Martin, Fianna Fáil and the toxic brand
Eoin Burke Kennedy
Can you imagine being at the helm of a major corporation, tasked with selling its brand in multiple markets albeit with one proviso: you can’t refer to it, at least not directly.
Essentially, this is the predicament Micheál Martin finds himself in.
In Monday’s televised debate, the Fianna Fáil leader defended his party’s policies in typically combative style, unleashing a few well-aimed salvos at opponents along the way.
For the 93 minutes he was on his feet, he never once mentioned the words Fianna Fáil.
The brand is now so toxic that even its leader, the commander and chief, dare not speak its name. The party’s logo on some of its election posters is so small that it’s almost impossible to discern from a distance. Even the Facebook and Twitter logos are on average bigger than the party’s. In Wednesday night’s TG4 debate, Martin was similarly ill-disposed to make direct references to the party.
The Fianna Fáil is being advised by US political consultant Tad Devine, a strong exponent of the principle: “you never mention the contaminated product”.
Doubtless, the tactic is to distance the candidates from the party’s past, no mean feat when you’ve been in government for 17 of the last 20 years.
Martin’s constant mantra about a fresh approach to politics and his strong stance on Dáil reform signal his desire to break with the party’s tarnished legacy.
However, the problem for Martin and Fianna Fáil is that they cannot escape their responsibility for so much of what went wrong. Party insiders quietly concede that there is little Fianna Fáil can do to avoid the imminent electoral bloodbath.
John Fanning, who lectures in branding and marketing communications at Smurfit Business School, believes Martin will not be in position to embark on a “New Labour-like” rebranding process until after the election when he will have freehand to appoint his own shadow cabinet and voter anger at this administration subsides somewhat.
The fact that the party is not spending money on a national advertising campaign is proof, if proof were needed, that it has already “ceded defeat”, he says.
“What Martin is doing is running a campaign to minimise seat losses and to position Fianna Fáil to make some kind of respectable showing at next election [in five years time]. It’s a damage limitation exercise.”
Despite the dramatic collapse in support, Fanning believes the party is still the most professionally run vote-getting organisation in the country. “There’s no reason to suggest that a lot of the expertise is not still there.”
A party in its position has little alternative but to target a select number of seats where it has done well previously and push aspect of the candidates’ personality or record that still sells, says Fanning.
“They’re better off spending money on market research in these constituencies where they do have a chance of holding seats rather than on a national campaign,” he says.
A well-placed insider said Martin was taking what he described as the bad dog approach; he’s eaten his master’s slippers and knows he has to go out into the back garden for a couple of years.
“There’s no point in Fianna Fáil buying into a big brand concept to communicate with the electorate because they know they’re screwed and it would only be a waste of money.”
In contrast, Fine Gael is running a national advertising campaign under the rather bland slogan “Let’s Get Ireland Working” which has a faint echo of the famous Saatchi & Saatchi Tory campaign slogan “Labour’s Not Working”.
Because of the well-publicised problems with selling Kenny as a future taoiseach to the electorate, the party is promoting him as the chairman, fronted by a team of heavy-hitters like Varadkar, Noonan and Bruton.
One individual, who worked on the party’s campaign, said there was nothing new in Fine Gael’s strategy as it has struggled in the past to get its leaders to be viewed as taoiseach material.
“John Bruton was widely criticised before he got in and was subsequently seen to have done a good job. Kenny may be on a similar trajectory,” he suggested.
“It is not unusual for Fine Gael to have a leader who doesn’t set the world on fire before he gets in but ends up doing a competent job when he does.”
He cites Brian Farrell’s famous book, Chairman or Chief: The role of the Taoiseach in Irish government, saying Fianna Fáil tend to go for chiefs while Fine Gael tend to opt for consensus building chairmen.
Several observers said it was a testament to Kenny’s abilities that barely a year after a divisive assault on his leadership, he was fronting a united team which stands on the brink of election victory.
