On The Record

  • On The Record at Primavera

    June 2, 2009 @ 10:20 am | by Jim Carroll

    When the time comes to compile the blame report for sluggish and slow festival ticket sales in Ireland this summer, the finger-pointing can probably begin with flights to Barcelona and Girona last week. Every single flight heading from Ireland to Catalunya for a couple of days must have been full to the brim with Primavera-bound punters. While the Primavera Sound organise don’t compile a geographical breakdown of where the 70,000 punters who hoof their way to the Parc del Forum hail from, there’s no doubt that there was easily a couple of thousand Irish in the mix - and that’s not just the very drunk young wan giving out yards to the man at the crepe stand because he didn’t have any butter. Rather than spending their hard-earned cash on Irish fests, these punters decided to spend that money on a flight, a ticket and an apartment or hotel room in Barcelona instead. Many too may have extended their trip for a couple of days and made a holiday out of it. And they still had enough cash left over for some tapas.

    While some might think that a Primavera-style fest would work wonders back home, the sums just don’t add up. Are there really 70,000 Irish folks who’d go mental for an hour with Sunn O)))? If there was, we’d have Sunn O))) playing every GAA field in the land. And would all those Sunn O))) fans be as tolerant and nonchalant about the huge amount of sponsorship and branding which Primavera have onboard to help them pay the bills and keep the ticket price low? Listen bud, there’d be a 14 page thread about that on Thumped before you could say “Raybans”.

    No, Primavera works in Barcelona for a whole lot of reasons, from its location and climate to the fact that, well, it’s not Ireland or London or Berlin. Just as Sonar has been a magnet for the international ‘lectronic underground since 1997, Primavera has become the indie and underground hipster’s favourite city break. Actually, on that score alone, LATFH wouldn’t know where to look at Parc del Forum. Aside from the city, the venue also helps. Parc del Forum is a gorgeous spot for a bash of this sort, all crazy angles, Lego block architecture and off-beam spaces looking out over the sea.

    Due to bumping into the bus bringing the triumphant FC Barcelona into town, my plans to start my two nights at the fest with Girls went astray. Instead, I caught The Vaselines (not very convincing amplified twee - I know that Kurt Cobain rated them, but he also rated smack), The Tallest Man On Earth (now, this is how you do the singer-songwriter thing - restless stage presence, gorgeous tunes) and Marnie Stern (once you’ve seen her live more than once, you realise she’s a bit of an one-trick pony) as I wandering around out and got my bearings about where the various stages were located.

    All that wandering around did produce one major highlight. Lightning Bolt! Man, where have they been all my life? One of the most manic, intense, fuzzy, freaky, thoroughly enjoyable live shows I’ve seen in an age. Punk rock drums and bass to the max. I can’t wait to see them again. By the way, apologies to the Irish dude in the No Age t-shirt I elbowed in the face in the mosh-pit.

    Other night one observations: Yo La Tengo open their set by wigging out with great gusto for about 20 minutes, but the rest of their set was a little smug and anti-climatic by comparison. Bowerbirds are trying very (very) hard to be The National with an accordian, but really convince when they move in a completely different direction. The Jesus Lizard’s David Yow comes onstage, takes off his shirt and stagedives into the audience. No harm in starting as you mean to go on and Yow throws some fantastic shapes and rasps some great lines as the other Lizards build up a wild, stunning head of steam. Jay Reatard was as scuzzy as Memphis garage rockers come, though he seemed to be in one hell of a hurry with his set. I thought Wavves just couldn’t get his shit together and wandered off to see someone else - turns out the surf-punk dude was throwing one hell of a hissy fit. OTR says: don’t do the dope if you can’t do the time. Aphex Twin and My Bloody Valentine both played the “hits”.

    The other highlight from night one? That would be Phoenix. Yeah, I know, I’m surprised too, especially after listening to and reviewing their new album “Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix”. Live, though, it was all brash and bright pop hooks hitting home runs at every turn. Absolutely lovely. Memo to self: listen to that album again.

    On night two, The Pains Of Being Pure at Heart were the ones to revel in as they turned the Pitchfork stage into a house of love. I’d really liked their show at SXSW but subsequent gigging has lifted them up several notches. Of course, they were also playing in Barcelona, a city where indie kids are born with a love of C86 cuteness with a touch of noise-pop thrown in.

