Irish Roots »

  • The last ‘Irish Roots’

    February 8, 2016 @ 9:53 am | by John Grenham

    The “Irish Roots” column began on February 28th, 2009, almost exactly seven years ago. This is the last one.

    Looking back over that period, the blink of a gnat’s eye in genealogical terms, there is no doubt that a revolution in access to records has taken place, one that in Ireland is quite peculiar.

    Back then, genealogy in other English-speaking countries – Australia, the US, the UK – was already becoming web-centric, researchers having long realised what a marriage made in heaven existed between family history data and computers. In those places, genealogy was already commercial and quickly underwent the same process of globalising merger and acquisition that the internet seems to force on all businesses. Giant global oligopolies are the result: MyHeritage, FindMyPast, Ancestry.

    Here in Ireland we did things differently. The first attempt to harness genealogy for tourism was a complete organisational dog’s dinner, with heritage centres, county libraries, local community groups and many others yoked together in a project that was part-genealogy, part-community employment, part parish-pump political stroke. But it produced a result: rootsireland.ie, still the only essential Irish genealogy website.

    Ad-haughery [sic] like this became the main feature of most Irish online record projects. One individual or institution would take on a project and carry it over the finish line: the National Archives census site; the Library Council’s Griffith’s site; the National Library’s parish registers site; Arts, Tourism and the Gaeltacht’s church and civil records site.

    All (including rootsireland) were motivated by a straightforward desire to serve the Irish public, which in later years also came to mean all those worldwide who claimed Irish roots. The result is that Irish research is now less commercial, more open, a bit messier but, above all, much easier than in any of those places that started before us.

    It’s a very unIrish thing to say, but we’ve been lucky. And we’ll meet again down the road, with a little more luck.

  • Who makes a living from genealogy in Ireland?

    February 1, 2016 @ 8:43 am | by John Grenham

    Making a living from genealogy isn’t easy in Ireland. There is no career path, very few employers and lots of competition. But many people involved in family history want to do nothing else, meaning there are quite a few groups and individuals who do use it to try to earn a crust.

    Accredited Genealogists Ireland (accreditedgenealogists.ie), of which I am a member, is a standards body aiming to provide potential research clients with security about the quality of commissioned research, and some collegiality for individuals involved in the field.

    Eneclann (eneclann.ie) is a long-established company providing high-quality research and archival services. It employs a small number of researchers.

    ProGenealgists (progenealogists.com) is an American company affiliated with Ancestry.com that provides research mainly to North Americans. They have recently taken on a small number of Irish genealogists in Dublin.

    Ancestor Network (ancestornetwork.ie) is a company based in south Dublin that uses a group of part-time researchers, most of them connected to the Genealogical Society of Ireland (familyhistory.ie).

    There are many individuals offering themselves for research. The National Library keeps an unvetted list, which is the first step for most people trying to get into the field. See: tinyurl.com/zx49cbv

    As for courses that lead to qualifications, the field is thin.

    UCC runs a two-year part-time adult education course in Cork (goo.gl/dG3rNe) that leads to an NFQ level 7 qualification, the equivalent of an ordinary-level primary degree.

    The University of Limerick runs a masters in the history of the family – goo.gl/fUJylN – which is as much sociology as family history, I think.

    Seán Murphy used to deliver a well-regarded three-year certificate course in UCD, but that has been discontinued. He is now running courses other than the Certificate: goo.gl/i8Qo4l.

    City Colleges in Dublin (citycolleges.ie) has a 10-week intensive course that aims to provide a detailed overview of sources and methods. I deliver these courses, and the next one starts on February 11th. Roll up, roll up.

  • The Revolution Papers is a work of genius

    January 25, 2016 @ 7:59 am | by John Grenham

    Anyone who has done research in newspapers knows that eventually you drift away from the research and just end up reading the paper. Whether it’s The Dublin Courier of 1761 or the Evening Press of 1961, there is a hypnotic fascination in the minutiae of day-to-day news seen through the wrong end of the telescope. “Little did they know what was just about to happen …” – hindsight provides irresistible dramatic irony. And perhaps we can sense how trivial or quaint our own worries will appear to future readers.

    So the idea of publishing facsimile copies of newspapers from periods of dramatic historical change is genius. The Revolution Papers (therevolutionpapers.ie) hits the bulls-eye. It sensibly condenses the seven years of the Irish revolution, 1916 to 1923, into 52 weekly instalments, that build into a temptingly collectible home-made archive. The print quality is superb. The cover art is excellent. Each comes with an original, succinct scholarly article on a specific aspect of the period.

