowed to bring a handbag and one item of hand luggage. At no point were we alerted to this (although it was in the fine print which we neglected to read but really, life’s too short) and my Mother got quite irate when she was told she’d have to put her handbag into her suitcase, which was really not looking very viable.

    I then put it into mine, swapped some items around and we checked on one item of luggage – not before the air hostess knelt on my luggage (without my asking for help), hopped up and down a few times and zipped it up for me (how I prayed she’d broken something expensive) and another Ryanair employee told me: “If we let you on with two bags, I’ll get fired. It’s a recession, I need this job.” Thank you for that enlightening pep talk but your job is not my problem. I used to work in retail and now realise how well I could have done if I’d bullied people into buying. “If you don’t buy that €2,000 Mathew Williamson dress, I’ll get fired.” Yeah.

    And doesn’t that McNamara fella sound like a real whinger? “Wah, wah, wah, everyone talks about Aer Lingus when we’re doing well too.” Pass the tissues.

    Comment by Rosemary
    55.
    August 16, 2009
    9:29 am

    I love Ryanair. Anyone who goes by Ryanair and expects to be dropped off in a city center is only fooling themselves. We all know how they operate so why are so many idiots shocked when they are dropped 20 miles away? Read their website. People want top class service but they won’t pay for it. Then they bitch and complain. If you don’t like Ryanair go to KLM.com. You might pay $300 for a flight to London but you’ll get a free drink and be dropped in Heathrow. Yippee. Then its an hour and a half jammed into an underground train to get to London. Or you can pay $10 to get to Stansted and another $10 to get the nice comfortable train with the quiet carriage to Liverpool st. I believe Ryanair sell the train tickets at a discount on their flight before you even land.
    Ryanair are honest. They tell you that they are going to charge for everything. Its the other airlines people should be complaining about.
    With Ryanair you know you’re about to be shafted so you lube up and prepare yourself for it. Aer Lingus just sneak up behind you and take you by surprise. I know which one I’d prefer…

    Comment by Kevin
    56.
    August 16, 2009
    3:30 pm

    @Rosemary- your analogy is flawed. If I have appendicitis, treatment can only be considered optional if I consider death a viable alternative. People justifiably debate equal access to healthcare as a fundamental human right. I don’t ‘need’ to fly to London for a shopping trip.

    Comment by Tom Ennis
    57.
    August 16, 2009
    5:11 pm

    Conor O’Neill : Ryanair DOES has a time limitation re online check-in. They open from 15 days to 4 hours prior to flight time. So if you’ve forgot to check-in, unless you arrive more than 4 hours ahead of your flight time, I’m afraid DAA provision of printer will not be useful.

    What I do do, is, when printing the boarding pass after online check-in, is to print a copy to PDF (i.e. create a PDF file using the print function) and this way, I can email myself a copy in case I need to print a copy closer to time if I’ve left the printed copy elsewhere, and not have to worry that I can’t access Ryanair’s website to reprint my boarding pass.

    Alan, in future, if you have only one bag to check-in but multiple travellers are to be booked in, why not book for one person separately from everyone else? This way you’re not going to pay unnecessary luggage check-in costs. Sure it’s a slight inconvenience to have to do check-in twice, with separate confirmation code etc, but it’s still a money-saving move.

    Comment by Lil
    58.
    August 16, 2009
    7:13 pm

    @Tom, you’ll notice I didn’t offer you a choice of having your appendix removed, the choice was in the amount of money you choose to pay to do it. Flying isn’t a necessity for everyone, that’s not what I was saying.

    My point is this: if you are treated badly, regardless of how much you pay for it, or the “standard” of the service you’re using, it’s pretty ridiculous to deny you a right to complain.

    And all analogies are flawed, are they not? One thing cannot be another. People get all angsty when it comes to healthcare so I possibly should have chosen something else, but it seemed a useful way to compare standards of treatment of human beings.

    Comment by Rosemary
    59.
    August 17, 2009
    3:53 am

    Rosemary, I don’t think that Ryanair denies you the right to complain, they just tell up straight up that they are not going to listen to you (I wouldn’t be surprised if Stephen McNamara’s email had a filter which automatically driected any email with “complaint” in it, straight to his spam folder!!!
    Also if people are not willing to use Ryanair nor willing to pay for Aer Lingus or another airline then let them get the ferry/train…

    Comment by Noel Fitzpatrick
    60.
    August 17, 2009
    10:59 am

    Have been flying commercial airlines the last 30 years mostly as a business traveler, and have seen many changes in the airline industry. I think most people would agree that the Ryanair business model of low fares has had a positive impact on reducing air fares in general, on short haul routes, and for that they should be commended.