    Elsewhere, future Fox News commentator Damian “Pink Eyes” Abraham and his Fucked Up mates raged hard, Spiritualized were blissful, dreamy and gloriously out-there, St Etienne’s “Nothing Can Stop Us Now” was an indication that some pop highs never end, Sunn O))) droned on in the most chilling subterranean manner possible playing “The Grimmrobe Demos” album in full, Crystal Antlers were absolute rubbish, Dan Deacon’s Ensemble show was basically Dan Deacon to the power of 10 though there were fewer takers for the run-around-the-room party games than he gets in Ireland, Throwing Muses took things back to 1993 and I spent 10 pointless minutes watching Jarvis Cocker before I realised I had much better things to do with my life. Like my VAT return. Or weeding the garden.

  • 48 Comments »

    1.
    June 2, 2009
    10:35 am

    i didn’t go this year, having been to 4 in row i decided to take a break. is there really 70,000? i never got the impression there was that many at it.

    Comment by petee
    2.
    June 2, 2009
    10:37 am

    Ditto on Wavves,I was wondering when he’d become interested in the gig before my girlf dragged me away from ‘this fuckin shit’. Just saw the beginning of his little incident.
    Didn’t think Jay Reatard was as good as I was hoping he’d be and I actually enjoyed The Vaselines for the pure ‘I’m sitting in the sun,drinking beer and about to have a fantastic weekend’ factor. I probably would have enjoyed Oasis at that point.
    I’ll have me full DropD write-up later on (declaration of interest and all that craic - I write for them every so often) but gotta say Ghostface Killah was a surprising highlight and The Bug was incredible as were the Jesus Lizard
    Have also got a great video clip of an Irish dude with orange hair being really obnoxious at Spiritualized.
    Anyone know who he was? It’ll be on youtube later,I promise

    Comment by adam
    3.
    June 2, 2009
    10:38 am

    petee - that’s the figure I was given, but I have a feeling it’s probably 70k over three days. Also, I’d be very curious to get a read of the number of Irish there - certainly, on Thursday night, there were Irish accents everywhere you went, though less so on Friday

    adam - yeah, i also concur on The Bug (missing from the notes above). And you also touched on one really enjoyable part of Primavera - just that sitting around in the sun or in the balmy night listening to music in the open-air. Can’t beat that - though I would draw the line at being happy to listen to Oasis!

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    4.
    June 2, 2009
    10:51 am

    they’re is definite burnout at primavera among the irish crowd. mates have mine have gone before with me and not shown up on the friday.
    it’s a marthon not a sprint :)

    Comment by petee
    5.
    June 2, 2009
    10:56 am

    Highlights included Michael Nyman, Wooden Shjips, Andrew Bird, Deerhunter and The Vaselines (the Spanish sure do love their jingle-janglely pop).

    Loved seeing the line of workmen with hardhats and yellow vests peering over the wire fence at the Ray-ban Vice stage watching ACR deliver a wicked Shack Up at 2.30 in the morning.

    Seemingly the capacity is 25,000 per day. They definately had a capacity crowd for Sat with Neil Young but there’s no way there was 25k there Thurs and Fri. Way way more Irish there compared to 2 years ago. Great weekend!

    Comment by Paul
    6.
    June 2, 2009
    10:58 am

    Pluggy plug plug - we’ll have our write up soon hopefully, the whole ‘work’ thing is getting in the way of writing it up.

    I had a ball and the tallest man on earth really was something special.
    Girls were good too jim, they seem like the kind of band who can get away with lyrics that would induce cringes from anyone else. I too left the sup-bar wavves pre-meltdown.

    I thought the sound on the main stage was a bit of a let down at times - i took in MBV from the grassy knoll at the back and it was a mess, though I was told it worked better up front. no such problems in the auditori.

    Comment by Joe
    7.
    June 2, 2009
    11:01 am

    Was curious about the number of people there too actually - if there was 70,000 then, by the Gods, it didn’t seem like that. Well organised stuff, so it was so it was.
    I read a comment somewhere (probably thumped…) that the food was crap too?
    I thought the food was nice actually and you could get lovely coffee too for when you hit the wall….which was every few hours, to be honest.
    I stayed in the hotel across the road, which had a rooftop pool and cocktail bar. Woke up one morning listening to Neil Young sound-checking for a half hour. Bliss.