In contrast to Fine Gael, Labour’s campaign has been focused solely around Eamon Gilmore, reflecting the leader’s strong standing in polls.
However, critics have claimed the “Gilmore For Taoiseach” slogan has not resonated with voters.
One party insider conceded the campaign was having more success in Dublin than elsewhere. He said each of the three main parties was “very deliberately” playing to their strengths, with Fine Gael projecting a strong team image in contrast to Labour and Fianna Fáil who remain focused on the attributes of their “charismatic” leaders.
Election posters, he said, have as much to do with the morale of the troops as they have with persuading voters.
“Of course, they’re about getting candidates into the minds of voters but they’re also about reassuring activists that the party believes in itself. The day you are ashamed of your brand is the day you are losing,” he said.


This morning I found a leaflet in my door from Brian Lenihan’s running mate in Dublin West, Cllr David McGuinness. It was printed on Fingal County Council paper and was ostensibly an update on what’s going on in the area (look! we’re *finallly* talking about building the school “testament to the community groups, residents association, school authorities and Brian Lenihan TD..”).
No mention of Fianna Fail except in a tiny footnote and along the side indicating that McGuinness is from Fianna Fail.
Talk about trying to hide.
FF let it sink in the ditch, where Collins was killed.
An elderly FF footsoldier arrived on my doorstep in Dublin 17 in an attempt to extricate a first prefrence vote for the latest celtic tigre offspring of the FF GENE POOL.Because of the ladies age I wanted to be polite,however this was quickly put to the test as this octogenarian trotted out glib promises and the prospect of a bright new future with the all new FF,represented today by her candidate.At this the candidate,all sweetness and light “tip toed” up my pathway and trotted out empty rhetoric as though from an invisible autoque,she was like the best girl in the class with all the answers for the teacher.They havent changed they have become Royalty aloof and detached from the people of this troubled weary land.I JUST CLOSED THE DOOR.
Perhaps it was my Dublin 17 addresse, theyd done the demographics and believed that everyone around these parts are just stupid
I’ve written to some FF candidates that seem to be trying hardest to hide the FF brand.
I’ve asked them why they expect the voters to have faith in a party that they don’t themselves have faith in.
I’ve asked them why anyone should vote for a candidate that is cowardly enough to feel they need the party machine, but too cowardly to openly acknowledge the party that they are a member of.
Needless to say….No Replies.
In a world gone mad the only thing keeping Fianna Fail from utter decimation is Micheal Martin who appears like a man of the people. However they will rue the manner in which they treated this country, and its citizens, like their own personal fiefdom. And rightly they will be virtually destroyed
A new Ireland needs to rise like a phoenix from the ashes of this disaster. Let’s all pull together under our new government and show ourselves and the world once again what it is to be Irish. But let us do it with honesty, integrity and proper leadership this time.
A canvasser from Fianna Fail called around to my door on Wednesday evening. Firstly he had to put up with my (admittedly territorial and grumpy) barking at him before I opened the door. He asked me for my first preference and I said “No. Never”. When he asked “why”, I told him that Fianna Fail stood against everything I believe in…
I’m not a member of any party and would consider myself a moderate, but damn that was satisfying.
FF are out of favour now. No one likes them because of what they have “done”, or failed to do.
But this recession will bite in the next 4 years.
Who ever takes over the reigns holds a poisioned chalice. Nothing they do or implent will change that fact. Things are going to get worse before they get better. The Economy will dictate that. Not our Economy, but the greater Global Economy.
Ireland has no voice in Europe, other then a begging one. We have no influence.
We are a pebble in a stream along for the ride.
FF will be out this year, but back in 4 years time. People will have forgotten about the issues they have with them now. There will be much greater issues in 4 years time.
“At least with FF at the helm we only had 14% unemployment”, will be what they will be saying when people go to vote in 4 years time.
