• RSS
  • Text Size:
  • -
  • irishtimes.com - Posted: January 24, 2012 @ 9:30 am

    Why, Irish Times, why? On fashion and related fripperies

    Rosemary Mac Cabe

    Image via Scotch & Soda

    Yesterday I received a comment by a young chap named Ronan* asking the above question in relation to this post on earworms. Though he may have been referring to my somewhat questionable music taste, it was the tone that struck me – the kind of “Lord, haven’t you got anything better to talk about?” thinking that pervades a lot of men’s – and women’s – thinking on fashion and what they may deem the “frothier” parts of life.

    It’s not a unique attitude; nor is it rare, and it’s something that baffles me more than I know quite how to express. Fashion is – and here is the first of many generalisations you are likely to hear today – at its most basic, a hobby. It’s a hobby that is enjoyed – and here’s another – in the main by women, and it is no small coincidence that it is a hobby that is derided, demeaned and belittled. I don’t see, for example, the guys on the motors blog having to defend their “hobby” to people who say things like “why, Irish Times, why?” or “do you even know there’s a recession?” or “honestly, have you nothing else to worry about?” and so on (and so forth).

    On a business note, fashion is a multi-million euro industry employing thousands of people here and abroad, providing jobs, generating revenue for governments and countries and individuals – some, granted, more than others – and one that, whether it interests you or not, definitely matters. And that’s not even getting into the philosophical aspects of what fashion means to us as humans.

    I could recommend a long reading list but, really, I feel that the naysayers should do their own research. So, from now on, I won’t be moderating any comments that accuse me of being vacuous merely for liking fashion. (If you’re accusing me of being vacuous for liking Hart of Dixie, on the other hand, I’m sure I’ll cope.)

    * Folks, don’t hate Ronan for asking the question. I’m sure young Ronan is an upstanding chap with his heart in the right place and excellent taste in Irish fashion blogs.

  • 11 Comments »

    1.
    January 24, 2012
    10:10 am

    BEAUTIFULLY PUT.

    Comment by Louise McSharry
    2.
    January 24, 2012
    11:29 am

    *applauds*
    I’m just gonna direct people to this when they ask WHY I get excited by fashion-related bits & pieces.

    Also, I don’t understand why people comment on things they’ve no interest in if it’s just to say they have no interest…have they got nothing better to do?! Not hatin’ on Ronan, maybe he does just hate the song, but i’ve seen a few comments here & on other blogs amounting to that.

    Comment by Cat
    3.
    January 24, 2012
    11:35 am

    Hear hear Rosemary!
    I have also noticed that fashion is the only hobby I have that I feel I have ever had to defend in some way. No one accuses you of being “vacuous” if you take an interest in any other creative media. If I bought a painting,a book, or a even a music album, no one would say:” Don’t you know there’s a recession on? Haven’t you anything better to do with your time?” to the extent that they would if you were seen perusing Vogue magazine.

    Comment by Maire
    4.
    January 24, 2012
    12:12 pm

    New Hart of Dixie time!!! i’m glad theres no judgement here
    http://www.sidereel.com/hart_of_dixie/season-1/episode-11/search

    Comment by ena
    5.
    January 24, 2012
    12:41 pm

    A fashion blog talking about fashion? During a recession?! Who ever thought this should be allowed?

    Well, I, for one. I love reading the blog, and looking at the lookbooks that come up, even if I know I can’t afford some of/most of/any of it.

    Keep writing, Rosemary, and i will keep reading.

    Comment by Robyn
    6.
    January 24, 2012
    12:54 pm

    Well said!! Very well said!!

    Comment by Anna
    7.
    January 24, 2012
    3:22 pm

    Extremely well said Rosemary! Fashion is just an interest at the end of the day, and nobody has the right to be getting judgemental about it.

    I really enjoy reading your posts by the way!

    Comment by Bernadette
    8.
    January 25, 2012
    10:59 am

    Thanks Rosemary for defending all of us who put time and effort into something that others find to be a complete waste of time! love it!

    Comment by Fashion Stylist_ka
    9.
    January 25, 2012
    6:12 pm

    I think people sometimes confuse a love of fashion with narcissism, vanity and the negative aspects of the industry, i.e. creating unrealistic stereotypes for females, underweight models etc. However, I think the majority of people who are interested in fashion see it as a form of art, and we admire the beautiful colours, shapes, materials, moods and images that fashion creates.

    This confused thinking could of course be applied to other hobbies, like in the example above, motors. If we watched Top Gear, we would see Jeremy Clarkson and co driving fabulous cars around the track at break neck speeds. For most people, this is fun to watch and they admire a V8, turbo charged, beautiful piece of engineering in motion, but they are not going to go out and buy themselves a 1 million pound car or drive around at dangerous speeds.

    Similarly, the majority of fashion fans are not going to go out and buy vintage Chanel for thousands of euro or lose dangerous amounts of weight. We are all simply admiring what we perceive to be a beautiful piece of art.

    So whether it is a Bugatti Veyron or a Burberry trench…. can’t we all just get along!

    Comment by Kate
    10.
    January 26, 2012
    6:50 am

    Breaking lurker status to applaud this post. You’re right, Rosemary, fashion is an unfairly judged hobby. I particularly enjoy it because it’s a creative interest that I can indulge in every day while going about my routine rather than having to wait for free time. I don’t understand why many people miss that connection.

    Comment by Jennie
    11.
    January 27, 2012
    8:33 pm

    Thank you! Thank you!

    You know, this post really comes as a sign, because lately I’ve been feeling really bad. I’m a journalist, and currently working in a part time job at the foreign desk of the biggest daily newspaper in our country. I also studied international relations at the university, so until now I was completely sure, that international journalism is the ONE for me.
    But lately I’ve been leaning towards fashion, and thinking about linking journalism and fashion in some way – although I did some research and sadly the hungarian fashion newspapers’ standards are really low, and I don’t see myself as a person who’d gave her name to one of these articles (but I don’t want to be a blogger either, because fashion bloggers are not that much important in hungary and definitely not something you can build a living on).
    Anyway, this post (similar to Miranda Priestly’s speech in The Devil Wears Prada about the billion dollar industry) felt really good, because – although, I still think that foreign policy is still more important than fashion :] – at least I don’t feel that bad anymore about this HOBBY, which I start to care really strongly for (and definitely gonna do something about it!).

    And btw, Hart of Dixie is my guilty pleasure too :]

    Comment by rabbityork

    Leave a comment

    When submitted, your comment will be moderated and, once approved, will appear on the site.

    The Irish Times reserves the absolute right not to publish comments.


Search Fash Mob