    Comment by adam
    8.
    June 2, 2009
    11:02 am

    Was at primivera the last two years.Both years the only drunk obnoxious people I saw at the festival were Irish. The only people I saw drunk in the q to get in to the fest on the first day were Irish. The only people who were shouting bring on Mundy and Aslan at the Low gig at PS 07 were Irish.

    Comment by demon
    9.
    June 2, 2009
    11:08 am

    petee - irish people abroad at fests usually fall over by day 2.

    paul - ooooh, i wish i’d seen Michael Nyman too. And yeah, I think 25k per day makes more sense.

    joe - tallest man on earth is the business and I really like the way he seems to staring right at you no matter where you are standing in the crowd. Dude’s creepy.

    adam - i thought the food was fine - a cut above standard festival fare, especially the Neil Young and My Bloody Valentine sandwiches

    demon - there’s one or two or a couple of hundred in every crowd.

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    10.
    June 2, 2009
    11:19 am

    Was very surprised at just how many people there where. Much bigger crowds than I expected to be honest.

    The heavy sponsorship was expected but the sheer volume of it was still surprising. Crowd i was with wasn’t in anyway bothered by it though. Maybe because it was a novel brand. Worst part was, that the beer in question tasted like arse.

    Highlights included:

    Thurs: Ponytail
    Fri: MBV (auditori)
    Sat: Neil Young

    disappointed with the number of bands I hadn’t seen before and enjoyed. Thursday had Jesus Lizard, Ponytail (at the cost of missing MBV and subsequently then Sunn O))) )
    Friday seemed to just completely drop of at about 1. Then back to a lot of clashes on Saturday.

    Comment might seem very negative but i did have a great time, more so to do with the crowd I was with than being at what pitchfork quoted as “one of the raddest independent music festivals in the world”.
    Great lineup and great acts but less memorable performances than i expected.

    Comment by Bold Lump
    11.
    June 2, 2009
    11:27 am

    Bold - The reason I mentioned the sponsorship is because, as you point out, there was so much of it yet without it, PS could not operate that low ticket price and still book that quantity of quality acts. It’s a case of how sponsorship works in the interest of the punter.

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    12.
    June 2, 2009
    11:40 am

    We are so over-exposed to sponsorship and advertising these days, you just kind of tune out dontxa (see what I did there?) and it makes no difference how many times you see the logos anymore. Electric Picnic take note - I couldn’t care less if the ‘Electric Arena’ was called the ‘Dr Quirkey’s Goodtime Emporium featuring Denny’s sausages adn Tampax’ Arena if you can get MBV to play twice while booking Aphex, Neil Young, Michael Nymanand the whole bloody lot while lopping a tonne off the ticket price.

    Comment by adam
    13.
    June 2, 2009
    11:41 am

    Jim - Oh don’t I know it. Chairs, parasols, tickets, pass cards, stage awnings, crowd barriers, utter and complete saturation.
    Ticket price was a pittance though so there’s the pay off.

    Visual pollution isn’t nearly enough to ruin a gig for me. My biggest grievance was there was no alternative beer.

    Sure even Glastonbury has had an awful beer as an official sponsor for years. The fact that there’s still close to a dozen different ciders, let alone lagers on offer means I don’t care.

    It’s clear there’s a financial payoff in the form of reduced price tickets but compare it to what your beer spend is likely to be (outside the VIP bubble) and it’s working more to the companies interest than the punters.

    Comment by Bold Lump
    14.
    June 2, 2009
    11:47 am

    Keeping things Out Foreign, anyone heading to any of the other festivals this summer like Melt, Exit or Field Day etc?

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    15.
    June 2, 2009
    11:52 am

    Was thinking of maybe Dour but lineup so far isn’t impressing me nearly as much as last year.
    Already have a flight home booked for No Fun Fest Europe

    Comment by Bold Lump
    16.
    June 2, 2009
    11:57 am

    Ponytail were the band of the festival for me. I can now claim to be fully obsessed with that bunch, made diving out of bed and grabbing a taxi to joan miro park on Sat morning totally worthwhile.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amE7pHpaY8M

    Lightning Bolt, MBV, Dan Deacon (when he did get around to playing songs), Magik Markers, Oneida, Sleepy Sun, The Bug, Mahjongg, Neil Young and The Drones were the ones that pushed my buttons the most. As Joe said above we’ll have a proper rundown soon.