    My initial reaction was that the whole thing seemed suspiciously well done, a little un-I rish even. Where was the PR blitz from the usual suspects? The high-visibility launch with political ribbon-cutting? And how could they afford TV ads voiced by Pat Kenny, for God’s sake?

    A little research shows that the venture is resolutely private-sector, produced by Albertas, a London-based, Irish-run company that already has similar very successful projects under its belt. In France it publishes Les journeaux de guerre (1939-1945), and in Germany Zeitungszeugen (“Newspapers as witness” 1933-1945).

    The Irish version deserves to be a runaway success; it is the best piece of popular history publishing this country has seen for many years.

    The company’s hair-raising experiences in Germany are salutary. For daring to reproduce Nazi-era newspapers, they were (ludicrously) sued by the state of Bavaria for infringing Hitler’s copyright and (even more ludicrously) prosecuted for disseminating Nazi propaganda. Common sense has since prevailed.

  • Digging up death records

    January 18, 2016 @ 9:33 am | by John Grenham

    Researchers from places such as Australia and Scotland, where death registers can give wonderful multi-generational family information, are continually disappointed by the Irish equivalents. Until recently, a death record here supplied no family information. As a result, headstone transcripts and cemetery registers have become disproportionately important.

    The biggest single online collection of transcripts is at interment.net, a volunteer US site. The records of some cemeteries are frustratingly incomplete and some transcripts may not be completely accurate, but the site is free, well organised and includes Irish cemeteries in every county except Waterford and Monaghan. Another US site, findagrave.com, has a huge number of volunteer transcripts, including (it claims) some from 3401 Irish cemeteries. Most of these appear to consist of one of two transcripts, however.

    The largest Irish site is the venerable historyfromheadstones.com, which covers more than 800 Northern Ireland graveyards. The site is paying, but the index search is free and there are some interesting essays on topics such as child mortality and military service.

    Brian and Ian Cantwell’s extraordinary set of transcripts from Wicklow, Wexford and the Atlantic seaboard are at FindMyPast.ie, also paying. Free Irish transcript sites include historicgraves.com, discovereverafter.com, from-ireland.net, IrishGraveyards.ie and igp-web.com. All cover slightly different areas, some include headstone images, most are not full.

    I try to keep track at irishtimes.com/ancestor, God help me.

    Cemetery records can be much more informative than gravestones, sometimes recording names, addresses and next of kin. Before local authorities acquired responsibility for graveyards in the 1890s, the only surviving registers are for urban areas. More than a million records of Goldenbridge and Glasnevin cemeteries in Dublin, dating from the 1820s, are searchable on the paying site glasnevintrust.ie, an essential resource for 19th-century Catholic Dubliners. The Church of Ireland equivalent, Mount Jerome, is not online, but a microfilm of their registers is available in Dublin City Library and Archive. A paying sub-site of belfastcity.gov.uk has about 360,000 Belfast burials. Mount St Lawrence graveyard in Limerick city has records from 1855, freely searchable at limerick.ie/archives.

  • Why genealogy is seasonal

    January 11, 2016 @ 9:58 am | by John Grenham

    Strange as it may seem, genealogy is a seasonal affair. There are uncomplicated reasons why family history should be of interest to particular groups – older people, for example, or descendants, or emigrants cut off from the wider family. But why should a specific time of year bring out the desire to look up your ancestors?

    And if there is going to be to be a rise in awareness of Irish family roots at a definite period, you might imagine it would happen around St Patrick’s Day. But no, the biggest upsurge of interest in family history research and all things related begins as regular as clockwork every year at the end of December. Immediately after Christmas, traffic to genealogical websites spikes and for five or six weeks thereafter the number of research inquiries and of visitors to archives and libraries grows and grows.

    Why? What is it about Christmas that drives people to research their ancestors? It is not hard to imagine someone locked up with their family for three days emerging with the burning question, “How in the name of God am I related to these people?”

    But the reasons are probably simpler. For all the commercialisation, Christmas is really the only fixed point in our year when families are more or less obliged to gather. Inevitably family talk across generations will touch on the common past, an elderly aunt will intrigue someone with unknown names and places, and the spark of research will ignite.

    Before the internet, this post-Christmas rush to genealogy was less visible, simply because research used to take much longer. So we saw only a general increase in interest spread over early spring. But when traffic to a genealogy site quadruples over 48 hours, the same 48 hours year year-in year-out, it becomes crystal clear that Christmas is the spur.