The TV debates at this juncture are purely academic. The only subject worth discussing is whether the Fianna Fail Party should be proscribed and banned from Irish politics forever for what they have done to the people and the Nation. All the sacrifices which have been made down through the years to assert our independence have now been negated. Fianna Fail have created a puppet (Ireland) and the puppeteers live in Washington, London, Paris and Berlin. These will shape our policies into the future whether we like it or not.
It’s fascinating watching this election from a real republic (even wih Sarkozy in charge). It has taken all this time for the Irish electorate to realise the toxic nature of Fianna Fail. Remember it was their leader who sent the draft of our constitution to the Vatican for evaluation. Dev then sent back the revised version when that lot objected to some of its contents. Wak up, it’s time for a Govrnment of the people.
I disagree with the premise that Ireland has no voice in Europe. It’s a small voice, but with a potentially big impact. The one trump card Ireland can play is the survival of the Euro. The ECB may be in the pocket of the large German and French banks, but when Ireland defaults on the bailout (and it will unless the agreement is substantially altered), it will bring down the Euro, bring down sixty-plus years of work towards European integration. Politically, this would be untenable both in Berlin, Paris and Brussels: they can’t afford to let Ireland fail. Not politically or economically.
Charisma – ugh! When are people going to get over celebrity-charisma and realize that you’re trying to run a democracy and do not need princes who are hot or blessed by a special ordination from heaven? Distrust charisma!
As a proud supporter of Fianna Fail albeit one who will not be able to vote n this election I grow weary of the constant immature and often anonymous vitriol being distributed in the media. This comments page is an obvious example with insightful comments from the likes of “Mickey Mouse”.
Fortunately Ireland has had one strong party of national leaders throughout it’s short history and although they will be quiet during the next governmental interregnum, as the looney left take the reins for a time it should not be long before Irish businesses and those who value personal wealth and freedom see sense.
The self deserving culture prevailing in Ireland at the moment is as toxic an asset as the country has ever had. Constant government handouts devalue the very notion of enterprise and wealth creation which has built our and many other successful nations.
A rising tide in the past was said to have lifted all higher on the socioeconomic ladder. Why is it now that people seem to expect all to sink as fast as everyone else. Would it not be better to have tax incentives to allow those with the means to grow strong so that in future we still have business people employers and wealthy tax payers available to nurture our ever weakening economy.
Lets not focus on the pandering to economic sob stories but try to objectively analyze the policies from the likes of Labour and Sinn Fein who with their policies will make us economic pariahs to international and domestic businesses.
The world is a big place and there are oodles of jobs to be had if people are willing to forgoe some creature comforts. Australia for example is crying out for skilled tradespeople in their mining industry. Would it not be better for people in difficult positions to do what other generations of people have had to do- work abroad and then return to Ireland if and when the time is right. Alternatively stick around bemoaning one’s failed investments, negative equity and over spending and ask for a government hand out, “How they they let this happen- I’ll vote for the crazies”.
Fianna Fail will be back the brand has not gone away. It’s core principles are strong and will remain so. Good luck to Micheal Martin and the rest of the team.
Had Finn Gail or Labour done anything different, if they were in power? If you see the pevious debates in the Dail and RTE Prime Time over last 10 years, you will realise; how these fellows were willing to push us one step more on same disastrous path on which Fianna Fail led. If these parties can dissociate themselves from what happned over that period, why not Michael Martin. In fact, he is more sensible than the others and has learnt from his failures. I’ll still vote for him.
Is Fianna Fail a product, a brand which adapts to the whims of focus groups or a political party that is supposed to defend the interests of the people and implement policy that benefits current and future generations?
Politicians and political parties are also not a political class of their own, somehow removed from society, they are drawn from society, it is the citizens of the Republic that bestow the right of others to govern for them, nor do these people come to power, they come into political office.
Think we have to be very careful with the language we use, because democracy is in danger of getting lost in totalitarian double-talk.