    Nice to arrive home to a heatwave, makes it less of a shock to an already shocked system.

    Comment by flynnduism
    17.
    June 2, 2009
    12:00 pm

    as for foreign festivals jim heading to field day (went last year enjoyed it though the weather was muggy. Also going to Oya festival in oslo, line up is hitting all the right marks for me with grizzly bear, fever ray, gang gang dance and amanda blank on the line up.

    Comment by tl
    18.
    June 2, 2009
    12:03 pm

    ti - ooooooh oyafest is lovely. A great setting right near the city-centre, brilliant line-up and excellent food. Was there in 2005, highly recommended!

    flynnnduism - wish I’d seen more of The Drones, liked the one song I heard when I was walking past the stage. And Dan Deacon should really cut out the games when they’re obviously not working (except for the Irish in attendance)

    Bold - I did Exit last summer which was, uhm, interesting. Would like to go back to Italia Wave in Tuscany (kraftwerk are headlining) and Melt’s line-up sounds good

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    19.
    June 2, 2009
    12:07 pm

    Finally some love for Phoenix, one of the most under-rated bands around. Their last Irish show was SO good.

    The new album is a grower, I promise, apart from the instant classics Lisztomania and 1901.

    Comment by Bobby
    20.
    June 2, 2009
    12:08 pm

    I had a great weekend.

    Only got there on the Friday myself and I’m pretty gutted to hear Aphex Twin played the hits, oh well. My highlights were Bat for Lases, Art Brut, Dan Deacon & Neil Young. It was my first time seeing Deerhunter who I thought were amazing.

    I did think it was organised very well - the volume for certain stages was earshatteringly good. Did notice plenty of pink irish faces alright but no aggro. Dan Deacon even asked if there any Irish the crowd which was kinda bizzare.

    The beer ticketing system worked well I thought provided you got there early bought a good few tokens, it was such a joy not having long q’s at the bar. Also noticed, unlike Irish festivals, the respect the punters had for the site, very few sightings of drunks doing their business all over the place (I often worry about that big tree in the middle at EP). It was a nice relaxing festival.

    As for the sponsorship, doesn’t bother me in the slightest. Sure it would be nice to a few choices of beer but it’s always muck at a festival eitherway. The staff were very generous in the measurements for my other half’s gin and tonic!

    On a final note my camping days at a festival are well and truely over after this. No way I’d pay 240 + 3 days of beer and crap food for a field in Ireland. The comfort aspect to Primavera was a significant aspect to my enjoyment.

    Comment by Sean D
    21.
    June 2, 2009
    12:19 pm

    oya does look really promising,especially the location and bookings. doesn’t seem to be many irish heading ( which might be a good thing). any favourites food wise?

    I would avoid Melt jim, some of my friends were there last year and had horror stories about it, total washout last year. Line up is compelling though

    Comment by tl
    22.
    June 2, 2009
    12:23 pm

    Bobby - I’m going back to that album to hear what I missed

    Sean D - No way I’d pay 240 + 3 days of beer and crap food for a field in Ireland. The comfort aspect to Primavera was a significant aspect to my enjoyment.

    A few people commented on this to me over the weekend. I assume most people were either staying in a cheap-ish hotel or sharing apartments nearby so the cost factor was down. You could have done Primavera for the cost of an EP ticket - flight + ticket + accom for in or around €240 - and I doubt if many people will be doing both Primavera and EP this year unless they’re either working or on freebies. As punters get older too - and the Primavera crowd was a little older than what I was expecting - that comfort factor becomes more important. For all the talk about how great the line-up is at Oxegen, are people really willing to pay €199 to share a field with kids celebrating finishing their Leaving Certs?

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    23.
    June 2, 2009
    12:23 pm

    Sean D - last paragraph. Agreed. Absolutely. Also, was sitting behind Eddie Argos on my hotel’s terrace one of the days as he was being video interviewed by some English journo. Not too bad a guy, considering I hate Art Brut.
    It was quite cool to see bands knocking around all the time, getting interviewed, having drinks and just hanging out in the sun.