  • Free-range, grass-fed Irish genealogy

    January 4, 2016 @ 10:03 am | by John Grenham

    Tourism authorities have long hoped to use genealogy as an incentive to attract more visitors to Ireland and have long complained of the fragmentation of online Irish records. “If only they were all on a single easy website – every Irish-American in Kansas would find their ancestors and come over to visit them.”

    No, sorry, wait. That was me, not just tourism bosses. One of the many bees in my bonnet used to be the plethora of Irish record sites, all with different search interfaces, many of them covering the same records: The General Register Office indexes on FindMyPast, Ancestry.com, FamilySearch, IrishGenealogy; Griffith’s on Askaboutireland, FindMyPast, Rootsireland; Gravestones on interment.net, FindMyPast, historicgraves.com, irishgraveyards.ie, discovereverafter.com; secular burial records on databases.dublincity.ie, kerrylaburials, glasnevintrust.ie, corkarchives.ie

    I could go on.

    Some put the surname search box first, others the forename box. Some use surname and forename variants, some have surname variants only, others have no variants at all. There are free ones, subscription-only ones, some pay-per-view, some mixing all three.

    No wonder the poor Kansans are confused. Just bring everything inside a single site, under a single organisation, make it all searchable by a five-year-old and bingo, tourism nirvana.

    But the revolution in Irish online research that has happened in the last five or six years just wouldn’t have worked under a single organisation. The Irish National Genealogical Management Enterprise – “INAGME”? I don’t think so. Ireland is just not a one-ring-to-rule-them-all kind of place. The revolution happened because particular organisations and individuals flung themselves at it, without any overall plan or risk/benefit decisions, with plenty of bitter rows and committee wars. It happened the Irish way, in other words.

    As for Joe Kowalski-Magrath in Kansas; well, the internet is falling over with guides to Irish research, because Irish research is now almost laughably simple. It’s called research because it involves some searching, Joe.

  • Hiding from Big History

    December 30, 2015 @ 10:13 am | by John Grenham

    We genealogists spend our time hiding from Big History, convinced in our hearts that small personal experiences are the real core of history. Because it’s always good therapy to stretch unused muscles, I’ve spent the past six months reading Brendan Simm’s whopping Europe: The Struggle for Supremacy, 1453 to the Present (Allen Lane, 2013).

    It’s taken six months because it’s impossible to absorb more than a dozen pages at a time. The level of detail and the breadth of overview are jaw-dropping. But it is a very particular overview. This is a history of statecraft, the way Louis XIV understood his world, with the interlocking endless consequences of diplomacy, treaties and wars. Simms masters it all as if it were a single, endlessly fascinating Rubik cube.

    Two big ideas shape the book. First, states’ foreign policy decisions have deep unacknowledged impacts on what appear to be purely internal events: the American Revolution is analysed as a by-product of European big-power manoeuvring, for instance. And second, it’s all about Germany. Every significant event since 1453 has revolved around the question of German power, whether as the Holy Roman Empire, the “German Lands” or the modern German state.

    At times, the evidence is stretched a bit thin to fit these theses, but it’s still an extraordinary achievement and I’m exhausted.

    So what does Simms (an Irishman) have to say about Ireland?

    Not much. Like it or not, on his telling we’re well removed from almost every world-historical event, an island off an island off the mainland. All the great upheavals of European history have ended as gentle ripples on our shores: the last incident of world significance to happen here was in 1690, when the Dutch beat the French at the Battle of the Boyne.

    Patrick Kavanagh knew this when he wrote “Epic”, his lyric paean to parochialism, in which we “make our own importance”. Because if we don’t, nobody else will.

  • Begrudgery

    December 23, 2015 @ 9:36 am | by John Grenham

    The recent ructions about stratospheric salaries in the Irish Farmers’ Association had some commentators reaching for the B-word. So, as usual when in doubt, I consulted the Oxford English Dictionary, and there was “begrudgery”, missing. “Begrudge” and “begrudger” are certainly present (though “Now chiefly Irish English”), but not the place or state of simmering resentment described by the B-word.

    So I tried Google. Surprise: every single occurrence of “begrudgery” is in Ireland.

    So it is exclusively Irish, which clearly means something about the national psyche. But what? That it’s easy to begrudge once, but you have to be Irish to live the begrudging life? Is it yet another demonstration of what small-minded bosthoons we are?