    However, the choice of whether to fly with Ryanair or not, is just that, a choice.

    I choose not to travel with them.

    My reasoning has little to do with cost, and more to do with customer service. Ryanair are a transactional airline only interested in the fare; my view is that they are not interested in providing you with a pleasant flying experience, they presume that a low fare will continue to attract your business irrespective of customer service. The relationship with you the customer for repeat business is based solely on a low fare nothing else. And a low fare structure which changes periodically, as they try to change customer behaviour to meet to their needs, where you the customer are effectively fined if you fail to comply. Acceptable to some, unacceptable to others, of which I am one.

    While the head of the airline is something of a character; I struggle to understand why everyone else in the organisation has to try and emulate his style of arrogant bullying communications as is evident in the reply from Mr McNamara. I would also add that in my view his reply is also insulting and juvenile to the readers of Price Watch, who are in effect his customers.

    Comment by Mark
    61.
    August 17, 2009
    11:24 am

    Fair enough. Surely though when two similiar services are offered, you would expect the cheaper one to be of a lower quality? Look, I really don’t disagree with you as much as it appears and I usually do look forward to a Ryanair flight with trepidation. Absolutely the customer should have the right to complain (Conor has previously made the point that we don’t really complain enough) but if after a bad experience you continue to use their service, surely you are only rewarding the sharp practices? It must be pretty apparent at this point that the only thing that will discourage O’Leary is falling revenue. Criticism only seems to fuel his ego

    Comment by Tom Ennis
    62.
    August 17, 2009
    12:25 pm

    Re fault # 2. Sunday August 16. Luton to Dublin, due to leave at 8.25pm. Flight delayed… plane probably late landing from what i could see. Meant to arrive in Dublin at 9.25pm… arrived around 10.25pm. Total joke – no explanation, reason, excuse or apology. But at least we didn’t have to listen to that on-time jingle! Oh, the Dublin-Luton flight was also delayed by about 15/20 mins on Friday evening :)

    Comment by DH
    63.
    August 17, 2009
    6:36 pm

    lil what would you suggest if I Booked 1 seat and then went on to book the other 3 only to discover there are not 3 seats available Info I would have received when booking four seats .ie four seats not available.

    Comment by ALAN
    64.
    August 17, 2009
    8:51 pm

    Well all, see Ryanair at it again inconveniencing there passengers by leaving Manchester because they wont drop there fees to suit Ryanair and now forcing passengers to travel to other English airports costing them more in Bus/Train fares to get to there destination Manchester.

    Comment by ALAN
    65.
    August 18, 2009
    10:21 am

    Alan, hmmm, check first if there are 4 seats available before booking? Or, if there are 2 computers at the same time, to do the booking simultaneously? I don’t really know to be honest, but I know of people who have done that (hence why I suggested that).

    I guess, unless you’re booking at the really last minute or for an extremely popular flight, the odds are better for successful separate bookings than seat unavailability.

    Otherwise, I guess it’s redistribution of the 15kgs to be carried as carry-on luggages between 4 passengers?

    Unfortunately, travelling with Ryanair is never straightforward unless one is travelling only from point to point, has little to carry, flexible re flight time and airport location, and is on his/her own. And oh, has a travel insurance.

    Comment by Lil
    66.
    August 20, 2009
    4:32 pm

    Alan,

    You can fly Dublin to Manchester daily with Aer Lingus for anything between 40 and 90 euro. So what’s your problem?

    Comment by dealga
    67.
    August 25, 2009
    9:01 am

    I’m flying with Ryanair this weekend because they are 62.33% cheaper than Aer Lingus (including all charges) on the exact same route.

    Comment by Peter Buchanan
    68.
    August 31, 2009
    5:02 am

    Is it my imagination or are Ryanair moving the rows of seats closer together by about an inch or so every month to get more in? I’m six foot and it sure seems like it. I’ll have to get roll-up legs

    Comment by gerard
    69.
    September 20, 2009
    4:36 pm

    Maith thú Conor!

    Why do people continue to fly with these morons, I don’t think they’re that cheap or convenient when you add up all the hidden charges and draconian conditions!

    I hate Ryanair as much as I can possibly hate something.

    Comment by Senorita

    Leave a comment

    When submitted, your comment will be moderated and, once approved, will appear on the site.

    The Irish Times reserves the absolute right not to publish comments.


Search Pricewatch