    Comment by adam
    24.
    June 2, 2009
    12:30 pm

    It think oxegen this year will see alot of people decide not to do the weekend camping at all and go for individual days, dublin bus service from parnell st is really good. Last year i went up and down from the city centre as the prospect of camping was far from appealing. back in town for half one and then back down again for around 3 you don’t really need to camp at oxegen. I wonder will day sales for oxegen be better in the current climate than weekend tickets? I know most of my friends are forsaking the weekend experience and only doing one day this year at oxegen

    Comment by tl
    25.
    June 2, 2009
    12:35 pm

    Instal - Glasgow
    Supersonic - Birmingham
    Colour Out of Space - Brighton
    No Fun Fest - Stockholm

    Ok they all have a pretty limited appeal but if it’s the kind of thing you’re after you can get flights tickets and hotel accomodation for under €240 if you’re organised. I’d add Roadburn too but you’d be hard stuck to get a hotel in Tilburg

    they also have plenty of sponsors too, albeit mostly arts councils and media publications and the onsite branding is limited to the FREE did you hear that irish promoters? FREE programmes.

    Comment by Bold Lump
    26.
    June 2, 2009
    12:40 pm

    joe - tallest man on earth is the business and I really like the way he seems to staring right at you no matter where you are standing in the crowd. Dude’s creepy.

    Such a massive highlight for me. In fact, as he’s never played Ireland before his name being on the bill was one of the big reasons I got on the plane to Spain, strange statement I know considering that he’s a relatively small name but the album an EP are wonderful and I’ve already seen many of the other bands that might appeal to me who were playing.

    As you said, wonderful stage presence and a great habit of eyeballing people that are there watching, it really personalises the thing I find. For me anyway one of the surefire signs that you’re at a really good festival set is how much the crowd has swelled by the end compared to the start and his was 3 or 4 times larger at the end. Great songs, fabulous guitar playing, massive voice. Leagues/Timo/et.al. should really get on the case with this guy.

    Re: Lightning Bolt, just wait til you get the chance to see them play on the floor, one of the most brutal live experiences ever. And that guy you elbowed could have been pretty much anyone there, the No Age shirt was one of the most commonly sported band T’s by punters all weekend along with the Sonic Youth “Goo” and Daniel Johnston “Hi How Are You?” album covers ones, oh and “Staff” whoever they are.

    Comment by Ian
    27.
    June 2, 2009
    12:42 pm

    **Keeping things Out Foreign, anyone heading to any of the other festivals this summer like Melt, Exit or Field Day etc?**

    Going to Field Day - amazing line-up: Errors, Fennesz, Juana Molina, Mogwai and loads more for only about 35 euro. Ridiculous.

    Sweden is expensive but Way Out West festival in Gothenburg looks tempting..MBV, Fever Ray…

    How loud was MBV’s ‘holocaust’ section at Primavera?

    Comment by Quint
    28.
    June 2, 2009
    1:00 pm

    It was my first time seeing Deerhunter who I thought were amazing.

    I’ve seen them 6 times now I think and up till now the largest room I’d seen them play was Vicar St. and everytime I’ve been up the front. On Saturday I took them in from the steps at the back and before they started I was a little worried how they’d do in such a sizable venue but fair play to them they stepped up to the big stage in some style.

    Comment by Ian
    29.
    June 2, 2009
    1:07 pm

    i’m thinking of going to bestival. bit close to EP but the line up is great

    Comment by petee
    30.
    June 2, 2009
    1:44 pm

    Phoenix have been better live than on record for as long as I can remember, with the exception of United maybe. Funky Squaredance is a guilty pleasure of mine. Last time I DJ’d it the bar manager asked me if it was Cliff Richard though. :(

    Comment by Philth
    31.
    June 2, 2009
    2:10 pm

    RE: Quint, loud enough that when I left MBV for Ponytail as they started it, I could hear it mid-song a good distance away. I didn’t hang around for it in the Auditorium either but the building was rumbling nicely as it escalated. I’d compare the volume thusly:

    Primavera Aud > Primavera Stage > Roskilde 08 > EP 09

    Comment by flynnduism
    32.
    June 2, 2009
    2:17 pm

    Incredibly few Irish at All tomorrow’s parties, which i was surprised at. Everyone went to Barca instead!