    I don’t think so. Irish begrudgery is very particular. It is not the Japanese variety which demands that sticky-out nails get hammered down. What we have is a very specific kind of scepticism, more irreverence than envy. It is the reason behind Article 40.2.1 of the Constitution: “Titles of nobility shall not be conferred by the State”. Or in the more succinct words of Brendán Ó hEithir’s blacksmith: “We will in our arse have our own gentry”.

    Begrudgery, strangely, is the quality that allows Bono to walk up Grafton Street unmolested or a former Minister of Education to cycle his Dublin Bike the wrong way down Trinity Street (I saw him) without anyone batting an eyelid. It is peasant anger at inequality, egalitarianism in its raw, uncooked state, and worth more respect than it usually gets.

    In Ireland, you can be as different as you want, once you recognise you’re no better than the rest of us.

    If it’s any consolation to the IFA, I suspect the trait may be very deeply rooted. The Neolithic Irish trussed up their kings, slaughtered them and buried the bodies in the bog. We’re only in the halfpenny place today.

  • The centre of the Irish family history universe

    December 14, 2015 @ 6:32 pm | by John Grenham

    There’s only one Irish genealogy website that I visit every day, and that’s irishgenealogynews.com. It was started by Claire Santry in 2010 and since then has become the centre of the universe – the compact but perfectly-formed universe of Irish family history, that is.

    If you’re interested in new online record releases, public talks, new publications, special offers from subscription sites, changes to repository opening time – in fact anything at all that connects to Irish genealogy anywhere in the world – Claire’s site is indispensable.

    How did it get to this position? The most important factor, I think, is that Claire is a professional journalist by training. The site presents facts clearly and coherently, without frills, paddywhackery or opinions, its easily readable text laid out around interesting illustrations that bristle with useful links.

    She is, it goes without saying, a genealogy nut, but runs the site as a full-time job, sometimes posting five items a day, all hard fact. On several occasions she has scooped me on the launch of sites I developed, an illustration of just how hard she works and what a nose she has for a story.

    And the site has no agenda, an extraordinary quality in a field buzzing with the unmistakable sound of axes being ground.

    Which doesn’t mean it has no power. A rumbling spat between various people involved in Irish genealogy – thumbscrews wouldn’t get names out of me – was threatening to turn nasty earlier this year. Claire wagged one elegant finger at the participants and peace broke out at once.

    She has received recognition of sorts: she came first in the Irish section of the tongue-in-cheek “Rockstar Genealogist” awards this year. But for an income the site depends on the ads peppered discreetly here and there. So turn off that ad-blocker now.

  • John O’Donovan’s glorious letters

    December 7, 2015 @ 9:30 am | by John Grenham

    The same upgrade that put the Valuation Office revision maps on the askaboutireland.ie site (see last week’s column) also added the Ordnance Survey Field Name Books and the O’Donovan topographical letters. The former are parish-by-parish alphabetical listings of the place-names that were to become the standardised English versions on the first Ordnance Survey six-inch maps in the 1830s. The entries include much technical detail linking them to the maps, but also some worm’s-eye-view descriptions of rents, landlords and tenants.

    The O’Donovan letters are of broader interest. They consist of formal correspondence addressed to, or from, the man in charge of the Ordnance Survey topographical department, the antiquarian John O’Donovan, and often provide superb summaries of local place-name lore, even down to the minutest detail: the entry for Darver in Co Louth includes a description and drawing of “a silver ring which Mr Duffy found near his house”. For anyone interested in local history in rural Ireland they are a magnificent treasure trove. And they give the lie to the notion that the OS process of standardisation and anglicisation was brutal, Anglo-Saxon and stupid.

    The versions on the site are typescript copies of the originals made in the 1920s. I’m not sure (nor, I think, is askaboutireland.ie) that all of them are here. Certainly, the six counties of Northern Ireland are missing. And it has to be said that there are drawbacks to having them broken up and plotted as links on the maps.

    But they are also browsable page by page, revealing all their gnarled glory, with folk-tales, principal families, ruined churches, annal entries, saint’s biographies and more.

    The voice of O’Donovan himself is also there, and strangely modern. At the conclusion of the second volume of Galway letters, he writes: “I have now done with the territories in the county of Galway and though it has cost me many an hour of severe application to lay down their boundaries I fear no one will have the patience to grope their way through my lucubrations.”

    He needn’t have worried.

Next Page »