• RSS
  • Text Size:
  • -
  • irishtimes.com - Posted: May 1, 2009 @ 11:18 pm

    Many Irish brands to disappear

    Conor Pope

    DOZENS OF grocery brands which are popular in the Republic will start disappearing from the shelves of Tesco stores from Tuesday as the retail giant launches a major restructuring of its stock. Industry sources say many familiar brands will be removed from stores close to the Border and in at least one new store in Cork from next week as Tesco seeks to more closely mirror the product offerings and prices available in its British stores.

    Up to 13 stores in Border counties as well as a large Tesco Extra outlet in Cork will initially be affected by the change aimed at combating the continued migration of shoppers from the Republic across the Border in search of better value.

    Consumers in the Republic are considered more brand conscious than shoppers in other jurisdictions, but the economic downturn, coupled with a weakened sterling, has seen British chains such as Sainsburys and Asda operating in Border towns profit from a dramatic increase in cross-Border business.

    When they travel North, consumers from south of the Border are willing to buy cheaper but less familiar products and Tesco is understood to be keen to stress-test this shifting brand loyalty.

    Some established Irish brands will retain a presence on the shelves but many will see their prominence significantly downgraded as the retailer moves to wean shoppers off certain products. While the move will initially affect only a small number of stores, Tesco is understood to be keen to implement the changes across the State.

    Camile O’Flanagan of Barry’s Tea confirmed that the range and amount of its products stocked by Tesco Ireland’s northeastern shops as well as one Tesco outlet in Cork will fall. She said some of its familiar brands would have significantly smaller displays while others would be dropped altogether. “We are a major player in the Irish tea market and it would be a concern for us if people could not get our products.”

    In the affected branches, Tesco has adopted UK planograms – the layout plans illustrating how and where products should be displayed – so the stores will now replicate the layout and design of stores in Britain.

    Tesco declined to comment but a source familiar with the retail giant’s operation confirmed it would be making “a significant announcement” on Tuesday.

    He insisted it would be more focused on lower prices than range and denied it would negatively impact on products sourced from the Republic.

  • 10 Comments »

    1.
    May 2, 2009
    11:47 am

    Tesco seem not to understand the Irish shopper, few British retailers fully do. Just because the shops look like British ones and ‘feel’ like them too, but at Irish prices, won’t make people buy products like they would in an actual British one. There is a sense of difference when people go up north and buy different brands but I’ll be surprised if they will shop the same in the south as they would up north because of a different layout which will go unnoticed by most people.

    Comment by Daniel
    2.
    May 2, 2009
    1:25 pm

    Many Irish consumers seem to suffer from some kind of delusion that things produced in Ireland are better than anybody else’s, and this extraordinary loyalty is in my opinion often abused by both producers and retailers who know that people will buy just about anything as long as it’s made in Ireland.
    How else can you explain the very low quality of most Irish pork (full of water), bacon (full of salt and water), sausages (45% meat), poultry etc. (The beef tends to be better for some reason). In reality, most average Irish chicken, bacon and sausages are only fit for the bin (just ask Richard Corrigan).
    I think we’d all be much better off if people were genuinely discerning, and truly demanding and fussy about quality instead of country of origin.

    Comment by Jonathan
    3.
    May 2, 2009
    10:06 pm

    It might not be just certain products that will disappear but maybe Tesco will do a disappearing act again like they did during our last recession and left the country when the going got tough.

    Comment by John
    4.
    May 3, 2009
    9:41 pm

    I have to say, and it might be to do with insane patriotism (delusional or otherwise), this decision will seriously influence my shopping. That is to say, I’ll be shopping in Aldi, Lidl or Superquinn before I shop in Tesco. Why don’t they try to negotiate deals with Irish producers to lower prices, rather than resort to UK produce? This has the potential to cause serious harm to the Irish economy, and I’d rather encourage retailers who are doing their bits to help both consumer and supplier (Superquinn just because it’s Irish, I guess, because the prices aren’t doing anybody any favours).

    Comment by Rosemary
    5.
    May 4, 2009
    4:40 pm

    Irish Government have done nothing to protect Irish jobs in the food industry and now they have let the 3rd largest retailer in the world totally dominate the much smaller and more vulnerable local Irish producer. Where is the Government to stand up to this?? On trips to Quatar while Tesco change the face of our shopping forever. Where will Tesco be when sterling strengthens?? Back counting their money in Essex while the thousands of former Irish employees that have lost their jobs in former suppliers collect their dole? Where are the farmers to put pressure on the things that matter?? Trying to stop the publication of the Euro payments . We all need to get real and demand Tesco and all major retailers act in the interests of all Irish shoppers for the long term , not just their interests for the short term.

    Comment by james
    6.
    May 5, 2009
    12:34 pm

    Thanks so much for flagging this, Conor. This really has serious implications for Irish food suppliers (and Irish customers, who may see their favourite foods disappear).

    Comment by Kieran
    7.
    May 5, 2009
    12:36 pm

    Basically, Tesco is loosing (southern Ire.) business to ASDA and Sainsbury across the border as it does not have any stores over the border – to combat this they are going to offer products a bit cheaper than the rest of the republic to try and stop some of the southern shoppers going as far as ASDA and Sainsburys. So not really trying to be competitive in the South just try to avoid the competition of the shops based in the North. Call me cynical!!! Hopefully, the media and Irish public will not be naive and see it as anything else!! I was in Belfast two weeks ago and stopped into a Tesco branch there, the difference in prices was jaw dropping eventhough I was aware there was some difference, I didn’t realise how vast!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by Cags
    8.
    May 5, 2009
    4:58 pm

    If Tesco stores south of the border offer UK prices, is this just creating a problem for retailers outside this soon-to-be UK shopping zone? Where does it all end? Instead of going to Newry to shop, I’ll go to Dundalk but I’m still migrating my spend away from Dublin. I guess that Tesco dosen’t care where in the ROI it generates sales but local store managers in the periphery of the border counties will not be happy surely?

    Comment by Garrett
    9.
    May 5, 2009
    6:16 pm

    But when I cross the border, it’s brands that I am familiar with here that are a lot cheaper – and I mean a lot. Innocent Smoothies with are €5 in the ROI for a litre – 2 litres for £4 in Sainsburys Newry, Tropicana juices the same, Sanex toileteries, Persil and so on. There can be no justification for the differentials – even factoring in increased wage and operational costs. What Irish brands are we talking about? Is there such a thing anymore?

    Comment by Peter B
    10.
    May 5, 2009
    6:23 pm

    I don’t think the Government can do very much – unless they strictly impose border controls which would limit the amounts of alcohol and high value items being imported into the republic. We are an open economy with the EU and we have to operate in that basis. If Irish produce cannot compete with British produce, then it will have to do something to become competitive. I firmly believe that a lot of Irish producers and retailers forgot about offering a sound value proposition to consumers, but charged as much as they could get away with. In addition, it’s a clear indicator of the cost base in Ireland, which is too high and must be tackled to restore competitiveness.

    Comment by Peter B

    Leave a comment

    When submitted, your comment will be moderated and, once approved, will appear on the site.

    The Irish Times reserves the absolute right not to publish comments.


Search Pricewatch