    The Breeders were the only other people on the flight home too, which was cool! (well, ok about five others).

    Comment by Morgan
    33.
    June 2, 2009
    3:57 pm

    I went to Summercase in Madrid in 2007. Had an absolutely great time at a relaxed festival free of beer-swilling idiots and mud. Much more civilized than the Irish version.

    Comment by Joanne
    34.
    June 2, 2009
    4:12 pm

    Funnily enough, the lead singer of Girls was one of the only fucked up and freaked out people at it. Saw him a few times and he never looked in good shape. Girls were pretty enjoyable though.

    Tallest Man on Earth was one of the highlights alright, as well as Neil Young, Bat For Lashes and Deerhunter.

    As far as Phoenix are concerned, I just don’t get it. Also, The Pains Of Being Pure at Heart were a huge disappointment. The sound wasn’t great and the set was way too short. The album is still charming little number though.

    Comment by P&M
    35.
    June 2, 2009
    4:37 pm

    “I know that Kurt Cobain rated them, but he also rated smack”

    I wouldn’t so much so he rated it as was devoured by it. He produced some of the best guitar pop on his way down so as put-downs go, Id say you blew both legs off just below the knee.

    Comment by Darchangel
    36.
    June 2, 2009
    5:38 pm

    Oh and did anyone else see the air guitaring toddler at Herman Dune? Cant have been more than 3 years old. By the end a large chunk of those of us watching him on the steps were applauding him by the end of each number

    Comment by Joe
    37.
    June 2, 2009
    6:49 pm

    I had a great weekend, but not as great as last year for a few reasons.

    The beer ticket machines they introduced were a nightmare on Thursday. It seemed to work better last year though this year I suppose you didn’t have to exchange thursday tickets for friday tickets and so on. Then again you were tied to your choice from the machine, no combinado if you’d gotten a beer ticket. Estrella Damm is far from the worst beer I’ve been forced to drink at a fest and the bar folks were delightfully generous with their measures.
    There was a little less variety on the food front I thought, but that was fine because I was full of riduclously good seafood by the time I arrived. Andalusian style squid, amazing! Galician octopus, razor clams, paella.. mmm

    Moving the Vice stage over the other side made it a pain getting in and out until you discovered the back entrance (stop sniggering).

    But I have to say great as the bands were individually, it lacked the variety of last year. Lots of guitar. Lots of volume, which is great. But in that quantity it would have helped to have had a bit more electronic/pop stuff, or something mellower. There was a definite hole in Friday night when it got boring. I wandered up to try and catch the Pains of Being Pure at Heart and discovered they’d just got off the stage with barely a half hour played. Throwing Muses = BLECH and I didn’t appreciate the way the timetable was laid out to make sure the two big stages got decent crowds, thus offering little choice at certain points in the evening. Saturday had too many clashes by comparison. Last year was less of a struggle, this year tired me right out.
    The Bats, The Vaselines and Yo La Tengo on Thursday was a tasty trio. Andrew Bird I liked but he struggled to hold my attention, those songs still seem so loosely assembled. Amazing voice though. Women were good, the Horrors got up my nose a little, felt like a mimicry of Alan Vega/John Cooper Clarke, not what I was looking for. Aphex Twin was pretty great, nice to end the night with that.

    Absolutely agree on Jarvis, the lyrics sound so rehashed, writing about life as he doesn’t live it, and with a sound that bores. Shellac and Spiritualized were good, Saint Etienne a lot of fun and good to hear those songs agin. Crystal Stilts I found charming, Shearwater were a lot fuller sounding than I’d expected and I enjoyed them live more than on record. What else? Basically, good but not as good as last year.

    Comment by Major Alfonso
    38.
    June 2, 2009
    7:26 pm

    **Keeping things Out Foreign, anyone heading to any of the other festivals this summer like Melt, Exit or Field Day etc?**

    There’s a really good new website called http://festivalsearcher.com that gives comprehensive listings of all European music festivals this summer.

    Full disclosure: the guy behind it is a friend of mine.

    Comment by Eoin
    39.
    June 2, 2009
    8:37 pm

    had a great time at primavera as usual. this was my third time attending.

    highlights for me were damien jurado michael nyman the mae shi shellac deerhunter neil young doing the hits squarepusher sunno(( who were nuts.

    crystal stilts were quite good as was dan deacon x12.

    looking forward to next year already.

    mcd and aiken should take a trip and learn how a festival is properly run

    Comment by derek murphy
    40.
    June 2, 2009
    8:42 pm

    Jim, I was at Melt last year and despite the really wet weather we had a blast! After the dangerous mix of mud and bold children at Oxegen 2007 we said never again and went abroad with our Euros!

    The festival is run really well, facilities are great and the beer is superb! Free Programs and timetable, its up already, http://www.melt-festival.de/programm.html, well over a month ahead of the festival too. Somehow the Picnic/Oxegen €15 festival programs dont seem to make sense… though they never did!

    It also runs pretty much 24hrs with quality bands playing well into the night and throughout the day giving you plenty of time to check out everything and send you into a bizarro twilight zone place after too many hours dancing! Attending the Picnic last September really didnt push the buttons after seeing just how things should be done!

    The line-up looks great again this year but sadly wont make it as it clashes with yer old pal Lenny!

    Comment by Dolan
    41.
    June 3, 2009
    11:35 am

    Highlights - Aphex Twin, Spiritualized, Michael Mayer, Neil Young, Deerhunter, Gang Gang Dance. Honourable mentions, MBV (both sets), Squarepusher, Vivian Girls, Plants and Animals, Black Lips, Simian Mobile Disco, A-trak, Angelo Spencer. Biggest disappointment Dan Deacon (so much better when hes not try to organise spontanaeity). Woncerfully simple festival to access, move around in, and enjoy. Great folks at it - as long as you accepted that the too school for school crowd were making their biggest effort of the year to look effortless. No problems with sponsorship when tickets are this cheap - as opposed to heavily sponsored Irish festivals and expensive tickets. Sound at every stage was perfect - why cant Irish festival sound quality manage this? Stayed at the bottom of the hill in Diagonal Zero for

    Comment by sponger
    42.
    June 3, 2009
    1:31 pm

    What about Jason Lylte. He was good despite using borrowed equipment…….

    Comment by hey_ho_let's_go!
    43.
    June 3, 2009
    5:53 pm

    jason Lylte was good I thought, got the new stuff / grandaddy ratio just right

    thought th’faith healers were absolutely magnificent, haven’t enjoyed a new (in the sense I hadnt heard of them till a month ago) band in ages. stonking

    the bug were class too,

    Comment by ronan from corksongs
    44.
    June 4, 2009
    10:42 am

    really enjoyed the festival despite a couple of bad experiences. Andrew Bird was incredible as were MBV, Neil Young and The Bad Plus

    The Auditori is a venue I would buy tickets for in a heartbeat to see any band play

    If you’re bothered Jim I have written a couple of things on my own blog

    Comment by G-Man
    45.
    June 4, 2009
    4:05 pm

    “Aphex Twin and My Bloody Valentine both played the “hits”. ”

    what?what are you on about? what kind of a sentence is that? is that analysis?

    Comment by daniel harrison
    46.
    June 4, 2009
    4:46 pm

    45. i dont think it was derogatory daniel. MBV were bloody amazing but they did play their most well known tracks as did Aphex Twin and i was well glad that they did. sure so did neil young which was all the better

    Comment by G-Man
    47.
    June 4, 2009
    7:35 pm

    daniel - It’s a sentence with 10 words in it. Where exactly do i say above that i’m providing “analysis” on the festival? Dismount that high horse before he bucks you off.

    Comment by Jim Carroll
    48.
    June 5, 2009
    2:45 pm

    sorry jim. post probably sounded a lot more belligerent than intended. but the idea of MBV having anything approaching a hit just sounds a bit absurd. i would say, however, that it was almost a carbon copy of the set they played at the Electric Picnic last year, which was an ever so slight disappointment.
    again, apologies for the post, i’m prone to the odd comment-board faux pas.

    Comment by daniel harrison

    Leave a comment


    • (will not be published)


Search On The Record

 
Close
E-mail It